smacking a child

father and son - responsible parents
Philippines
May 31, 2007 10:26am CST
when i was a young child, as a punishment i was smacked. i was old enough to understand why i was being smacked, and old enough to learn from it. i was hard enough to cause some pain, for me to learn what i did was wrong. but not hard enough to be abused. i respect my parents for it, and it certainly has worked better than the groundings and technology-banning i get now i am teen. and when i have children, i will most likely use the same forms of discipline my parents used. time outs for real little kids, smacks for junior primary kids, and groundings and technology-banning for older than that. i know that time again my kids will disprove theories that worked for my parents, so that's likely to change. and i would never smack another person's child. * * * * * what i would like to know is: do you think we should be allowed to smack our children as discipline (provided it does not become abusive) and what other punishments could/should be implemented? * * * * * and i realize this probably isn't the first time there's been a thread on this, if all you're going to do is tell me that, save both your time and mine..just don't bother. if you're going to tell me it's wrong to smack a child, tell me why!
5 responses
@kawaii24 (520)
• Australia
7 Jun 07
Ive been smacked by my mom to discipline me when i was young. I know some frown about this method however, I believe as long as its not excessive then smacking a child is okay...trust me based from my experience it worked for me hehehehe lol
• United States
7 Jun 07
I, personally, don't spank my kids. I was spanked as a child and I was one that learned from it. However, I have seen kids who don't learn from that type of discipline. I don't think it should be up to the government to tell anyone how to raise their kids unless, as you said, the child is being abused. I think there is a huge difference between spanking as discipline and abuse. I have seen it cross the line though and that is where things get tricky. I don't spank my kids because I would rather use other forms of discipline where they can learn why what they did was wrong. I use time outs on occasion as well as other discipline techniques I have researched. I don't want my kids to think hitting anyone is okay.
@inked4life (4224)
• United States
31 May 07
Like you, I was spanked as a child and have shown no ill-effects from it. As a parent though I choose not to spank my kids for the simple reason that I teach them not to hit other kids or each other. It would be pretty hypocritical of me if I am hitting them at every turn. I find that setting rules, being consistent with them, and having a suitable punishment (taking away toys or tv privileges works great) has a very good effect if you keep on top of it.
• United States
31 May 07
I am 18, but when I was younger, I did get smacked and punished. It does help. If a child is talking backing I feel they should get smacked because just words wont teach them to stop. If you tell the child once to not do something and they do it again they should get hit. I mean like you said, not to an abusive way but a way to make them learn the right from wrong and maybe the pain will teach them not to do it again than just yelling at them. I feel that kids should get punished and hit, and the whole I'm telling the police thing on you, is lame and I wouldn't care because I dont think you can get introuble for it if they dont have any marks on them or if your not beating them. Kids these days need to get hit for there actions because half of them dont think anyays.
• United States
31 May 07
I was definitely hit as child and I turned out fine. I was never smacked or hit in the face though. I do believe children should be discipline but only as a last resort and they should be old enough to understand why they are being spanked. I know I am very grateful for my parent's discipline, I was very disobedient and I don't know how I would've turned out had my parents just removed TV for a week or gave me time out - things that really didn't affect me or bother me in any way. I also think it's important for the parent to know their child. If the child hates being alone staring at a wall, than time out is the best for that child - not spanking. Children are all different and what's punishment for one can be absolutely nothing for another.