Boycotting gas stations May 15, 2007 WON'T affect THE OIL COMPANIES in the least
@beaniefanatic13 (5076)
Grand Junction, Colorado
May 2, 2007 9:08pm CST
I have seen several discussions started on this subject and expect to see many more between now and the 15th and thought I would be able to better shed some light here rather than responding to all the individual discussions.
I started working at a gas station back in 1989 until 2001 that was owned and operated by my in-laws. I'm going to attempt to explain why picking a day not to buy gas will have NO EFFECT on the big oil companies. I'm also going to attempt to explain that the owner-operated gas stations AREN'T getting RICH selling gas.
If a gas station pumps 10,000 gallons of fuel a day at approximately a .10 per gallon profit they have only made $,000 for the day. This money has to pay for the employees wages salaries and benefits, the electricity, and the many types of insurance that are required for operating a business. There are many other expenses that most people don't even think about in running a business like water, sewer and garbage. There are maintenance costs and landscaping, and property taxes and the list is practically endless. Yes, $1,000 sounds like a lot, but I can assure you that it's nothing compared to the expenses involved. Gasoline profits are exhausted on day to day operations.
Have you noticed that owner-operated gas stations now rely on other more profitable avenues? There larger convenience stores, car washes, repair shops, propane sales, truck rentals and even fast food establishments attached.
All of the stories about boycotting in the past that state that they have had an affect are untrue. Here are a couple of links which provide more detailed information:
http://www.snopes.com/politics/gasoline/nogas.asp
http://www.snopes.com/politics/gasoline/gasout.asp
I can assure you that no time in the late 90's did gas drop overnight by .30 or that stations noticed any kind of change in the purchase of fuel. Certainly NOT the oil companies that we would be trying to negatively impact.
"By definition, a boycott involves the doing without of something, with the renunciation of the boycotted product held up as tangible proof to those who supply the commodity that consumers are prepared to do without it unless changes are made." (This was taken from the 1st snopes link provided above.) The only way to have an effect on the big oil companies is to change your driving habits. You need to carpool and/or use public transportation, and for many these aren't options. There is a big difference between rescheduling your activity versus eliminating the activity altogether.
Your thoughts on this?
7 people like this
12 responses
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
3 May 07
I've always thought those one day boycotts of products are silly. If you're going to boycott something and make a difference, it has to be a longer term commitment than a day. And you have to realize that the manufacturer won't feel the impact as much as the store owner will.
4 people like this
@porkrind333 (288)
• United States
3 May 07
"And one in the audience silently stood and began slowly clapping",,,,,,, Alternative Fuel sources, Public Transportation and small changes in day to day routines across society will hurt the BIG OIL companies more than boycotts. What confuses people is that Oil Companies could care less about how much the Oil costs coming out of the ground. They will get the costs back at the pumps. However when we begin to use less fossil fuels that will hurt their margins. A 1% cut in thier profit margins will get thier attention.
4 people like this
@claudia413 (4280)
• United States
3 May 07
I'm very glad you posted that info. I had already passed it along to several people who sent me the email about the proposed boycott on May 15. I remember several of the other earlier emails about boycotts also. I guess I've been around for a long time. LOL.
3 people like this
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
3 May 07
Well hello there Ms. Beanie,
Nice to visit with you again! Your thoughts are right on the mark!!! Anyone who has ever owned a business understands that profits are not gauged daily. Daily averages are used in monitoring overall profit averages yes, but the margins are compared to prior year sales by a month to month, quarterly and annual comparison. So trying to 'put the hurt on' big oil with a one day boycott will accomplish absolutely nothing.
If I may, I'll also take this discussion to the next step. In the past, after this "boycott big oil on such and such a day" message gets out, and is debunked by the presentation of relevant facts ... the next logical step is to start hearing a call for boycotting specific big oil companies. "Stop buying Exxon" etc... Sadly, this is futile as well, because the big oil companies sell amongst each other.
Beaniefanatic is right! The only way to send a message to big oil is to change our consumption habits.
Of course, there is another way to affect the cost of fuel. That is to start demanding that the Federal, State, and local governments lower the tax percentages they are collecting on each gallon of gas.
Or better yet, start pounding on the doors of your state and local officials to demand that they stop demanding so many different types of fuel mixes. California is a great example. Beanie, maybe you can jump in here ... if I remember correctly the state of California and it's various different municipalities have legislated over 9 fuel mixes in CA alone. That's 9 different blends that all travel along the same fuel transfer distribution infrastructure. That's a big part of our fuel costs. Every time the fuel mix has to be switched to a custom blend, the oil companies pay labor costs that they, in turn, pass on to you and I.
3 people like this
@poppoppop111 (5731)
• Canada
18 May 07
i saw this discussion the day you started it and lost it before i could answer and it was bothering me. so i'm glad i found it again. anyway. i didn't even know there was a boycot going on. maybe there wasn't one where i live then. but i didn't buy gas that day anyway. i didn't need to. and i still haven't botten gas since. i'm getting really low on gas but it's just way to expensive to buy these days. i'm hoping it will go down in the next couple of days or else it's going to cost a fortune to fill right up. maybe i'll just get 10 dollars at a time to see if it will go down soon.
2 people like this
@maildumpster (3815)
• United States
20 May 07
I think the whole thing is silly. I get gas when I need it. I don't care what day it is nor how many people have told me not to.
I think a better tactic would be petitions to the oil companies and the government.
2 people like this
@ElusiveButterfly (45940)
• United States
10 May 07
The best way for us to get the prices down is to stop using so much fuel. Conserving energy is crucial.
2 people like this
@visitorinvasion (7709)
• United States
3 May 07
Don't be such a pessimist!
It's high time people started sticking together again, and this is as good of a cause as any.
1 person likes this
@beaniefanatic13 (5076)
• Grand Junction, Colorado
3 May 07
I attempted to outline the facts and add perspective and logic to this so called boycott and why it won't work. Changing your purchasing habits for a day, will not change the prices of gas, all it will do is inconvenience the consumer. You will still need to purchase gas, unless your driving habits change. So instead of purchasing gas on the 15th you purchase on the 14th or the 16th, either way the oil companies lost NOTHING! The only way to get the attention of the big oil companies is to use alternative transportation such as carpooling and/or public transportation. This would have an impact on the oil companies if done by the majority of consumers and done for a length of time.
2 people like this
@maildumpster (3815)
• United States
3 May 07
The problem is that many areas don't have good public transport. We have buses and trains here but to get to any of them you have to walk quite a distance or drive there.
I don't believe that not buying gas on any day will do any good.
2 people like this
@whiteheather39 (24403)
• United States
3 May 07
Yes I saw this on snopes already. Dont you just love snopes? I do.
2 people like this
@kelly60 (4547)
• United States
15 May 07
It's true that Boycotting gas stations May 15, 2007 isn't going to hurt the oil companies. I have pointed this out in my responses to quite a few discussions already, mentioning the link to snopes where the information is detailed.
For those who want to try it though, go ahead. It won't hurt to to it if you want to, although don't expect anything to happen.
@sunshinelady (7609)
• United States
24 May 07
This is a very informative discussion and I appreciate it being put here. My husband were talking about this and came to the conclussion that the gas station owners are making a mint off of the raise in prices. I am going to let my husband read this. As you say and this is one of the things that my husband and I were talking about is the fact that one day is not going to make a difference in making the gas prices to drop. It would have to be a continuing boycott until it acually made a difference. Very good discussion. It opened my eyes up.
1 person likes this