CHRISTIANITY says im going to hell? i can never be saved?

Canada
June 17, 2007 7:17pm CST
i just read something thats pretty scary (if i was a believer). Jesus forgives everyone for everything, he even forgives those who doubt him. however, there is one exception. you are not forgiven to even doubt the holy spirit for one second, which i believe everyone has/will in the course of their lifetime. this is in A)LUKE 12:10 and B)MARK 3:29. A)"If a person says something against the Son of Man, he can be forgiven. But a person refuses to accept the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven. B)But whoever curses the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven. He is guilty of an everlasting sin. so there you go, i cant be saved, its done, its over, im out. could this really be the case?
18 people like this
41 responses
@suspenseful (40193)
• Canada
18 Jun 07
Actually if you do not say that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh, and deny that Jesus Christ is the son of God, you will not be saved. So if someone said that he did not like Joseph and Mary's son, Jesus because he was too busy talking when he should have been working as a carpenter, that is saying something against the son of man. However if you deny there is such a thing as the Holy Spirit you are guilty. You see, there are three in the Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit (or Ghost in older translations.) and if you deny that the Holy Spirit comes from God, and that God sent Jesus on Earth to save us from our sins, you are guilty. And Jesus does not forgive everyone for everything. He forgives those HE has chosen and if you are in that lot, you will be forgiven, but then God will grant His spirit to you so you would be unable to not curse the Holy Spirit or deny that Jesus is the Christ.
@sahm35 (890)
• United States
18 Jun 07
There is a quote by Martin Luther the reformer: "To deny the trinity endangers your SALVATION and to try to comprehend the trinity endangers her SANITY." John Wesley said: "You bring me a worm that can comprehend a man and I will show you a human being that can comprehend the Triune God. I think that the trinity is one of those just accept things and go on.
2 people like this
@Krisss (1231)
• Australia
18 Jun 07
oh they are great quotes. I love them
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
i dont deny it. i dont believe it. 2 different things.
4 people like this
@babykay (2131)
• Ireland
18 Jun 07
This is really interesting and I have never heard of it before. I am a Christian, as in I go by Christian values and I do believe in Jesus etc, but not having read all of the Bible I cant claim allegiance to it in the way some do. I am going to keep an eye on this post to see what the answers are!
3 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
yes, it pretty interesting alright.
4 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
i guess your not a "True Christian" if you have not read the bible..
3 people like this
• United States
19 Jun 07
I think you can be a true Christian eventhough you haven't read all the Bible.
• United States
18 Jun 07
If it is true, you are free. You can tell all the travelling Christian sellsmen that they can try to "save" someone else.
2 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
thats true, its the end of missionaries
5 people like this
@missak (3311)
• Spain
20 Jun 07
Thanks for your comment Sarah (see my replies) :D.
• United States
18 Jun 07
if you are worried at all, that means that the Holy Spirit still dwells in you, which means you have not chased the Holy Spirit away. If you were not worried at all, that would be a cause for concern. "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved." Acts 16:31. I don't believe in a religion of arbitrary rules and regulations... but only in one thing: that God cared for and loved you and me so much that He gave His treasured and only Son to die and rise again, to pay the price for whatever we have done. If we decide to accept this, we have newness of life. The hope of glory is that Christ and the Holy Spirit are indwelling, in you. I have been out of church for 5 years or so, because too many rules and regulations distract me from this truth. But I maintain what I have just told you. God SO LOVED "fightingisintheonlyway" that He gave His only begotten Son, that "fightingistheonlyway" should not perish, but have everlasting life. adapted from John 3:16.
• United States
18 Jun 07
The Holy Spirit is the teacher of truth, which lives within, and acts a conscience. As long as the conscience is not seared completely (ruined), there is hope. :-)
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
i dont believe that an all loving god would even banish those who deny him.
4 people like this
@lillake (1630)
• United States
18 Jun 07
I figure if you don't believe then why care if they say you are "saved" or not.
2 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
just saying why people can stop trying to convert atheists cause they are already gone.
3 people like this
• Canada
20 Jun 07
there is no such thing as free will if god is omnipotent. it is an oxymoron. but lets say for the sake of debate that what your saying is true. il try to "teach" you another way.. does god control our destiny?
2 people like this
18 Jun 07
As a reformed Catholic who now shuns all organized religion, let me assure you it's how you live your life that matters. God gave us intelligence to question and challenge and following any religion (which were all created by man, btw) is foolhardy. IMO And if I'm wrong I'll see you in hell ;)
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
a reformed catholic s basically a theist?
2 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
sorry i meant "deist" not "theist"
2 people like this
18 Jun 07
My belief in God has not changed, but I no longer wish to be a part of the Catholic Church for personal reasons and I really don't feel organized religion of any denomination is for me. That does not affect my spiritualism, which is quite a separate issue from religiousness.
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
18 Jun 07
my earliest memmories from my father's family was being told that i was already condemned to hell, whatever. My father's family were primative methodists. I thank the bones of the earth that my mother's family were pagans, and this is the path i follow. It seems self-defeting to me to to tell your believers that whatever they do, they will burn in hell. If that is the case, then why not do as you like? Always struck me as odd that one lol keep on posting blessed be
1 person likes this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
18 Jun 07
well yes actually i am
• Canada
19 Jun 07
yea, mithra had the same story of jesus for some reason, hmm
2 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
are you aware of who mithras and dionos are?
3 people like this
@volschenkh (1043)
• South Africa
18 Jun 07
As a believer, I am of the opinion that we should never take the text of the Bible literally, one should rather read it in context. Modern day chistians have to adapt the scripture into modern day context, otherwise we are all doomed by at least one or many versus in the Bible.
• South Africa
18 Jun 07
Thats an entirely different topic all together. Is there another book claimed to be written or enspired by God on this earth? There are many scriptures that have been found that people debate about whether it should be part of the bible or not, and if the conent of the bible in its current form is a true reflecetion of the facts etc etc. But I dont even wanna go there. I believe that everyone has the right to choose in what he/or she bleieves. And we really shouldn't judge each other for that, or even try to convince one another ortherwise. I was just trying to shed a little perspective from my side. I really dont want to get into a religious debate about does God exist or not. We live in a free world, and everyone is entitled to their views on religion or no religion for that matter.
• South Africa
18 Jun 07
But, may I add, from the nature of your replies, I can see that you out to provoke. Hey if you cant join them, make money off them, right? I find it a little bit too entrepeneurial for my liking, so I will quit THIS discussion!
• Canada
18 Jun 07
if the bible is the word of god, it shouldnt matter what year it is
2 people like this
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
20 Jun 07
The Holy Spirit only comes to us AFTER salvation. It's the Spirit of God that lives in us once we've accepted Him. My understanding of these scriptures is that if we accept God and then turn our back on Him, then and only then is it too late. It sounds to me like you've never accepted God in the first place, so you're probably still ok.
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
20 Jun 07
What does being religious have to do with it? If you equate religion with faith, you've clearly never understood either.
• Canada
20 Jun 07
no, i used to pray and love god just like most of you. through logic and education i grew out of it.
3 people like this
• Canada
20 Jun 07
no, i actually used to be religious. i dont know 1 person that grew up as an atheist, this is because of our generation. but as you have stated, i may not be okay, in your eyes.
3 people like this
@susieq223 (3742)
• United States
18 Jun 07
The scripture you quoted says nothing about doubting. It talks of not accepting and cursing. There is a big difference! It would take a lot to turn against the Holy Spirit if you have accepted Jesus and believe whole heartedly in God. It would be like a plane flying over the ocean from North America to Europe. At a certain point in the flight there is not enough gas left in the plane to go back, only enough to go on. If the Holy Spirit has filled your heart, it would take a lot of evil to turn away. If there was enough evil to overcome the Spirit, then like the plane that turns back, you would go down. I do believe there are people who are so filled with evil, or become so filled with evil they are damned. But I don't believe anyone who is sincere in their belief or their seeking for a relationship to God will be in that category. I hope I am making sense, here. It is a matter of the inner being. Even disbelieving is not the same thing. You have not blasphemed the Holy Spirit because you are a non-believer. You cannot blaspheme what you don't have. If you ever experience the Spirit, then deny what you have experienced...that is the difference.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
what if i dont accept and curse? i think that will be the same outcome dont you?
2 people like this
@blueyesco (156)
• United States
18 Jun 07
Oh well, it's an abomination to eat shell fish too. Don't see Red Lobster going out of business.
• Canada
18 Jun 07
really?? thats not in the bible is it?
2 people like this
• Canada
19 Jun 07
lol..thats pretty funny. its like muslims who dont eat pork
2 people like this
• United States
18 Jun 07
Yes it is in Leviticus...sorry can't remember the exact passage.
@vivienna (582)
• Venezuela
18 Jun 07
Dear fightingistheonlyway, it is really sad when so mane people, Christians inclusive, treat questions of faith at a level of more ignorance than knowledge. To be a believer includes the study of my faith' teachings. Then I will not misunderstand them or give confounding answers to people who aks like you do. The Holy Spirit is God's agent in order to convince people of their sin, of God's plan for salvation and that God judges evil (John 16:8). Rejecting the Holy Spirit is rejecting God's invitation to accept his mercy and a denial to repent. Well, this can never be forgiven, simply because God's pardon is given to those who decide to ask him for it. Hw who, forced because of persecution will be so weak to deny being a follower of Christ, will still find forgiveness. But he who never once allows himself to receive the Spirit of God, can't be born again and has condemned himself. If ever somebody seriously worried about having sinned against the Holy Spirit, this is enough to show that the Holy Spirit is well present in him.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
so god sends people to hell?
2 people like this
• Canada
19 Jun 07
god already knew the decision i was going to make, so whats the point of all this? + what if one does not believe in god? (reject and disbelief are 2 different things)
2 people like this
@vivienna (582)
• Venezuela
18 Jun 07
No, God doesn't send people to hell, they send themselves by rejecting his love. People are like a drowning person in high sea who rejects to fetch the life saver. You can't say they were drowned, they rather reject to be saved! God has given man free choice: it's up to us to accept the Savior.
@AndriaToh (1268)
• Malaysia
18 Jun 07
It is very important to read the Bible verses in context. If you read the whole of Mark chapter 3 (I'm not able to copy and paste but if you would go the http://www.biblegateway.com and look for Mark 3) In that chapter, Jesus had just healed many people. The teachers of the Law said that Jesus could heal because He had the evil spirit. Jesus then said those words in Mark 3:29 to warn the teachers of the law that if they continue not to recognise the workings of the Holy Spirit then they cannot be saved. Note that it is the Holy Spirit that convicts us of sin and the neccessity to repent and turn to God. So, if we are to reject the Holy Spirit then how are we to come to God. Hope this answers your question.
• Canada
18 Jun 07
god isnt all loving if he sends people to hell is he?
2 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
god already knew who was going to heaven who was going to hell, who would not believe in him, who would reject him etc. so whats the point?
2 people like this
@AndriaToh (1268)
• Malaysia
18 Jun 07
Changing the subject, are we? "For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through Him." John 3:17 It is not God's desire to condemn anyone, but its our choice to choose our own destination.
@sahm35 (890)
• United States
18 Jun 07
Have you ever cursed the Holy Spirit? If you ever cursed the Holy Spirit I think that you would know it. Because you would get smote down so quick! Dont try it now to curse. Just ask for forgiveness for all sin and go on. I think that we get to hung up on the legalistic crap. God just wants a relationship with us.
1 person likes this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
no, i never cursed cuz i dont believe... ive made fun of him.. saying "smite me" lol.. but yea does that count?
3 people like this
• United States
18 Jun 07
I think what that is really saying is that if you reject God, or renounce him then you can never be forgiven. I'm sure you have not done that, right? Through God all things are possible. Also, keep in mind that the Bible was written way back when. Alot of things have changed since then. Although you should still abide by the 10 comandments and the basics, there are things in the Bible that don't really cover issues of today. Take for example the fact that it says, you shouldn't live with someone unless you are married? How can one do that today? You don't really know the person unless you live with them. Keep God in your heart and soul and always welcome him and never reject or remounce him. You'll be ok!
• United States
18 Jun 07
Making fun of God? That's blasphemy. And not forgivable. And regardless where the 10 comandments came from, they are still God's law. And ones that everyone should abide by.
• Canada
19 Jun 07
lol..god is completely illogical, not one thing stands alone, the theory of god is full of contradictions
2 people like this
• Canada
18 Jun 07
i dont believe in god, i make fun of the idea. the 10 camandments were made in the code of hammorabi, not the bible btw. lol..k
2 people like this
@dodoguy (1292)
• Australia
20 Jun 07
hi fightingistheonlyway, This is about as nonsensical as any logic i've ever seen. I'm talking about the idea of taking an important religious question to a free-for-all public discussion forum, and hoping to get a useful answer. Sure, you'll get answers, just the same as if you took important questions about your house electrical wiring installation to the local laundrette to discuss with the locals who happen to be there doing their laundry at the time. Which means basically that you're not really serious about the question, beside it's value as a vehicle for idle gossip. Which may be very serious for you - lots of people take their gossip very seriously. There's whole branches of "Christianity" that have sprung up that way - complete with their own "church", as if God's Creation is a democracy and whoever gets the most votes wins. No doubt lots of people would even like to vote God out of Heaven - and there's lots of shysters that would happily sell the voting cards to you. If you have any real interest in such an issue, then I'd suggest asking someone who has more solid grounding in the matter about it.
@dodoguy (1292)
• Australia
20 Jun 07
actually, the reason that you are "asking" your question is logically self-evident, namely that your intention is not to seek answers or to consider the opinions of the people who respond, but rather it is to "instruct" these people according to the wisdom of your world view. you have stated this quite plainly in what you have said just here. in effect, your question is "rhetorical" - it's not a real question, it's your method of directing respondents to your unstated point of view. now, I haven't criticized you for doing this - but the people who are responding most probably haven't cottoned onto the fact that the "discussion" isn't really a two-way affair here. I don't regard the approach as particularly honest, but your willingness to disclose your purpose also demonstrates a lack of mischevious intent. Therefore you are quite self-assured of the security of your view. We shall all be enlightened on these matters in due course - unless one is fortunate enough to not subscribe to the notion of a Day of Judgement.
• Canada
20 Jun 07
haha, that was great. i agree. but its not necasserily rhetorical, i dont agree with that. this is because if one has a good answer to my question it will get me thinking as well, but so far, i have not found any good questions. I was surprised that you looked at my question analytically and not as if you wanted to answer it.
2 people like this
• Canada
20 Jun 07
the problem with your answer is that you dont see why im asking this question in the first place. im asking it to the Christian regulars, so they can question it themselves, go ask their priests and see if their answers make sense. or they could give an answer and i would rebut it, making them think about their own rebut, in turn, will turn out positively. these are the people who can still open their eyes as they dont have there heads stuck up their behinds. if you didnt want to discuss, why did you?
2 people like this
@saralee1 (1983)
• United States
19 Jun 07
I am Agnostic, but I like to play around with the idea, that GOD indeed exists, just because I like having a backup plan to becoming worm food. I know you are toying with this discussion, (tsk-tsk) because it seems you pretty much have your mind made up that GOD does not exist, but this topic gets some great responses. So, how do you curse a holy spirit? "oh you #$&5*(#! Holy Spirit!" or, do they mean something else? One thing I have noticed about the Holy Spirit is that it is not exclusive to any one religious affiliation, or sect. you can have it in a Druid gathering, or a Christian gathering. Pagan or Christian, what a concept! anyways, the spirit is the same. I have assumed that the spirit being used for other religious affiliations would be an abomination according to the bible, for my best guess.
• Canada
19 Jun 07
looll yea, i guess when im in debates with my religious friends i joke around saying "smite me oh lord" haha, and guess what? nothing happens! anyway, my religious friends warn me that hes cooking something up for me, i cant wait! i make fun more than i "curse". i seem to curse religion because of all the trouble it has brought upon the world. but yea, im sure if you look at it logically and reasonably you would one day open your eyes too. i used to be religious, then went agnostic/theist, now im an atheist.
3 people like this
• Canada
20 Jun 07
www.mylot.com/w/discussions/1145441.aspx problems with religion
2 people like this
• Canada
19 Jun 07
Fighting One,,, religion has not brought trouble upon the world. Only people have. It is always people at the root of distruction. That is why we need a savior!
• United States
20 Jun 07
It my opinion that if you are even asking this question than you have not whole heartedly denounced God. In fact it is extremely difficult for any human to do so unless they were born with a "black heart". Furthermore, I dont believe that any human has the right to pass judgemnt on another, so anyone who says these things to you is walking a fine line, becuase the bible says Do not pass judgement on others for you shall be judged a 100 fold. Meaning that they will face a much harder judgement. The fact that you even know the scriptures says alot. Most of us go through our lifes without even knowing or understanding ourselves let alone our hearts. Dont confuse what the mind believes with what your heart believes. Each person is different so dont stop searching for the answers you need, not want, NEED. Sadly, no one will truely know the truth until they die. I know this probably creates more questions but I hope it helps answer a few too.
• Canada
21 Jun 07
i totally agree.. but here are some of the reasons why i do what i do. www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4fQA9mt-Mg
2 people like this
• United States
21 Jun 07
I may not be the one who asked the initial question, but your response has made me think and has actually made me think about why I am questioning such a thing. It may not seem big, but I do wish to thank you. I think...no, I feel that I can look at something without worrying about what others judge, for it does not matter.
• Netherlands
18 Jun 07
If you are a believer then what you read is'nt scary. The verse is for people who after hearing about Jesus hardened their heart not to believe on Him. You see, the Holy Spirit is pointing out to Jesus for salvation. Believing not Jesus is quenching the Holy Spirit.
• Canada
18 Jun 07
actually, this isnt scary for non-believers because hell (as well as everything else) has already been logically disproven and thers nothing to be scared of. this is to scare the people who believe so that they stay believers, and dont stray away.
2 people like this
• Netherlands
19 Jun 07
There is no more worry left to those who put their trust in Christ. Why should the believers be scary of anything when he trusted all things to His Creator Jesus Christ? Think it again, if there's a person who doesn't worry about anything, it is the one who put their trust in Jesus Christ the Creator. Heaven is real as well as Hell is real. It does'nt need to be proven to become it real. They are both existing!!! Whether you believe it or not it is real. Hell is in the center of the earth. Science attested that the center of the Earth is thousands of thousands degrees hot. It conforms to the description of Hell in the Bible. You ask any believer of Jesus Christ if they become scary once they trusted Christ, they're not.
• United States
19 Jun 07
I think it's more referring to someone who never accepts the Holy Spirit. Like you said, everyone has doubts, but if you come to accept the Holy Spirit by the time you die, then you will be forgiven for the times that you didn't believe, but if you die a non-believer, than you won't be forgiven. That's just how I see it, but I guess we can only really speculate.
• Canada
20 Jun 07
oh i see, thanks
2 people like this
• Canada
19 Jun 07
jesus said that he was the only way TO heaven. this says that this is the only way TO hell. so what if you havnt done either?
2 people like this
@Amstardam (1348)
• United States
20 Jun 07
sorry but your question doesn't make sense. If you don't accept Christ then you are rejecting the Holy Spirit. There is no middle ground. If you accept Christ then you don't deny the Holy Spirit.