Guess what, No One in American is Expected to Raise a Family on

@ParaTed2k (22940)
Sheboygan, Wisconsin
October 1, 2007 3:24pm CST
Figure that federal mimimum wage is $5.85 (and many states have set minimum wage above that). $5.85 x 40 hrs/week x 52 weeks/yr = $12,168 Every family with 2 kids whose breadwinner makes minimum wage is eligible for $408/month in food stamps. $408 x 12 = $4896 Every family with 2 kids working for minimum wage is eligible or $4204/yr in Earned Income Credit. That comes to an annual income of: $21,268. $21,268 / 52 weeks per year / 40 hours per week: $10.23 per hour. Now, what do you want minimum wage to be at? And remember, the higher we set all these entitlements, the harder it is for people to get off them.
4 people like this
8 responses
• United States
1 Oct 07
You know, it's not wages but the differing cost of living across the US that drives me nuts! In Texas we lived uppermiddle class, always with more than enough money to spare, go out, shop, do whatever, but now that we are in California, even though we make more money, it really didn't cover the cost of living increase that we have experienced. I feel as though there should be some things that stay fairly even across the board - rent, utilities, that kind of stuff - but I know it's unrealistic at the same time. Yeah, I do kind of think minimum wage should be higher too - thazt would help a lot - but really, tolive somewhere "nice" like california - you know, popoular places (even though we are here cause my family is all here) shouldn't be so expensive it is ridiculous to try and live there for average people with average income.
1 person likes this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
No, my point is that, with all the rhetoric, nobody with a family makes less than $10/hr. What would you propose we do to "even" things out across the country?
• United States
3 Oct 07
Well, we sat down and did the math the other day, and we came to relaize that my sister - even with the child support she doesn't receive anyways - does in fact NOT make $10/hr. She's in realestate, but since the market out here sucks right now, she isn't selling houses, and is doing contract work. We never realizes that with her child support included she makes $9.28/hr (we used her tax records) And she is entitled to NOTHING! No WIC, no medical when she was pregnant, no food stamps, no assistance with the bills, NOTHING! Partly because she lives with us, but even still, if she were to move out on her own, she would only get $128/month in food stamps and WIC doesn't cover the formula teh baby gets (she has allergies in that department) and Misty would basically be living in poverty. So yeah, I think they do expect people to just suck it up and move on and stay broke when they get turned away from the social services offices. Up until recently we thought they had turned her down cause she was making too much money and therefor doing pretty well for herself. Really though - that is not the case. As far as getting things more fairly priced - I have no clue how to acheive that! I just wish it could be done. I know it won't happen and I am not clever enough to pull it off, but I wish it would happen. I would LOVE for our rent in so cal to be the same as it was in Texas! But I do live in reality and sadly accept the fact that it cannot be that way. Just wishing though, and that doesn't hurt anyone but my own little soul :( Anyways - Happy Wednesday!
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
3 Oct 07
If she is living with you, she isn't raising her child on mimimum wage, right? Actually, to me you and she are doing it the way it should be done. She is having problems so you are helping her out. You and she should be commended!
1 person likes this
@Destiny007 (5805)
• United States
1 Oct 07
The higher you set entitlements the higher they are to get. The higher the minimum wage goes, the higher prices will go to keep the profit margins high enough in order for companies to stay in business. The more prices go up the more people b!tch and complain that they just can't make it on their paychecks and that we need to raise the minimum wage again. It is a never ending cycle that is geared to making more and more people dependent on government handouts, and more and more people want the government to take care of them. They are all for the redistribution of wealth and any other socialistic plans and ideals. People claiming not to be able to make ends meet on what they make need to either find better jobs or learn how to budget. I am tired of the whining and complaining of these people. Why don't they just grow up and learn to stand on their own instead of waiting for the government to do it for them?
1 person likes this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
Exactly! It isn't the job of the federal government to guarantee a standard of living.
1 person likes this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
Marciaj Do you enjoy making excuses for others? Do you enjoy acting like I've never been there? Do you enjoy accusing me of things when you don't know me? You see, I can play that silly little game too. The point is that no one in America actually raises a family on "minimum wage", so they want to raise it. But the thing is, people who have kids already receive a lot more than what they are trying to set "minimum wage" at. yes, there are people have to settle for minimum wage due to situations beyond their control. However, if they aren't willing to put themselves out in the areas they can control, that is a CHOICE they make.
• United States
2 Oct 07
marciaj.... You assume a lot when you comment on one of my posts and suggest that I have never been in a situation like some of these people who are b!tching about not being able to make ends meet on minimum wage. Tell you what... why don't you try living with no income other then food stamps for 18 months while fighting for SSA disability that you paid into for 30 years and then tell me how hard you have it? Give it a try and see if you don't change your attitude some. You want to talk abouit jumping through some hoops? You haven't seen hoops until you try to get disability. Then once you do get it, see how you like living on 60% of the average of your last 7 years of income based on your 3 highest years. Don't even try talking to me about how hard you have it, because I don't even want to hear it. My suggestion to you is learn how to budget and get your priorities straight as to what is more important, such as discretionary spending as opposed to the necessities and what you have to do to survive. Learn to stand on your own and stop looking to the government to take care of you. If you don't like your situation then figure out some way to change it.
• United States
2 Oct 07
I think it is hard to make ends meet on $10 or less with 2 incomes. We make do making a little more than that and we have to work hard to get by on that. Our budget is stricter than most though and we like it that way. The cost of living is going up so fast we can barely keep up.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
So when you decide you need/want more, will you do something to increase your income, or expect the government or your employer to give you more?
1 person likes this
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
1 Oct 07
Even if your figures were absolutely, positively accurate, do you really expect someone to live on that? I know for a fact every family earning minimum wage with 2 kids is not automatically entitled to $408 in food stamps, there are other factors used to determine eligibility. They also still pay payroll taxes, state and local income taxes, etc. What if said breadwinner becomes sick and has a miss a few days work during the year? People earning minimum wage don't usually get sick pay! How are they supposed to pay for health care? Their kids may be covered but in many cases the parents are not! What about heat in winter? Even with energy assistance it doesn't come close to paying the whole bill, if they're lucky enough to be eligible they may get a couple hundred bucks for the whole year. What should minimum wage be set at? I say if someone works 40 hours a week, 52 weeks a year they should be able to feed and clothe their family, heat their home and get treated if they become sick without any entitlements! Annie
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
I'll ask you what I ask everyone I meet who complains they don't make enough... "What are you doing for yourself to make more?"
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Oct 07
I make about 19,000, family of four, we don't qualify for food stamps, it's hard making minimum wage, at least I don't pay for heat.
1 person likes this
@Modestah (11179)
• United States
5 Oct 07
interesting, frightening though. does it sound a bit like the idea of atheistic communism?
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
8 Oct 07
Well, communism isn't automatically atheism, but any government program that seeks to replace personal altruism is wrong headed to start with.
@lgwlong (199)
• China
2 Oct 07
Raising one kids will cost much more than mimimum wage,at least triple mimimum wage,if cannot reach the wage level,the child have no chance to go to high school and have to work in his early age
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
But it isn't the government's job to make sure people who choose to have kids make enough to raise them. That is the responsibility of those of us who choose to have kids.
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Oct 07
that is about what our goverment wants us to do...
@devilsangel (1817)
• United States
1 Oct 07
Well I guess I'm glad I don't work for the federal goverment anymore. Hell even when I did I made more than that a year. You've got to also consider cost of living when you do your figures. In some states $5.85 an hour will actually be plenty to live off of. On top of which thats assuming that everyone in the country works for the federal goverment. Most don't, so they get paid the state mim wage, which varires from state to state. In washington the mim wage is $7.93 an hour. Most companies pay at least $2 over mim wage so thats about $9.93 an hour for many Washington employees. Hell the last job I worked I was making $12.44 an hour. So even though your figures are shocking they aren't very accurate for the American people or the cost of living in various areas.
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
2 Oct 07
Your comment doesn't make sense. Federal Minimum wage isn't what the federal government pays, it's what the federal government mandates private businesses pay.
1 person likes this