Disciplinary spanking...

Philippines
May 9, 2009 3:16pm CST
There was this article in our local newspaper before that caught my attention. It was something about a way of life that existed a few years back and made me reminisce my childhood days. It was the time when began to learn the meaning of the word hate, how I associated that word to my parents sometimes, and how much I value those experiences now after I realized what it really meant. Heard of the word spanking? It is inflicting any physical force to a person, and it comes in different forms; a slap in the face or behind, a pinch in the arms or legs, be battered by a leather belt, slippers, stick, fan, or any object, etc. What are they anyway? It was predominant before in our country as way of disciplining children. Any wrong doing comes with a painful remembrance just to make one, hopefully, not to repeat such act again. I grew under such rule existing in our very home. It's like having a tyrant living inside a structure which suppose to be a place of love and happiness. I was young then. I didn't get the idea why I am being slapped by my parents and elder relatives everytime I do something wrong. I get slapped in some areas in my body based from my actions; saying bad words -mouth, stealing stuff from others - hands, going home late - legs, making other people upset - behind. I still consider myself lucky though since I didn't get to experience more "significant" versions such as kneeling on rock salt, eating soap, or being hanged on a tree inside a sack. No, it's not yet that extreme. I'm still alive. Those were gestures of love before. It didn't violate any law until now. It appears harsh, strict and scary. If it is painful, then how did it become a gesture of love? If you will judge such at the time it was administered, I will certainly agree that it appears more of anger than love. But after the painful feeling has passed, or run a few more years that you become older and wiser, how do you view them now? Me and my friends are laughing about our own experiences. Again, we are still alive. We are somehow more disciplined than the youth of today. We learned to fear wrong things. We learned how painful it is to do something wrong. We learned that those people whom we have done wrong were in more pain that what we really got from them. We learned how much our parents and our elder relatives loves us that they wish to teach us the right things and make it a part of our way of living. We learned that no hate really existed during those times, it is more of concern, to our future. With so many laws created and activists roaming around today, such culture has decreased dramatically over the past few years. But what happened to our present generation? It is saddening to see most of them as they are right now. The right values are diminishing to children as if the good ones are a rare breed. They are no longer afraid to do the wrong things, which is pretty scare if it falls to majority of the children today. Does a little bit of spanking really help in enforcing discipline? Were you raised this way by your parents? Do you think it helped you become who you are right now? Can we still apply this to the present generation?
1 person likes this
9 responses
@Greenhill (178)
• United States
9 May 09
I got my butt smacked many times. I grew up just fine. I didn't become a delinquent or nut case so I am glad I was punished...I wasn't really bad, just did stupid things..My little sister got a new doll for Christmas and I cut the dolls hair off, things like that. I don't have kids, never had the desire to be a mother so I don't know how I would have been at disciplining a kid. I think I'm better off not knowing!
• Philippines
10 May 09
we were little troublemakers once in a while during our childhood days then by doing pranks and stupid stuffs. im also single and i dont have any plans of having a wife and having my own family. but i get to use this skill of disciplining when at work or simply spending some time with the children of my relatives. knowing when to and when not to give a little spank to kids is a bit of a help really, especially when things gets annoying, hahahaha!
@Jixapose (97)
• United States
9 May 09
People are essentially animals - funny little monkeys that wear clothes, write plays, and play around with nuclear forces. In training any animal, the reward and punishment system is very effective. If a child does not learn that 'hot' equals 'pain', then chances are that child is going to burn him/herself. The idea of us teaching our children is to give them a greater chance of survival and procreation in this interesting social reality we've created that has little direct correlation to our inborn animal instincts. Spanking or physical punishment reinforces the knowledge, skills, and training that we give our children to succeed.
• Philippines
10 May 09
nice comment here, technical but full of meaning. yeah, hitting a child is like reinforced learning. a mistake is equal to pain, a good deed is spank-free. the best thing of being a human is we can act, explain and understand the meaning of our instincts. as we strive to survive ande exercise our animal instincts, we get to show our love and concern to those who are dear to us.
@keasling (723)
• United States
9 May 09
IT does help in the discipline process. I work at school that the children are wild and disrespectful. It is truly sad that parents do not see that spanking when done correctly is very needed. I was spanked as a child and at times I felt i was beat. I know not to do wrong things though. I try to teach my children that misbehaving will have severe consequences and if they do wrong I will not just let them get away with it. Thank you for posting such a great discussion.
• Philippines
10 May 09
i guess we can only do a little of this at home. i teach in high school and doing so might send me somewhere. thanks for the comment!
@iskayz (5420)
• Philippines
10 May 09
Hi there! When I was a kid I've experienced being spanked a lot of times. My dad used to spank me and my brother. I even experienced being forced to stay inside the bathroom for hours until I stop crying. We're not bad kids. We don't actually do bad things for us to get spanked but there are times my father gets irritated whenever we are having our tantrums. But we never thought spanking is a bad thing. I think parents who spank their kids don't have enough patience. Kids are kids and they don't know a lot of things yet. Their ability to comprehend things and situations are not that thorough so parents must have enough patience in teaching them and not hurting them. But sometimes to get the kids attention you must let them experience a little spanking for them to realize that you are serious in talking to them. In today's society I believe spanking is still prominent in some families. I think it has been the nature of parents in disciplining their kids that way. As long as it doesn't go over beyond smashing the kids' nose, I think it's ok otherwise it's abuse and they shouldn't be tolerated. Ciao!
@rajeshfgh (1629)
• India
10 May 09
My parents, especially my mother, used to beat me with a wooden scale if I were to misbehave or shout around in the house especially in the afternoons when everybody was sleeping. Personally, I feel it is not the right way, children must be made to understand why they should not do a particular thing lovingly rather than trying to go the Hitler way. Yes, if the child repeats his mistake then he/she should be penalised in some way, surely not by spanking.
• Philippines
10 May 09
I had so many experienced like that when i was just a kid. and that time, parents of the 80's were same as the last decade of that, very strict. Now a days there are still quite a few parents who does that sort of thing. but let me remind you, that if a parent does spank you in the Butt, it doesn't that they hate you or angry with you. it's because they're angry of what you've done. I know, because my mom cried after than painful spanking. I told her am sorry and then she hug me tight.
@sulynsi (2671)
• Canada
10 May 09
I think there is a vast difference between spanking and some of the forms if corporal punishment described in your post. My Dad never had to spank me. I just was the kind of kid that didn't need it. I did get a few from my mom, usually for being saucy. I was NEVER saucy with Dad. I don't like spanking unless absolutely necessary. I found that IF the child needs firm discipline, if it is done early in life, it isn't necessary to do it in later life. Other forms of discipline should be used as a child gets older. The intent of this form of punishment is to correct, to help a child not repeat mistakes that could harm him or someone else. It should not be done to humiliate or physically harm a child. It should never be administered in anger. Any form that does this is not what I would think of as spanking.
@cobra1368 (702)
• United States
10 May 09
I think we can and we should. I was raised that way. Heck, we were even paddled in school if we misbehaved. I have no hard feelings or grudges against my parents for their method of discipline. I am an upstanding member of society: married, good job, Masters degree, great house, etc. I've got no problems in life, and I was spanked many times over the course of my childhood. Every single event is laughable, even the most severe one. Man, I deserved it, LOL. To this day, I don't blame my dad for spanking me. He had just gotten a boat from a guy, and it was perfect except for a fist-sized hole in the side of it. So, dad got some fiberglass and was patching the hole one afternoon. He had spent about four hours on it, getting it as smooth as he could. I come back home from a friend's house (friend in tow), and walk around the side of the boat. I see the patch, and I say, "What's this?" as I proceed to poke a finger-sized hole straight through the still-drying fiberglass patch on the boat. My dad, immediately realizing what I just did, comes flying around from the other side of the boat and said, "WHAT DID YOU JUST DO!!!!" I was then slammed on the rear three times, so embarassed, and my friend turned tail and ran home. Of course, I was more embarassed that he did that in front of my friend than I was upset about the spanking. You better believe I never touched anything again without asking what it was and if I could touch it! Children need to feel a little sting. They need to realize that there are sometimes serious consequences for committing the wrong action. Honestly, the times I remember being spanked, my pride hurt a lot more than the actual spanking. Then, I learned my lesson and added my wrong-doing to the list of things I should never do again if I knew what was good for me. What do kids learn if they are put in "time out" for 5 minutes and then get to go about their day? It means they can actually bite people, throw tantrums, and do whatever bad things they like to do, and basically get away with it. Some kids desparately need the discipline. JMO
• United States
9 May 09
I personally don't believe in disciplinary spanking, because it angers me when I did get spanked... I felt like there was a beat inside me, just wanting to get out and attack the people who spanked me... My mom who spanked me, said that she only spanks me because she loves me, but I don't really believe that. I believe that she loves me, but I don't get the fact that why would she want to hurt me if she loved me... Lots of people go around saying that... Disciplinary spanking is also common in South KOrea, because when I went there for like 2 monthes of schooling, because I had nothing to do, I got spanked, and very hard... Currently in the United States, only a few states allow disciplinary spanking, and most schools in those states do not do disciplinary spanking. Disciplinary spanking is very cruel, and should be banned throughout the whole United States.