Is this considered stealing? / myLot

Philippines

May 9, 2007 5:50pm CST

If you take something from someone without the knowledge/consent of the owner but you have the intention of returning it before the owner knew it was missing, is this considered stealing or borrowing?

3 people like this

6 responses

afoolproofplan

@afoolproofplan (43)

• United States

9 May 07

I guess it all depends on how well you know the person. I mean if you know they wouldn't want you to it's iffy. But if you're sure they'll be alright with it... Will this person inform the owner?

4 people like this

earth2jacq

@earth2jacq (1502)

• Philippines

10 May 07

I think he wouldn't because he took that thing without the consent of the owner and he intends to return it without the knowledge of the owner as well. thanks for posting :)

1 person likes this

rainqueen21

@rainqueen21 (338)

• United States

9 May 07

ok technically it is stealing because the person doesn't know that you took it, but at the same time it is borrowing becaue you have the intentions of returning it...lol this is a good one http://musicfusion2day.blogspot.com http://latestrevolution.blogspot.com

3 people like this

earth2jacq

@earth2jacq (1502)

• Philippines

10 May 07

Yeah it is quite difficult to determine whether it is stealing or borrowing...confusing :) thanks for posting

1 person likes this

Lshauna1

@Lshauna1 (216)

• United States

15 May 07

Yes that is stealing. I don't believe you asked that question! If you was not stealing the item then you would've asked the person for permission to use or borrow the item. In the court system that is considered STEALING. that is just the same as going to the store and putting on a pair of pants or shirt and walking out the store without paying for it. Then the next day (returning the item)taking it back to return. THAT IS STEALING. No way around it just theft.

@earth2jacq (1502)

• Philippines

15 May 07

This is a hypothetical question. I did not say I am doing it. This was inspired by one of Spongebob Squarepants' (Nickelodeon channel) episode where Spongebob and Patrick took a balloon from a vendor with the intention of returning it...unfortunately the ballon burst so they were unable to return it and then they became fugitives wanted by law. Thanks for the post.

Lshauna1

@Lshauna1 (216)

• United States

16 May 07

I did not think it was you doing it? Spongeboob do be into some really strange things.

webeishere

@webeishere (36313)

• United States

9 May 07

In the yes of a court if there wasn't any discussion about borrowing said item it would be considered theft if reported as such. Bummer HAPPY POSTINGS FROM GRANDPA BOB !!~

3 people like this

courts

theft

earth2jacq

@earth2jacq (1502)

• Philippines

10 May 07

Yeah I think you have a point. thanks for posting.

1 person likes this

wifeofharvey

@wifeofharvey (1156)

• United States

10 May 07

It absolutely is stealing, I have no doubt about it at all. If you thought that the owner would lend it to you, you would have no problem asking. If you thought they would not lend it to you, then you are sneaking and taking something which is beyond a doubt stealing. I would make an exception if it was an emergency and something like you needed to drive my car to take someone to the hospital, or police station, and I wasn't available to give permission. Anything else is theft.

2 people like this

@earth2jacq (1502)

• Philippines

10 May 07

Thank you for posting :)

mamounz

@mamounz (248)

• Israel