this weeks episode

I actually quite liked it..... I do like McDreamys ex wife but I wish she didn't play Alex around like that :(

I didn't like it very much, but hopefully it will improve when it is on it's own. It was just odd to go back and forth between two different sets of characters. Private Practice is rumored to be on ABC's fall schedule. The rumored day of the week is Wednesday, which is an odd choice. One would think that it would be a better fit after Grey's on Thursdays.

I kept jumping between channels I only liked the Greys anatomy part I really don't think the spinoff is going to survive. I mean the characters were nice to look at, but the plot was quite boring. I really didn't like the ogling of the young surfer kid I thought that was a little aging for the characters we tuned in to watch.

I think this whole season has been pretty boring. I HATE what they have done to George and Izzy so anything to do with that sucks for me to watch. I think the spin-off looks OK, but nothing very exciting. I think Addison is better off staying where shes at. I think Derek is going to stay with Meredith for awhile although he doesn't want to because of her dads wife dying. I think that if they have Derek and her split right now shes gonna go nuts!!! All in all not much has gone on this season!!

I love greys anatomy its a great show.I loved this weeks episode and I am looking forward to watching the spinoff. I a HUGE fan. I think that derik and merideth and starting to have problems i am anxious to see what that turns into.

It is very common for show to bring together and then break up popular characters. After all, conflict makes for good viewing. So yes, derek and merideth may in for some trouble, I am sure it will be resolved.

It wasn't "bad" per say. It just felt really contrived. But maybe that's because I already knew that is was positioned as a spin off episode. It was too deliberate and obvious. I'm definitely not left wondering if Addison will go to LA. I KNOW she will. Y'know?

I thought it was good to sort of introduce the spin off into the episode..I think it could be good..but all in all I wasn't impressed. I always think that the director's of Grey's do a wonderful job of their episodes..but this one just didn't hit home for me. There were too many disconnects...too many story lines that didn't gel and I just didn't care for it. Perhaps a one hour regular Grey's with a second hour devoted to the spin off may have been easier to enjoy!!! Either way I love the show but don't know if the spin off will be as good...

I thought it jumped around too much, but I have no life so I'll watch the spin off lol. I love Taye Diggs so I have to watch!

I wasn't tooo thriled with this weeks show. I wasn't sure how I felt about a spin off but now I don't think I will watch it if it does for sure happen. I wanted it to be a normal episode but nope it wasn't. I love Derek and Merideth together and I don't want them to break up. But you never know with this show. And I can't stand Izzy.

To be completely honest, I didn't like this episode. I wasn't against the idea of a spin off, but the story was so boring... the characters so uninteresting... that I couldn't avoid the thought: "Kate... do you REALLY have to leave Grey's Anatomy to do THIS? Seriously? Seriously?!" I had some expectations, which were not fulfilled. I was hoping Addison would leave the SGH to do something really interesting. But it seems that is not what's going to happen. And what can I say about Grey's Anatomy? It used to be one of my favorite shows ever. But this 3rd season... it's being so boring since the beginning up to now. Bailey's not appearing how she used to, Preston just talks about the wedding, George doesn't have the slightest idea of what he's doing at all, Izzie suddenly stopped mourning to fall deeply in love with George... Good stories are not happening anymore. It's not funny anymore, it's always so dramatic and/or so boring. I know some people are enjoying the show anyway. But to me, it's not what it used to be. It's not what it was on its first 2 seasons. And I feel sad about that.