where do u think are the other horcruxes??
By lloydbelleza
@lloydbelleza (1227)
Philippines
10 responses
@uu4h708 (638)
• Philippines
30 May 07
it seems that the reason why Dumbledore mentioned Nagini being a horcrux is because he wanted Harry to think/remember that there is a possibility that a living thing can be a horcrux... in order to create a horcrux, one must kill.. either by extreme hate or love.. and there is also one thing the creator must do.. (that, i wont tell for now) n_n
so nagini is not one of 'em, i think..
about harry, yes, it is quite obvious that he is one, and he was made as a horcrux accidentally, when voldemort tried to kill him,.. aside from transferring some powers to him, he also made him as a horcrux.. which would support what the other person said that voldemort did not kill harry but killed dumbledore, to support again that voldemort didnt know in the beginning but only came to realize about it after some events...
@uu4h708 (638)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
as far as i know..the only reason why harry could see what nagini/voldie sees is because he is a horcrux...
and as ive mentioned, when voldie found out that harry is a horcrux, he will stop the pursuit of killing of him.. but instead, will give harry a potion that will comatose him (with the expertise of snape of course)... voldie will give him the ________of______ ______... oh come on... i dont want to give out any more spoilers... hihihih.. not unless you really want it.. about the other questions... wait, let me read again...
@ram_cv (16513)
• India
27 May 07
I am not sure it is an horcrux within Harry. The two of them are related via the scar, but I don't think there is an horcrux within Harry. Also as these have been planned by Voldemort and the accident with Harry was something for which he was not prepared, hence I doubt if Harry is the horcrux!!
Cheers!
Ram
@prashanth1489 (748)
• India
6 Jun 07
Other horcruxes , they are the same ones harry and dumbledore predicted , only that they will find more than one horcrux in one place .
I can only say , Harry is not a horcrux , duh , some one pleas put the link to JK's Interview , she has confirmed it 10000 times that harry isnt a horcrux .
One can only predict ,
few may say nagini is one , but i think other wise , i think there are only six of them in all , the seventh one which he wanted to create was after killing harry which he failed at once .
@tyetuery (20)
• United States
29 May 07
Well, my aunt and I have been reading it through again and we've come up with quite a few theories. As far as the horcruxes go, we have narrowed at least most of them down to what we believe they could be.
1. The diary
(everyone knows that one)
2. The ring from his grandfather
(also, already known)
3. The locket in kreacher's cabinet
(i think most people have guessed that one already)
4. The cup of Hufflepuff
(also, i believe everyone's had suspicions about that one)
5. Nagini
(though Dumbledore things it's a bad idea to make a horcrux of something that can move and think of itselfm the snake represents a very powerful wizard that Voldermort idolized)
6. Harry Potter himself.
(this one is no more than a guess. Though him making Harry into a horcrux, or imbedding one in Harry would make sense, at the same time, it would not make sense as far as Voldermort wanting to kill him.)
7. Obviously something of Ravenclaw's.
(though I'm not sure what it might be)
That's about it though. Mere speculation and suspicion, but sometimes those coupled with a sharp mind and a lot of time can lead to the answers.
Anyone else have any ideas?
~Tye~
@kawaii24 (520)
• Australia
8 Jun 07
definitely not harry. Coz remember the prophecy, one of them has to die ...if harry is the horcrux then it will negate the prophecy itself.
Ok heres what I think the horcruxes are:
1. voldemort
2. ring
3.cup of hufflepuff
4. locket of slytherin
5. nagina/snake
6. diary
7. something made of ravenclaw
cant wait for the book 7 to come out hehehehe
@anc350 (326)
• India
27 May 07
Well to be honest, I am totally confused.
1. Harry has a lighting scar, and so does Slytherin's ring ( destroyed horcrux )
2. Voldy had Dumbledore killed but did not try to kill Harry. ( understood that harry was
horcrux )
3. Harry can sense / see Voldy's thoughts and visions.
4. HP & OPTP - Soul balance shows two snakes of smoke to dumbledore !!!
But it appears to be a bit too obvious and dont want to accept this as it is against popular choice also!!
@anaknitatay (1335)
• Philippines
28 May 07
didn't Dumbledore mention something about the connection between Voldemort and Harry with regards to the scar was over (Half-blood Prince)?
@Marcellinha (58)
• Brazil
28 May 07
I think that the other two that anyone know its the object of Ravenclow (I don't know how to write) and Harry, after I just don't acept this hypotisy but after I think....
Harry have some "powers" of voldemort, he knows how to sepak with the snakes, he can see the thinks af voldemort is thinkin like been just one person, he fell like voldemort fells, and why???
I think the one parto of the alm of voldemor go to harry wen he survive of the "avada kedavra" and acidently turn one horcrux.
In the 6 book say that have a magic for the person put one part of his alm in a object... maybe this magic is the avada kedrava becouse this kill, separete the alm, why can't be of the transfer alm too?
@carbyville (97)
• United States
27 May 07
At first I thought for sure the other horcrux was in Harry, but now I am not so sure. I think it might be too obvious, but maybe that is the point?