This makes me so angry I could just spit!
By gardengrrl
@gardengrrl (1445)
United States
April 30, 2007 11:51am CST
Heard on the news yesterday than some town council in Bumtuck, NJ has voted to ban cigarette smoking inside your car if a child under 16 is present. WTF??!!*!@??
Where do I begin, to list the problems I have with this? First, when will my occasionally moronic fellow Americans wake up and accept the fact that YOU CANNOT LEGISLATE COMMON SENSE? I am so damn tired of people wanting the government to raise and protect their children! If a parent is not concerned enough for their kids' health to stop smoking around them, that is their perogative (if we live in a free country, that is.) Children of smokers very often become smokers themselves, so I imagine it would be difficult if not impossible to separate the effects of second hand smoke on long term health.
The legal act of cigarette smoking generates hundreds of millions of dollars in tax revenue to the same hypocritical legislators who want to ban it. I have yet to hear even ONE politician explain how they'll make up for the tax revenue lost if cigarette smoking were eliminated!
There's a great deal of support for these kinds of initiatives from right wing conservatives, the very same people who claim to be anti-big government. Why don't people understand, the more you use government to control other's behavior, the larger that government must be?
What about the enforcement issue? Crime is a problem pretty much everywhere, so is drunk and aggressive driving. Don't the police have better things to do? In this case, it is a secondary offense, meaning you have to be doing something else to get pulled over. It won't take long to for that to change, much as the seatbelt laws did.
I don't know, this kind of myopic idiocy just really, really, pisses me off. I'm an odd amalgam of liberal and conservative tendencies - I am against big government overall, but I darn sure want it to be big enough that no American suffers from hunger or lacks a roof over their head. It makes me foam at the mouth when people and politicians get sidetracked with this nonsense, while genuine issues are ignored. It's part of the greater issue, I know, politicians lose touch with the everyday lives of average citizens because they never have to go home and live with what they've wrought. This tidbit just really, really sizzled my bacon, so I thought I'd put it out here for discussion.
2 people like this
3 responses
@angelface23 (2494)
• United States
30 Apr 07
I agree with you that it is a pretty hypocritcal law to pass but being that I have a child under 16 I am not really bothered by it. You said that if a parent chooses to smoke around their kids, it's their perogative. Well what about the kids. The parents are supposed to protect them so if they won't protect them by not smoking around them at all then someone else has to step in and make that decision. I don't think the issue here is to pi$$ you off because you can't smoke in your car with your kids. I think it is being put in place to protect the children.
@gardengrrl (1445)
• United States
30 Apr 07
Hi, angel!
Actually, I neither smoke nor have kids, so this wouldn't directly affect me. It's just that I grew up thinking of the American people as independent, tough minded, fair, and free. Heck, the WWII generation certainly was! My mom didn't need the government to tell her how to protect her kids, nor did she expect it to. She would have resented the heck out of any attempt to do so. Nowadays, it seems like many people expect the government to take over the parent's role as guardian. Some people are too lazy to teach their kids morals or manners, and expect the schools to pick up the slack. People don't think through to the consequences of their actions, as long as they're satisfied right now. This cannot be cured through legislation! I think we may be in danger of raising an entire generation of young people who don't understand that self control is the ultimate control, and expect some authority figure to tell them how to live.
1 person likes this
@gardengrrl (1445)
• United States
30 Apr 07
ps Yes, friends, I have quit smoking! It's my 6th try in the past year, but this one feels like it will take. Wish me luck!
1 person likes this
@angelface23 (2494)
• United States
30 Apr 07
to elhawks somment. Yes it is the parents responsibility. Everything your kids does is on your shoulders until they turn 18. Why don't u think about that??
@adams03605 (436)
• United States
30 Apr 07
The way I see it is this.... so long as I don't smoke in my car with my kids, I can continue to use my cell phone and send text messages to all my friends and family. That isn't endangering their lives. Unless that text is sending out some radioactive thing that could kill them...
They need to worry about getting the drunks off the road first before they start paying cops to be wasting time out on patrol looking for people smoking in their cars.
I don't know what this country is coming to, and I feel sorry for my kids and what they will have to deal with in their lifetime!
1 person likes this
@Springlady (3986)
• United States
15 May 07
I wish they would ban smoking completely. Who wants to breathe someone else's smoke from their cancer sticks?
If you want to smoke, then do so by yourself, not around other people.
1 person likes this