Home school vs Public school
By rosehunter51
@rosehunter51 (17)
United States
June 8, 2007 1:01am CST
I have been considering homeschooling my 5 year old. I have done the research and the cost. I don't like the public schools in my area and feel that sports is given the lion share of the money. There is not enough emphasis put on the subjects that are going to be useful in the real world, nor are they rewarded for the hard work it takes to be the best in math,sciences,english or writing.
Any thoughts out there, Pro or Con?
1 person likes this
6 responses
@Nardz13 (5055)
• New Zealand
8 Jun 07
Home School: is neat and more relaxed, there are so many benefits from being home schooled, the downer is, you may not come out socialable, anti social...
Public School: Your surrounded by different influences, therefore you must make some wise dicisions and try not too feel peer pressured, and the stressed from some teachers, not all teachers just some. The Upside You get to make new friends, and go out on field trips...
@rosehunter51 (17)
• United States
8 Jun 07
One thing that I have learned is that you can do all kinds of field trips and make friends anywhere so that isn't a down side. Thanks for all the input
@grecychunny26 (9483)
• Philippines
8 Jun 07
If it is cheaper to homeschool your toddler then do it. It is good that you have decided that and your thinking of your child safety. Hat off to you rosehunter.
@rosehunter51 (17)
• United States
8 Jun 07
not sure if its cheaper unless you count the time I would have to spend at the school and miss work. But I feel that the whole education thing is so much better.
@lillake (1630)
• United States
8 Jun 07
I am very pro-homeschooling. You can give a better, more custom fit ediucation with homeschooling that will allow your child to show their own talents. That, to me, is much better than the one-size-fits-all approach found in public schools. Also, despite the common myth, homeschooling opens doors for a better social experience. Rather than being locked up in a room all day with a group of children the same age and from the same background homeschool children are out and in the "real world" on a daily basis. They are avble to learn how to behave socially from adults rather than from other children just as socially imature as them. also they get to experience how the world works rather than just reading about it in a book. You can read more here. http://momisteaching.com
And here's a great debate to read: Is homeschooling better than formal education? http://www.helium.com/channels/793-Homeschooling/debates/sbs/65926-homeschooling-better-formal-education
You can read my reply to the debate here. http://www.helium.com/tm/356083/difficult-answer-because-situation
@rosehunter51 (17)
• United States
8 Jun 07
thanks for the input. I agree with what you said 100%. My biggest fear is the socialization. Hunter is an only child and I fear that he will be missing something. However I also feel some of what he misses he doesn't need to know at age 7 or 8. 2 days of daycare a week take care of all the bad things I have to retrain or explain is bad and why!
@Nardz13 (5055)
• New Zealand
9 Jun 07
Hi again: Public School, Your surrounded by different influences, therefore you must make some wise dicisions and try not too feel peer pressured, and the stressed from some teachers, not all teachers just some. The Upside You get to make new friends, and go out on field trips... Personally there is no down side to field trips... Read again, your reply wasnt relevant to my post... Thanks for ??? :)
@luv2cook4u (398)
• United States
8 Jun 07
I just finished my first "official" year of homeschooling my 6 year old and will start with my soon to be 5 year old this fall. (I actually start homeschooling at a much younger age, but they officially start at 5/6). There are many pros to homeschooling and the only negative I have found is the ned to find and provide curriculum (which is actually rather easy) and the need to provide for many, varied social activities. The social aspect can be overcome with active involvement in a homeschooling group, church, scouts, and/or town sports/activities. There really is a ton of support and information out there.
@mon_aranha (39)
• Ecuador
8 Jun 07
I'm a homeschooling unschooling mama to my 2yo (not officially unschooling yet, but we're already in the path). I think homeschooling not only will cost you less money, but will provide your kid a better quality education, based on his/her own needs in the right time.
Homeschooling should work for every family willing to make it work, so I don't see any cons if that's what you want to do.
I encourage you to find homeschoolers in your area and meet their families to see how it works differently but fine for every family.
If you worry about socialization, take a look at how kids attending school socialize with adults. No doubt they socialize with their peers, but even in school it is very common to find groups by race, social class, etc...not true socialization. Do schooled children really have good socialization skills? Is being a bully or his victim part of normal socialization?
If you're interested, I strongly encourage you to read the book Hold on to your Kids, by Dr. Gordon Neufeld. A lot of issues have become clearer once I read his book/attended an online class. Not sure if I can add a link to his page here, but you can easily find his site googling his name.
Hope I've been of help