what would you do if someone told you a bad secret about your friend?

Philippines
May 27, 2007 4:10am CST
okay guys. this is fresh. i have this friend and she has a very nice and clean image with me and my other girl friends. but just lately, someone has been telling me some stories about my friend with the "clean" image. it seems that she is not as saintly as we thought after all and i was kinda wondering if i should tell my friend that there are some stories ("bad ones) going on about her or should i just go mum about it? if you were in my situation, what would you do?
6 people like this
36 responses
@sensesfail (2251)
• India
28 May 07
I would just give a damn about it.Its my friend and its my duty to trust my friend otherwise there's no point in being friends. On the other hand I'd go upfront to friend and talk to her about the accusations against her that way it'll clear any unresolved misunderstanding within. So i suggest that you talk to the person accused rather than talk to your other friends about it and going mum also will lead to problems.All the best.
1 person likes this
• India
2 Jun 07
well you cant always be shy.If you wanna take a ride , you gotta pay for the ticket.
• Philippines
28 May 07
oh okay. so you are saying that i should talk to my friend immediately and clear things up with her, am i right? well, it seems to be an easy thing to do, but you see, i am a bit shy therefore i have a hard time opening up to her. :(
• United States
27 May 07
Well i think i would tell my friend that someone is saying this or that about her behind her back. I mean, after all, would you want to know if this was happening to you? People like to talk, its entertainment to make others life misreable, for some people. Yes its wrong, but those people wont understand that until it happens to them. If the rumors happen to be true, she can explain why. I mean, more then likely it was nothing as major as these people are saying, they just needed to feed the fire, by stretching the truth.
• Philippines
28 May 07
hmm, yeah, you have a point there. if some gossip was running around about me, i would really appreciate if someone told me about it so that i could defend myself if ever it isnt true. well, thank you for your advice. :)
• United States
29 May 07
Your welcome... :)
@stella1989 (2274)
• India
28 May 07
Well I can take the bad story about my frined and find it by myself whether its all true or not.Without telling about it to my friend!! But just a harmless searching about my friends past.Mind it harmless searching!! If things doesn't seem alright then I can just walk over to my friend and ask her staright away. Thats it, will get things cleared off!! AS soon as I can. But I guess should talk to your frined first!
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, yes, thank you so much for your response. i think i have really gotten some reliable advices from all of you and i am very thankful for your participation. you are really good online friends, guys. :)
@lirael (501)
• Philippines
29 May 07
If I were in the same situation, I would keep mum about it. I would find out first if it was true, or just some nasty rumors to ruin her. If I find out that it wasn't, I would confront the one who told me and tell that person to stop spreading the lie. If it were true, well, I don't think it would make much of a difference in our friendship. Just as long as she's not a perverted, psycho something!lol!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
29 May 07
haha, well, thanks for your sensible and practical advice. :) i think i would have to decide whether to keep mum about the situation or not because it really involves some real nasty rumors about my saintly friend. lolz.
@Neo_Knights (1882)
• Indonesia
28 May 07
I would find more information about the issue. I usually get information easily, whether by asking for the right person or sometime the information came to me by itself. If it's true, then I will tell my friends, just inform them, but not in any intention to discredit him.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, that was one of my ideas too, to investigate privately without my friend knowing it. that way, i can get down to the bottom of the issue without having my friend know that i know something about the nasty rumor going on about her.
• Philippines
28 May 07
you've said that she is your friend...as a friend, i think you shouldnt judge her just bcoz someone told you about such bad things bout her..talk to her first, as her if it was true..and if it happens to be true, ask her some explanations and try to understand why it is so...
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, yes, i know. i am not really judging her. my dillema now is whether i should tell her that i know a bad rumor going on about her or should i just pretend that i dont know anything about it?
@JcHitomi (100)
• Nepal
28 May 07
hmmm actually I dont care about that gossips. For me they are just chiszms and rumors about that person, if ever that it is true well then Ill just have to wait to my friend will tell me about the truth but never will I opened about that gossips. I will just leave that and I will never talk about bad things to her. You know Im no where to judge.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
oh okay. so you are saying that you will not tell your friend about the ongoing gossips about her? wont she be mad at you for knowing about it and then just hiding it from her? well, i guess you are right. who are we to judge people anyway.. :)
@TriciaW (2441)
• United States
27 May 07
I really think you should tell her. Just say I needed to tell you something I heard because it is bothering me and I want you to know what is being said about you. This way you aren't saying you believe it and you are leaving it open for her to tell you if it is true or not. Be prepared for her to ask who told you because as anyone would she is going to want to know who is going to spread rumors about her. Myself I would tell her the person because it is my belief that if they want to spread rumors then they better be ready to be confronted. I really hate rumor spreaders.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
hello there. :) i have really gained a lot of insights from your response. yes, i would like to leave her that kind of impression, that i heard some nasty rumors about her but it doesnt mean that i believe it. the only problem is, i dont want to name names because the one who told me is also a friend of ours and i really dont want to bring conflict. that is why i am a bit hesitant to telly my friend about the rumor.
• India
27 May 07
Yes, I got into a similar situation just 2 months back. A friend told me something really nasty about my another very dear friend. I was shocked to hear that, but I didn't quite react in front of that person who told me the thing. Also I decided to keep mum, just to avoid any unnecessary quarrels, or problems. I am not sure if I chose the correct path, but I know that I certainly didn't believe in that nasty rumour. I know my dear friend very much, and I am not going to suspect him, based on some cheap rumour.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
oh, okay. so i guess everything went well even though you just kept mum about it. me too, i really dont believe the rumors going on about my friend. my respect for her is still intact. well, i sure hope the rumors about my friend would die down, especially if it isnt true.
• Canada
28 May 07
I personally would go to your friend and say, I'm sorry, I've heard some rather nasty things about you and I just want to know whether they're true or not. I would stress that you're not casting doubt or anything, but you just want to hear from her what the truth is. If these things are true, then she has a chance to come clean. If not, then at least you can go back to the other person and say "hey, quit with the lies, they're putting you in a very bad light."
• Philippines
28 May 07
well, thank you for your sensible advice. you make it seem so easy and simple. well, i hope i have the guts to tell my friend about this, you see, i am not really the type of person who is comfortable in confronting people. lolz.
@Zelmarq (12607)
• Cebu City, Philippines
28 May 07
Dont fuel the gossip. Let it end on you for passing it one wont do any good and others mught think ill of your friend. Its not good to spread this around and it would be very shameful on the part of your friend. if you were on her shoes surely you wont feel good about it. If I were you I will try to keep it to myself, I would try to settle the issue with my firned if I will be given the chance to.
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, you are right, it is really not advisable to fuel the gossip. what i am trying to do is try to settle the issue with my friend and try to ask her if it is true. the problem is, i am hesitant in asking her because i am a bit shy. lolz.
• United States
28 May 07
I would not say anthing to her. If the stories that you are hearing are untrue, then your friend could be very hurt. I would just stand up for her, unless I knew without a doubt that the stories were true. I don't like to be involved in any type of rumor mill, so I would just let it be. If the situation continues or gets out of hand I would probably just give my friend a heads up about the stories that are going around. That way she herself could confront the people saying these things, and she could stand up for herself, or do whatever she feels is best.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, that was what i did. i stood up for her and i told the person who shared the rumor to me that i have a hard time believing her because i know for a fact that my friend has a good heart and i couldnt believe that she could do something like what the rumor said.
• United States
28 May 07
My mom's favorite piece of advice is "believe nothing that you hear and only half of what you see." This seems to fall into that category. However, I am also one who not only wants to know the truth, I want others to know the truth. if the "clean" friend does not know about these rumors, she cannot defend herself against them. I would privately discuss the situation with her, letting her know what you heard and even where it originated from. This would give her the chance to either admit to it/deny it, explain it and/or confront the person who said it. If she denies it and you continue to hear nasty rumors, I would just tell the person who keeps spreading them that you are not interested.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
hey, you know, i really like your mom's advice. :) your mom seems to be so wise and full of wisdom. :) yes, i guess you are right, my friend really does have the right to know about the rumors about her so that she can defend herself and she can tell me if that is true or not.
• Philippines
28 May 07
Ill just be quiet and pretend that i dont know anything. You know it is bad if we pretend to our friends or relative, but if its for good sake. Why not do that. Rather than telling your friends what his/her negative sides is. I cant do that to my friend.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, i agree, some things are better left unsaid and im wondering if this is one of those times when i have to just keep quiet. i am still a bit confused on what to do..
• India
27 May 07
What the others are saying about your friend must not matter to you. As long she is good to you,nothing should concern you at all. Friendship is one step above trust, if you dont trust you are not a good friend.I dont think you should be really be bothered about your friend's past,all secrecy in life.I would suggest you not to talk to your friend about this the the time he/ she is willing to discuss it with you.
• Philippines
28 May 07
well, yes, you are right. my friend is good to me and good in my eyes. however, i just dont want other people to be talking and gossiping about her behind her back. it would hurt me a lot if my friend got hurt because of that.
@magikrose (5429)
• United States
28 May 07
This friend of yours has a right to know that people are talking about her. She has a right to clear her name. PLus you can find out the truth from her directly.
@magikrose (5429)
• United States
28 May 07
That is all the more reason to tell her what is going on. A rumor like that could completely ruen her reputation.
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, yes, i do agree with you. my friend clearly has the right to know what is going on. the problem is, i just have no guts to tell her straightforwardly because the rumor is just too nasty and maybe she will get so shocked or hurt.
• Philippines
29 May 07
yes, i know, i think i have the mission to stop people from ruining her reputation. i would feel really bad if what's going on about her isnt true and i just let it happen. :(
@34momma (13882)
• United States
28 May 07
if someone told me something bad about a friend of mine i would tell them. because i would want to know if someone was talking bad about me. i mean if this is a good friend then you should let her know
• Philippines
28 May 07
hello there. well, you are right. i would also like to know if someone was talking about me, or gossiping about me. she is really a good friend, so maybe i'll just tell her. oh my, i am still confused.
@syndhujaa (252)
• India
27 May 07
hmm..It all depends on person to person..how they take it.. but If someone comes and tell something wrong about me then i might not yell back at them but i will not trust it unless and untill it is confirmed..i cant trust people simply and it might be some nasty rumour and i will definately not tell my friend abt this even this is true.. that is for sure..!!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
oh, okay. so you are saying that you wont confront your friend about the rumor going on about her?
@stacy624 (2776)
• Canada
27 May 07
I would for sure bring it to her attention, it may help her see if these rumors are true to straighten up. Sometimes when we are wrapped up in issues we don't see what it is we are doing. But if these are not true then she will let you know I'm sure. Best of luck to you Stacy
• Philippines
28 May 07
hello stacy. well, i guess i should gather up enough guts to tell her about the nasty rumors going on about her. but i hope that i can really have the guts because it is a really nasty rumor. oh my.. wish me luck stacy.. :)
@stacy624 (2776)
• Canada
28 May 07
You can do it, invite her to for coffee don't worry to much I'm sure it will all be good in the end. I'm here for you please keep me posted! I will be thinking of you. Best of Luck! Stacy
• Philippines
29 May 07
oh.. :) that's a nice idea. thank you so much for your advice, my friend. :) i really appreciate you taking your time to answer my discussion and help me with my problem. :) mwah. GOd bless you!
• China
27 May 07
first of all keep it first to yourself and dont believe immediately try to observe it by yourself and know more about her/his attitudes and characteristics then at the end u can conclude who really is... there are times also people maybe bad in the past but maybe trying to change to become good so the best thing to do stop , look and listen and dont make it a big deal.....
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
yes, yes, i have ahard time believeing the rumor anyway. i am really trying to not make it a big deal. sometimes, i just wanna shrug it off and just forget that i heard a rumor like that about her. lolz.