Should you force someone to learn something?

@h_gaurd9 (986)
United States
June 2, 2007 10:19am CST
Has anyone ever asked this? I think it's partially true that when somebody has to learn, they need to be pushed a little. But heres the thing, people turn away from things they are forced into. Like when it comes to religion. You can't force somebody to learn religion because they will turn away from. I'm sounding repetitive, but am I wrong to think you shouldn't be forced on something?
4 people like this
18 responses
@wonderful1 (2075)
• China
3 Jun 07
I never force someone to learn something except myself. I force me to learn Japanese, because I like Japanese cartoons, such as bleach and naruto. I don't want to see the words only, I hope I can know what they said. It is more funny, I think. I force me to leave majiang, it is a gambling game. I lost over $150 in a week, and I earn only $150 a month now. So I have to give up it. Do you think it is addicted? Do you play some gambling games? Good luck, friend.
@h_gaurd9 (986)
• United States
3 Jun 07
I don't play Majiang but I've heard of it. I don't play gambling games because I'm not of the age. Thanks for your response!
• Singapore
2 Jun 07
Forcing someone to learn is not the most effective way to learn. With no passion or motivation or interest, the person forced to learn might subconsciously or intentionally resist learning. So what's the point really? That person is upset because he has to do something he does not like. The person forcing is upset because because that person he is forcing is not learning it well. So it becomes a lose-lose situation. The best way for this is to find a way to motivate the person to want to learn it himself. But of course, religion is something you can't force. You can't learn a religion even if you want to really learn. To know God, you need to use your heart. You may memorize your scriptures well but that's different from knowing God.
• Singapore
4 Jun 07
Geez, thanks for best response! ;-)
• India
2 Jun 07
Forcing people to learn has some advantages and disadvantages. You can not force adults to learn if they are not interested. You can force children to learn things because they don't what they want and you can put seeds in their mind to learn.
@h_gaurd9 (986)
• United States
2 Jun 07
Good responses! I see your points as to why it doesn't work for adults but children instead.
• United States
28 Jun 07
No. It's somehow unethical to force someone into learning something, especially when (s)he might not like what that person is teaching. If we did force someone into learning something, we'd be no better than the fascists and Nazis of World War II. No. People have free will. They'll learn things on their own. And if someone forces another to learn, it may make his/her learning process slower. It's better to let him/her learn on one's own time. Free will is what counts.
• India
2 Jul 07
I don't think so by forcing anybody he can learn....Somebody can only learn when he has interest...So its better to leave on that person who has to learn..
• India
3 Jun 07
no we cant force someone to learn something because it will stay in mind if they r not willing to learn we must leave me them if they learn with interest they will not forget it easily
• India
3 Jun 07
no,it is not possible to force anybody to learn something.because i think every body has hi/her own identity ..and to make them learn something forcefully means to detect terms onthem.. nobody will appreciate this...even in case of religion...it should come naturally from within.
@magnel (2263)
• India
3 Jun 07
Yes you cannot force anyone to learn something, but you can always tell all the good that will happen when they learn those things...
@Sir_bobby88 (8231)
• Singapore
3 Jun 07
No we should not force someone to learn something when he/she dosen't want to learn it yea .... i mean no point helping them since they don't want help ownself yea
• United States
3 Jun 07
no good, u can persue or show them the advantages of learning anything, but not by pushing, lil bit of pushing is okay, but dont bit up someone to do it.
@azimsay (543)
• India
3 Jun 07
We can not force to any one to learn something ,because other person like other things to learn.Why we should force them to learn.Some one is like drowing ,swimming,studies,sewing,cooking,amradaries .All are not thinking same thing and liking same thing.So do not force some one to learn wich is you like.
• United States
3 Jun 07
If i want somebody to learn something, i will not forced them because its better to learn in their own way than pushing them.
• India
3 Jun 07
I dont think u can force anyone to learn something.if u will do he wont he would not learn in his life time.if some body has an interest we can force that person.
• Philippines
3 Jun 07
Forcing a person to learn something is not really a good sight. That person should be interested what she/he wants to learn so that they wont turn away from it and that they really would learn something about it.
@magikrose (5429)
• United States
2 Jun 07
I dont think any one should be forced to do anything they dont want to do. They may come to resent you for forcng them in the first place. all you can do is voice your opnion and encourage but in the end it is there decision to learn it or not. The other thing to remember is you dont want to be pushy either. If they say no then leave it at that and dont bring up the issue again unless they do.
@friendship (2084)
• Canada
2 Jun 07
Yes, we can't force someone to learn something. Otherwise, he will not learn anything. Learning something should come from himself. Forcing someone to learn something can get a disappointed result. You have already spent time to ask, beg or force him but your efforts won't be heard at all.
• Canada
2 Jun 07
I agree that the harder you push sometimes will only make the other person more determined to do things their way and not listen to what you have to say . Everyone likes to make their own decisions and does not like to think that they were forced into doing someting they didn't want to do . I know for myself that if someone is persistent then it just makes me mad and then I don't want to listen to anything they have to say but if they give me options then I am more willing to listen to their point of view . We do have to push on ceratin issues but issues such as religion is for each to decide what is right for them as I don't believe there can be a right or a wrong when it comes to religion as there is no way to prove that one is better then another .
• United States
3 Jun 07
I've never tried it, and I wouldn't want to. They are really learning it out of fear, and they won't really learn it.