are u against the religious war - jihad?
By manish243236
@manish243236 (591)
India
April 22, 2007 12:17am CST
Jihad is a muslim war,which was started by some Mmslim fanatics,is widespread throughout the world.
It has killed thousands of innocent people living in many capitalistic countries. No one can define what it exactly wants, and it's been many years since it started and none could comprehend its emphasis.
do u support the religious war? or are u against it?
1 person likes this
11 responses
@mogie_systems (70)
• United States
22 Apr 07
I love the people but against a jihad, its so sad that these beautiful people are so misled by something that was written alittle over a thousand years ago when they were in their deepest need.all are deceived by hatred.
2 people like this
@manish243236 (591)
• India
22 Apr 07
ya, it's really disheartening to see innocent people suffering due to some fanatics.let god establish a formula to end war and bring peace to world!
1 person likes this
@collstarx (1177)
• Indonesia
22 Apr 07
I think you many read article from west country, every religion teach to love every people not must same religion.
You know the meaning of jihad ? jihad is war for allah my gods name, so if someone have religion muslim but they kill other people, I think their people have ill in their heat.
bset regards
@danishcanadian (28953)
• Canada
22 Apr 07
Yes I am very much against Jihad. To me religion and war can not go hand in hand. Now isn't an American form of Jihad what George W Bush is doing? George seems to be trying to make the whole world believe what he believes, and often uses religion to justify what he is doing. Jihad is a Muslim world which can easily describe what the American president is trying to do, and to describe ALL religious war, not ust Mulsim. I don't believe in ANYONE's Jihad.
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
23 Apr 07
but George Bush's war is reactionary to jihad attacks from Muslims, he isnt actually on a jihad, religious war, or religously inspired war. So its def. differetn.
@chiquitita (1226)
• Indonesia
23 Apr 07
okay.. Jihad is a "struggle" and it is not only about a war. A student who struggles to get good grades is jihad. A mother who's labouring her baby is also jihad. In terms of war, jihad is a self defense, for instance, your country is being invaded and you stand tall to fight for your country, that's jihad. BUT attacking and killing innocent people (even in the name of religion) is not jihad, because there's no way God tells us to attack innocent people. So things that is happening now, is simply a blasphemy. Hope it clears things up.cheers!
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
22 Apr 07
Manish243236! I think your knowledge about Jihad is limited with regards to history. Jihad is not something new as you say. It's a very old term and it means Holy War. The concept of holy war is present and has been active in every religion. Let me quote a verse from ld testament here.
"They devoted to destruction by the sword the entire city: man and woman, young and old, cow and sheep" (6:21)
This "devoted to destruction" which is also called "ban" refers to israelite Holy War.
similarly there is crusade in christians, and as you belong to India so in hindi you must be knwoing the concept of dharamyuddha. So holy war has been there for millenniums and is not new. Now the fact that some people have misused the concept doesn't mean that one should derogate it. We should see the things in right perspective. Jihad means self defense, which every nation will do, should it be attacked by any foreign force. I believe that indians will defend their country against any aggression. Same is Jihad. We need to have tolerance towards all religions and should better understand the concept first, before giving our opinion.
1 person likes this
@manish243236 (591)
• India
22 Apr 07
ok dude...its good u know the real meaning of Jihad
but do u feel that's wat going in the world???
aren't u worried about thousands of people suffering due to some idiotic mind set by some powerful people in the world?
Is it really SELF- DEFENSE going on .....???
isn't it massacre and reason-less killing going on?
@manish243236 (591)
• India
23 Apr 07
yep dude, every religion has its own principles and we should have tolerance...thats indispensable. but no religion teaches war or killing. Jihad may be interpreted as self-defense, but who is attacking? where is the scope for self defense?
okk lets imagine that the fanatics are self-defending themselves.....but why are innocent citizens hurt,dying and suffering every moment??
is there any reason to attack a community of people and kill them...and calling it as "god asked us to do it"?
would u tolerate if anyone burns or kill ur village/town and say that "our religion demands it....and we don't give a damn to the consequences"
please answer this question straight .....
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
22 Apr 07
Manish! you have rightly pointed out a problem here. There are people who are misusing this concept. Reasonless killing in each its form and manifestation is condemnable. But won't you agree that these types of people who have their personal vested interests are present in each religion and in each region? If each region and religion has these types of personalities, is it right and just to single out just one of them? having said that Self defense is really a wide term and have much room for interpretation. What do you think RAM did when Seeta was abducted (i don't have a proper word so please don't take offence of anything) by ravan? what do you think about tens of thouands of men, women, old and children who are killed in Kashmir by Idian Army? i don't want to debate who is right or who is wrong. i am just saying that every body fights for whatever he/she consider right. What do you think about more than 100,000 (135,000 precisely) casualities of hiroshima and nagasaki, what about thousands of women and children masssacred in palestine?
I really agree with you that ruthless and merciless killing is wrong. My point is just that how would you define self denfense in above cases and are there not these types of people who misuse, every where?
1 person likes this
@Harley009 (1416)
• India
10 Nov 09
Hi Manish,
Being a Muslim let me clear what is 'Jihad'.
'Jihad' is an Arabic word which means strive/struggle. It is not just a term for war by some Muslims. It is striving to keep Islamic moral, striving to keep away from our inner lusts and evil, striving to help others, striving to convey the message of Islam, striving to protect people from enemy, etc. In the case when enemy fight us, as a last resort we can fight back with those who attack, Under normal circumstances enemies attacking family or Islam could be taken under the court.
So translating Jihad as Muslim War is against the concept of Islam. Of course the aspiration of every individual to have Peace for their own, and having peace in the society and country is good of course. We cannot just start fight just to establish Islamic country for no reason. If Muslims first individually make their own better in practicing Islam and keep the commandments of God, and if our society achieve such a peaceful condition, and if we are worthy of it Almighty God might grand us to lead as a nation.
It is wrong to adopt false ways to achieve a right goal.
There are some black sheep name sake Muslims in our community, I agree, as per the Islamic rules they might not come under the fold of Islam and they are not under the hands of Muslims, but with Politicians. Islam denounce terrorism of course, we denounce 9/11, London bombings, Mumbai bombings, Gujarat Riots, Attack towards Iraq Palestine and Afganitan.
Police is to establish peace and minimize crimes, but even police use some violent methods to establish peace. If the same condition happens towards Islam I agree with fight for the sake of peace otherwise No fight or war.
India is a great country for sure, it Allows everyone to practice and preach their faith. Forcing someone to join a belief system against to Indian constitution. Islam also prohibits to force someone to accept Islam.
So Jihad is not just a Muslim war. and If some Muslim fight it not necessarily to be a Jihad. If a Muslim strive for good in the right way then it is Jihad.
Peace.
@giegrace (213)
• Philippines
10 Nov 09
I'm totally against using religion as a basis or driving force behind a war. This sparks hatred towards Islam and puts Muslims in a bad light.
Proponents of Jihad are mostly radical Muslims who misinterpret Allah's teachings.