Perfume and other scents

Perfume - A bottle of perfume
@emeraldisle (13139)
United States
July 5, 2007 2:29pm CST
Should they be allowed in the work place? Right now in the City of Detroit one worker is suing the city on this very topic. She claims that the scents used by a colleague have made her sick and made her miss work along with other problems. A similar case was heard back in 2005, also in Detroit where the complainant won against the employer and was granted monetary reward. Now I'll be honest here and say I'm very allergic to many perfumes and scents. I deal with it for the most part and avoid them when possible however there are times when one can't. So now I'm curious what others think on this? Do you think that perfumes, colognes and air fresheners should be banned? You can read about this here and it does mention the (2005 case at the bottom) here: http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2007707040355 I'm really looking forward to hearing what others think on this.
4 people like this
8 responses
• United States
12 Jul 07
Humm...I don't know. I think that if the case is that someone is allergic to another persons cologne, perfume or body spray then the person wearing it should respectfully either change scents, go lightly on it (cause a lot of times it could be a matter of them over doing it), or stop wearing it all together. I think we're getting on a fine line here because everything smells. Shampoos, conditioners, body wash - and I'm honestly afraid of how far something like this could go. Honestly I can't stand the way some spray deodorant smells to the point of nausea. I've made my hubby switch until we've found one that I can tolerate. But he's got to where deodorant. I don't think it fair either that everyone should have to pay for one or two scents being a problem. I think their should be some compromise made. And I don't think that it's too much to ask of a person either to switch scents, ect. I might be bummed about wearing my favorite scent at work but I would understand. Besides I can always where it outside of the workplace.
2 people like this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
14 Jul 07
I think a lot depends on how this woman is wearing it. If it's too much on or if it's the other woman being too sensitive to it. The woman suing though when she took the job did not have any problems with working there, it was only after the co-worker came into the department. I just stated in another response that it's not like she can quit and get unemployment for it since they do not accept allergies to a co-worker's perfume as a valid excuse. So I could see where they'd have to pay her at least a sum until she could find another job.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Jul 07
I too have a real problem with chemicals, scents and odors. I have made my employer aware of this and they are very accomodating. The pest control man can only come after work or on weekends, my co-workers have been asked to go easy on the perfumes and colognes and no to use scented air fresheners. Because we just moved into a new building, there was concern about all the chemicals in the paint and glue; my boss was trying to find another office for me to work from until I could tolerate the new building. Fortunately due to the many delays in moving, several months passed and I was able to be in the new building without any problem. The fact that they are so accommodating makes me think they would be liable if I were to get sick after making them aware of the problem. I appreciate that most people in my life are considerate about my sensitivities. I realize there are times when it can't be helped. Because I interview people several times a week, I am often exposed to their perfumes. I understand it is not my employer's fault and they can't be held responsible. I choose to work in this field and refuse to lock myself away from the public so it's on me if I have an allergic reaction. If I had made my employer aware of my condition and they had ignored it, then I would probably sue also.
2 people like this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
8 Jul 07
Exactly. I think that is the whole situation here, they have been ignoring it and not carrying about the situation. I'm glad that your work has been accomodating. That can make a big difference. I'll be the first to admit perfumes or air fresheners can be nice but there are some places it shouldn't be limited at. If we can smell you coming it's way too strong :) and they should be told that.
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
11 Jul 07
Well Sweetie no I don't think they should as People use them to freshen up specially in the Summer I only ever wear Body sprays that are not to strong and I used to wear light Scented Perfumes when I was working as an Area Manager I still wear light Scented now but I wear more Body Sprays now I mean they are needed really to keep fresh Ok there are People like you that are allergic to them and I would respect that as long as I would know and if I had to work next to you I would then get none Scented Deodorants but I do have to admit I do like my Body Sprays and Perfumes
1 person likes this
@gabs8513 (48686)
• United Kingdom
12 Jul 07
I certainly do not wear it strong and I would consider the Fact if someone was allergic to it As for spraying it from head to toe is silly as it does not really give the effect it should do and I have to say even I would be staying away from that Person
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
12 Jul 07
Overall the ones like you who are polite aren't the problem. The ones who put it on lightly or if you know they are allergic would switch. The problem comes in with many who seem to think they have to spray a ton of scent on and don't care if others are allergic. Which is what this case was about. She'd obviously told the worker and her bosses and nothing was done about it. The problem comes in not everyone understands that body sprays aren't supposed to cover the entire body, neck to toes. I've seen women back when I was in a gym spray themselves with them all over and in that case it's very heavy and really can be smelled by many others from a distance. It's really only supposed to go on at key points. I'm allergic so I don't wear them as a general rule but even when I have found scents I can wear I don't where them except on special occasions. If you want to freshen up a washcloth with soap and water can do that far better then spraying something on you. Sprays just cover the odors, it doesn't get rid of them, and if it covers then others can smell it.
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
5 Jul 07
In a way I don't blame her. I sneeze myself around some perfumes and some have given me a sinus headace.
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
5 Jul 07
I know what you mean. Some scents (perfumes etc) cause me to sneeze while others can cause me to have a migraine then some at the worst cause my lungs to just shut down and I have to use a rescue inhaler. I'm just glad I have one.
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
5 Jul 07
i don't need a inhaler but I do have a lot of allergies.I hope if this lady wins this case.
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
5 Jul 07
I hope she does too. I think some women and men for that matter need to think about what they are putting on to and how it can effect others. Let alone when you bring in air fresheners. The one Wal-Mart near me has one in their bathroom that is nice but way too much and I end up with a migraine every time I go by it.
• United States
6 Jul 07
that might be a good idea,i've worked with people before who take sprays and perfumes to obnoxious levels. one person wore something i was allergic to and made my work experience miserable.the boss finally asked them to tone it down when i started missing work days (i couldn't stop sneezing around him).
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
8 Jul 07
Back during my college days, and this was when I took classes at night, I'd gone to class and the woman in front of me her perfume was giving me a migraine. When we took a break I decided to move and she asked me why. I told her and she was like "But I put that on this morning before work" and it was now 8pm. I told her well I can smell it. It really makes me wonder if people think about how much they are putting on.
1 person likes this
• United States
8 Jul 07
i don't think they do.either that,or they have a lessened sense of smell and don't realize how strong it is.
1 person likes this
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
7 Jul 07
It really depends....I like to wear very light cologne myself...but that's the key word...LIGHT---Let's face it though,some people wear such heavy scents, or at least it smells like they bathed in the colonge or perfume and is so overpowering to make one want to gag--I'm all for people wanting to smell nice, but it's another thing when the scent is too strong...Even I'll get sick from the smell
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
8 Jul 07
Exactly key word is light also some don't realize how much scents they are putting on. Think about it. Most women I know take a shower, the soap and shampoo have scents. They will often use a lotion or powder (if not both) afterwards, both have scents in them. Then they will add a body spray. Then add in hairspray or something to hold the hair together, all with scents. Then they will add the perfume on top of it. That is a lot of scents on the body mixing together. Try walking into a bingo hall or anyplace with a lot of women over the age of 60. Most seem to bathe in perfume before coming in there. It's very over powering.
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
8 Jul 07
Oh I agree with you there. I've known many men who put on way too much as well. It just seems at least to me that women have a tendency to do it more then men but I could be wrong.
@pyewacket (43903)
• United States
8 Jul 07
I know the whole thing can be overwhelming...but women aren't the only ones to blame...men can wear just as overpowering scents also!
1 person likes this
@nicolec (2671)
• United States
5 Jul 07
Why is she suing hte city and not that person wearing the offensive perfume? I can't stand it when they put way to much on. I was at the gym the other day and walked by this lady who smelled like she just took a shower in it. Your in a gym, for pete's sake! Your supposed to smell sweaty...just like everyone else. Phew. thanks, needed that rant!
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
5 Jul 07
You're welcome. Glad I could give you the chance to rant :) I think she's suing the city because they have not encouraged the woman to stop. That they have continued to allow her to effect her even though she's complained about it. I'm sure the co-worker is named in the suit as well.
@aprilgrl (4460)
• United States
5 Jul 07
I am allergic to perfumes and some scents too. That's why I am always home because every time I go out somewhere I can smell the perfumes and I get all swelled up and have to go to the ER. can't breathe my lungs will swelled up. Some people wear too much perfumes and probably don't realize it. Oh talking abut the air freshener or carpet freshner at the stores when I walk in the store I can't breathe and I have to go back out I have a very bad asmtha and eczema. I try to stay away from the perfumes as much as I can.Thanks for sharing the article.
1 person likes this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
6 Jul 07
You're quite welcome. I do know how you feel with it. It gets me at times. Smoke doesn't bother me at all, never did but get me near someone with perfume on and I can't breath. Go figure. Let alone some flowers which many people don't think about either. They just put them up in places not thinking someone might be allergic.