Old Take That or New Take That ?

To be honest i love both, ive grown up with them so there ages reflect on there music. The past reminds me of my childhood singing along to tracks with my mum in the car and the present ones are fantastic to. The thing is there not trying to be something there not like 18 again or look like mutton dressed as lamb etc ao thats what makes them special. There music has grown with them but saying this, i think a lot of them still look funky break dancing but have noticed Gary Barlow doesnt join in on much of that these days, but what the heck hes got the fab singing voice so he shouldnt have to anyway and even though the lads are a bit older, if you can still pull it off i say go for it lads!

I liked the old Take That, but I prefare the new one. I love Robbie Williams though, he is my idol. I wish he had of came back with the group. My favourite songs are, Never forget, Back for good, Rule the world, Shine, Could it be magic and a Million love songs. In fact I just love all of them. I love the new album, 'Beautiful World'. I love Reach out, wooden boat and Mancunian way.

I grew up on their music too,and i think they have matured along with us,so i love the new songs,but i also always listen with pleasure the old ones,make me remember the teenage.

I love both of them. The part one gaves me the chance to live a great youth. I remember that I always listened to them in every second of the day!! I want to make it clear first that I've never left them or their music. I've been a Take That fan since 1994 and I kept on follow them as soloists trying to find infos on them,even when they split up.. Now,talking about the part two I love them because they are a bit different. We cannot consider them as a "boyband" anymore and they are more professional. Now that Rob is back again the dream come true!! I cannot believe it...and I hope to see them in five at least on time in my life!!

Both! I've been a massive thatter since 1994. I've seen them for the very first time in 2007 (as 4) and, 2 years ago the dreams came totally true! I've met the whole band! *_* I can't choose between the old and the new. They are amazing always!