I will miss CARLY!

Singapore
April 26, 2008 8:54am CST
Carly Sminthson is one of my favorite finalists in this season's American Idol. She has everything. She is very good vocally, good style, can reach high notes and has a very powerful voice. She is also pretty and very down to earth. She is one big thing in this music industry. I am sure that sooner or later, her album will be out and I will not be surprise that she will be one the finest artists. I will definitely miss you. Since you are gone, I am sure that the two David's will meet in the finals. Keep posting, Mickey
6 responses
@Deblwest (98)
• United States
30 Apr 08
Talk about shocking hah. I really liked her and had hopes she would win it. She is amazing. I explained to my fiance that if the voters think they do not need to vote cause a singer is a shoe in to win that person can get voted off. I vote faithfully every week. Take care!
@ladym33 (10979)
• United States
30 Apr 08
I agree, I was shocked and angry when she was voted off. It really made it seem more like a popularity contest, when that happened.
@SueRod (238)
• United States
26 Apr 08
I agree. I was a bit shocked when it was revealed that Carly was the one to leave last week. I thought her voice was powerful and that some of the others would go before her. I will miss her as well. However I do think that they all will have an opportunity to make it big now that they have reached this far on American Idol. My guess is that David Archuletta will win. David Cook will make it no matter what. We'll find out soon enough.
@howard96h (11640)
• New York, New York
27 Apr 08
Me too, I thought Brooke would have been eliminated before Carly. I also think the two David's will be fighting for the title.
• Philippines
29 Apr 08
lol..you have no idea how i was SOOOOOOOOOO pissed when they voted off Carly. she was the one of the best among the rest and i knew it by heart that she'll make it through the top 3. but hey. they favored the other girl - brooke white - no offesne to brooke fans. oh well, i just hope they will give carly a big break and i know that her career will soon start just like elliot. =)
@DJenson (18)
• United States
29 Apr 08
Yeah, it was sad to see Carly go, but she's not going to be gone long. I'm sure she probably already has a record deal, and we should be seeing an album from her pretty soon.