Would you stay with a man who hits you?
By mycharm88
@mycharm88 (2288)
Philippines
June 7, 2007 9:20pm CST
Would stay with your boyfriend even if he hits you? This happens to one of my friends. She's beautiful and a very good friend of mine. I just knew this lately for she's been hiding the bruises on her legs and arms. I noticed it when we tried some clothes at the mall. I just don't understand why she wouldn't
let me report her boyfriend even to her parents, she said she loved him so much, she's willing to endure the pain. I hate the guy for doing this.
What can i do? Do share your thoughts pls.
16 people like this
53 responses
@magica (3707)
• Bulgaria
8 Jun 07
No and i have really wondered to theese women who develop a Stockhold syndrome to their abusers. In fact the love and the physical abuse are two different things.And there is no excuse for a man who hits the loved woman.Sorry for your friend, but she must dare to leave if she doesnt want to be a slave of man like this.
4 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
I totally agree with you magica, i just don;t know how to convince her to leave him. I'm feeling sorry for her and always tell her to wake up and find another one who would truly love her, but would just walk away.
2 people like this
@nandhinir (154)
• India
8 Jun 07
I agree with you Magica...Why she is wasting for the one who hits her
@liminghuan (10)
• China
9 Jun 07
I think he need this hurt to proof her realiy love some body,and find this is true love ,she may think if can conqueale this abuse then will find some satisfaction!
this comment come from one of psychopathy books.
hehe ,some way is confimed by the begin
@mrsbrian (1949)
• United States
8 Jun 07
I would never stay with a man that hit for any reason and i dont know how you can love a man that hurts you. I hope your riend wises up before it is to late. I think all you can do is be there for her Is this girl a minor or an adult? if she is a minor her parents do need to know about this,but she needs to stop this now before it gets out of hand.
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
She's only 21, that's what i told her that her parents need to know about this. She warned me not to tell anyone, told me she'd just handle it herself. she doesn't need my help.I 've always been there for her whenever she needed me, i always thought it was just a normal fight with the boyfriend.She never told me that she's been hurt physically.
2 people like this
@TheCatzMeow1 (579)
• United States
8 Jun 07
Love is blind. Love is all that matters to some people. Once they get a hold of it, the don't want to let it go no matter what the consequences are. The abuser usually apologizes and promises to change, so the abused lives on that hope. I know someone who has stuck it out. Her partner has changed for the most part, but once in awhile it all comes back to bite her. She even says she doesn't know why she puts up with it, but she loves him.
If she doesn't want help, there's not much you can do besides being there for her when she needs someone to lean on.
No, I would never stay with a man who hits me. He would pay for his actions if he did.
2 people like this
@TheCatzMeow1 (579)
• United States
9 Jun 07
You're right, there are many like her out there. Sure I'll help you pray for her. May God open her eyes and protect her all the same.
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
I just can't live with a life like my friend does. He means the world to her. She is blinded, she doesn't want see the truth that he's no good for her. It's odd right? but people like her does exists. Thanks friend... pLS. help me pray for her.
1 person likes this
@jhoanee (598)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
i remember once ive been into that kind of relationship. my ex hit me twice. at first i forgive him coz after he did it he ask forgiveness until to the point that he try to kneel just to ask my forgiveness, because i loved him so much and remember the good days weve been together i forgived him and ask him not to do it again. he didnt do it for a couple of months until one day it was our company outing and i ask him to come with me. after the party we went to our house but there was one instances that makes him mad and hit me again. it was the second time i had bruises and still try to cover it so that my sister or may parents wont seen it. again he still do the same act of asking my forgiveness. i guess i was stupid then and think that there would any man love me the way he did when he is not mad. i forgive him for the second time even if it hurts a lot. i cant forget the day he is doing it. but one day he lives for another girl. i guess it was a blessing in disguise coz our relationship ended by then. althought i tried to fixed the relationship and willing to forgive him but i guess that was god's plan for me. it took me 2 years for the process of forgetting him. i guess i just love him so much thats why its hard to forget despite the bad things that happen to us. but now i am happy with the man who loves me and never tried to hurt me both physically and emotionally. it was one of the things that i wont forget about the past. i learned a lot from it. i cant blame girls who still try to understand and forgives there partner but if the actions still there i guess its time for them to wake up and leave the relationship while theres still a way to leave so that no one wont regret later. have a nice day!
@jhoanee (598)
• Philippines
11 Jun 07
there are things in the past that hurt us but in a way it make us who we are now. at first i was really shy to share my story but then i realized that it happend to me and i cant changed anything about it. what matter is i had learned a lot from it. i know it is impossible for me to hope but still i do wish it wont happen again to any woman. if ur in the situation its hard to say no or get out specially if u love your partner. it was a process and decision that i should make within myself. i understand woman who is in the same boat as am i, yes its true that it is stupidity to continue the relationship but for sure in some case they also have there reasons and with that i respect them. i just hope that sooner or later they will realized that theres a lot nice things in this world that will come into there life they just need to be open with the options that comes. thanks a lot and i can say i am perfectly fine now, im still hoping that he will change into a better person inorder for him to have a happy life too. godbless u!
1 person likes this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
I'm touched by your story jhoanee.. You are very strong in dealing with this kind of situation and have a strong faith in God. I think you are very special and kind hearted, i'm just glad that you have finally found someone to love you and would never hurt you. Yeah.. past can really hurt us, but we had much to learn from it. Thank you very much for sharing this.
1 person likes this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
12 Jun 07
So nice of you to say that for him, you do have a forgiving heart! God bless you Friend
@aprilsong (1884)
• China
8 Jun 07
My god,your friend is really silly and weak.Yes,there are lots of men who beat their wives,but the wives nowadays have their choices,right?Why stay with such brute person?Why not report his bad deed to parents or even authorities.U know,men is such a kind of animal,the more you love and be afraid of them,the more worse they treat u.
If your friend do love her husband very much and do not want to leave him. I think she should at least give him a warning or a lesson,to let him know his deed is wrong. Or else,she will live a miserable life in her rest life,and can not get respect from her husband.
3 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
It's worse for her april because they're not married yet. He is just a boyfriend, I tried to make her understand that her life would be miserable with him. But she insisted that she'd handle it herself. Oh how i hate that guy!
1 person likes this
@wondericequeen (7876)
• Hong Kong
8 Jun 07
No way, who would enjoy the pain given by your loved ones, no matter physically or psychologically. Doesn't your friend see that the guy doesn't really treasure her as a respectful human being? I think it's good to talk to her about it and don't let love "blind" her eyes and nerves. It's a very unhealthy relationship. I would never stay with someone who hit me and I would report him to the police because I know from my heart that that person can't love me that much or at all if he is using physically violence!
2 people like this
@wondericequeen (7876)
• Hong Kong
8 Jun 07
No way, civilized people talk instead of fighting against each other. That distinguishes us from animals. Sometimes I just don't understand some of the women at all, it's like they love to be tortured by men and they thought this is what called love. I don't think so. Even if she has done something wrong, the guy should not hit her! He should talk with her.
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
Same here, never would i stay with a man who hits a woman. I just don't understand my friend, she keeps on telling me that she loves him inspite of the bruises. Sometimes she tells me that it's her fault, is that an excuse for him to hurt her?
2 people like this
@samtaylorskykierajen (7977)
• Canada
8 Jun 07
I realize as a friend this is hard to understand but the truth is she does probably really love him , she is also scared and doesn't know how to face her fear . She feels all alone in this and can't imagine what life will be like without the guy she is with . She is emotionally and physically broke down . When someone abuses someone else they break that person down so they can gain complete control of them . I don't know what I would do . Honestly I would love to say that I would leave in a heartbeat but you don't ever know what you will do until faced with a sitatuation yourself . You can assume what you would do or go based on what you think you would do but what one does and what one says they will do when faced with this are not always the same things as you have no idea what the feelings and fear are that control a person into doing what they do .
As her friend all you can do is be there for her and let her know that no matter what you will never abandon her even if you don't understand her .
Take Care !!
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
12 Jun 07
Yeah, she always tells me that she really loved him and could not live without him. That she wants to deal with this alone. It's hard to see her hurting.. Thank you friend for the response.
@cherriemae (3370)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
of course, i would really hate him and don't stay with him...it's not good to hit a person, whether your a boy or a girl, specially, when a man hits a lady..it's abusing, need that person to be go to jail..in the case of your friend, having so much love with her bf really have disadvantage because she can hide the pain because of love..and it's not good because i'm sure her bf don't have respect and love to her anymore that's why his doing that bad thing..all you can do friend is that be at her side always,encourage her that she's living in a terrible life,pray for her hoping everything would be fine, soon..good luck friend..Gob Bless..
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
She use to tell that she felt so loved by her boyfriend. She would always say that he was so sweet and i believed her before i knew what he has done to her. I dont really understand why she is so inlove when he's been hitting her. I'm trying to convince her to leave him but as of now, she wants me to back off.
1 person likes this
@MJLami (1173)
• United States
8 Jun 07
The first time someone hits me will be their last. I grew up with men who don't hit and will not suffer one that does. Your friend's self-esteem is in the gutter with her believing she should endure this pain because she loves him. You can guide her ti care for herself and you can show her there are other options out there but she ultimately has to be the one to decide the pain is not worth enduring and choose to end it. Be her friend and support her even if she keeps going back for more. One day she will thank you for sticking by her even when she gave up on herself.
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
12 Jun 07
It's nice that you grew up with men who don't hit like i do and so does my friend.I will surely stay for my friend.. To listen and just be there for her. Thanks
1 person likes this
@lisacor (7)
• India
8 Jun 07
i already hate the guy.....who does he think he is........report him.....i mean sure your friend might hate you for a while...but she'll survive...i hate when guys even shove their opinions in my face....if that happened to me i might wanna shoot him...convince ya friend against him....if she doesn't want your interference....then obviously stay out of her affairs..
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
I'm trying to convince her and i'm staying by her side. Thanks lisacor... You take care friend.
1 person likes this
@pallidyne (858)
• United States
8 Jun 07
She needs some serious counselling. The problem with people being abused is that they so rarely seek help, and its almost impossible to help them until they really want it. If you call the cops, I'm betting she'll deny anything happened.
Support her, give her love and friendship. If an intervention is needed get help from her parents and others around her.
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
12 Jun 07
You are right about that Pallidyne.. I'm giving her all my support as a friend.
@clannad (40)
• United States
8 Jun 07
Iam a man. And there is no excuse, and NO situation exists to where a man ...lover...friend ... spouse ...whatever., should ever lay one finger on the woman that he suposidly loves. Anger is a management issue... hitting on woman is a criminal issue. Ill turn him in myself! Whats the name of the guy and number?
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
I'm pretty sure that you are one sweet guy who would never do such a thing to anyone...Thank you so much for being a friend I wish i have somebody like you here close to her to help her with this.
1 person likes this
@redhorton (58)
• United States
8 Jun 07
I did that too when I was married to my x. It takes a lot to leave someone you love. As a friend don't abandon her. Stay with her. What it is on her part is insecurity. Hopefully she won't get hurt. But it is very dangerous to stay in an abusive relationship even if it is just verbal it usually escolates farther and farther each time.
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
12 Jun 07
Hi redhorton!! I would never live my friend, I really do hope that she'll get over him soon.
@deejay0312 (15)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
I think not. Though I know it is really hard to let go if you love someone but Women are made to be respected, nurtured and loved. Here in our country, there is a law against that. I hope your friend is okay though.
@maryannemax (12156)
• Sweden
8 Jun 07
i am glad that we have women's rights here in the philippines. such cases should not be tolerated. just like what deejay said, women should be cared for not being used as a punching bag. there's no sense in keeping such an immature relationship at all... anne
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
My friend love's him so much, she forgives him. A sof this time they're still together, there is not much that i can do if she wont let me help her. I'm always reminding her that i'm always here for her. Thanks Suman...
1 person likes this
@chaime (1152)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
Never. Not in any circumstances should a man hit a woman, no matter if the woman has a fault.
I suggest you talk to your friend, as friend, do not judge her or tell her off, just listen to her be a friend to her, maybe she has a deeper ahm shall we say insecurity that's why she stays with her boyfriend even though he hurts her. And if you find out what that is, that is where you will start to build up her self esteem belief in herself, because only she can gather her own strength to leave her boyfriend.
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
Thanks for the advice chaime. I think you're right..
1 person likes this
@teleios (737)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
that's a typical emotion that women in abusive relationships feel, that they love the guy too much to be able to leave, and that the guy feels the same way. i know that perhaps if we we're in her shoes it would also be difficult to think objectively,especially if we feel that we really love the guy, that he is IT. however, i think the only thing you can do is stand by your friend, and let her see that this relationship is not doing her any good.
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
Thanks Teleios... That's what im trying to do, i tried to convince her that she's better off without him. but doesn't listen. I won't leave her, and praying for her.
1 person likes this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
Yes ice, i really hope she does soon. I don't want her to get hurt again with that guy. Thanks for your response.
1 person likes this
@pearl_angel (42)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
No, I don't approve violence against women. Even if you're married to that man. You should learn to respect yourself if you want others to respect you. I have learn it the hard way. My 5years relationship ended because he was living with another woman although he live with us before. He was hot tempered and everystings seems to upset him. t was because he had another girl. He left us and live with her. Me and son left and I found out I was pregnant with our youngest and I gave birth without him. After that I have move on and plans for our future but when his mother asks us to visit home and let their father see his sons, so we did go home. But to my dismay he welcome me with bruises because I hid the photo of him and the girl at our old room, my son saw it and told me about it I was crushed because when he was telling me he was tearry eyed an d I couldn't bear how hurt he was. So i hid the photo. He came home and that was the first thing he looked. He found it missing and hit me, choke me and say bad things to me. Infront of our sons. It was horrible, my eldest was watching us as he hurt me. The baby was crying as if he wanted to help me. His friend rushed over to stop him and pacify his anger. I no longer kow the person I have loved before. We left early in the morning, away from him, away from his cruelty.
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
I really hate people like them who hits women, specially in your case that he did it on front of your babies. Poor babies of yours and you also, it's a good thing to leave him and never ever let him see you and the kids ever!Thanks for sharing Pearl_angel.. take care and do kiss your babies for me.
1 person likes this
@knakamitsu (33)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
Never stay with a guy who hits woman. She should realise that she has been spending her precious lifetime with the most cowardly man. Waste of time. By the way, what if a woman hits a man, can we also apply the same logic?
2 people like this
@mycharm88 (2288)
• Philippines
9 Jun 07
Glad to hear that from you Knakamitsu!! Yup! i think i think so. It's just not right to hit anyone, and that goes to everyone of us... Thank you so much for the response.
1 person likes this