DHONI Vs KARTHIK Who is a Better Player ???

We are not having two. But three Wicket batsmen at resent. It also includes our Captain Dravid. Also if they play Robbin Uthappa, we will be having four Wicketkeeper batsmen in our team. You cant compare Dhoni and Dinesh as both are equally good in their respective positions. Dhoni can play swashbuckling innings when needed and certain shots only which he can. Whil Dinesh Karthik always plays a rather composed innings and has most of the times shown that his selection as a batsman to be a good gamble. I will never compare these two. because at present both are playing good game. Its not like we can afford only one wicketkeeper batsman. If the four guys happen to be in the best of form, we may have a team with four specialist wicket keeper batsmen as they seem a better gamble than the others who struggle to make decent scores even against a bowling attack as weak as bangladesh.

Now Both of them wanted in the team... Karthick is better than Dhoni in Test and Dhoni is better than Karthick in ODI

I did not had very good impression on Dinesh Karthik until I see him yesteday. I thought Dinesh Karthik is more of a test player than ODI player. After seeing him yesterday, I think he is good ODI player. I would like to see both Dinesh Karthik and Dhoni in the 15 squad. This will keep both players in their feet and also will provide extra options for Indian team. Both can bat and both can keep wickets. This is good option and is better than taking a specialist bastsman.