Is it right for me to discipline husband's nieces & nephew?

Philippines
July 27, 2007 10:51am CST
Here is the background. My husband is the youngest. His eldest brother died over 10 years ago leaving a wife and 3 kids. For some reason, the woman (wife) seeks help from my husband's family (and ours) and doesn't ask for help from her side. Naturally, my in-laws ended up taking her and her family in because she refuses to work (until very recently) and thus can't afford to raise her family financially anymore. Even the responsibility of disciplining her children has been relegated to my father-in-law. The issue is, my husband's nieces & nephew keep making the same mistakes to the point that my father-in-law has repeatedly blown up and threatened to move them out of his house. The children are already in their teens and twenties. If they move out of the house, there is a possibility that they will try to convince my husband to take them in or to give them financial support. We have 2 kids of our own! Plus, they keep insisting that my husband provide a fatherly figure to these children. The children have no appreciation of how fortunate they are to still be provided for despite their lack of finances. They are on scholarship but they don't care if their grades don't make the requirement. They ask for extravagances before making sure their needs are met. It has come to a point that it affects our family because they often expect my husband to come to the rescue whether it is paying for their bills, buying them shoes, or even mediating with their school to take them in again. It is crazy. And when they talk to me about their discipline methods, I don't entirely agree. I would like to give my two cents to these kids and make them realize how fortunate they are but I am afraid I will look too meddlesome. At what point can I intervene? Or do I have no place in it at all?
2 responses
• United States
30 Jul 07
I am assuming these kids are in college from what you said about them being on scholarships. When these are coming to you and your husband for your dimes, don't worry about being meddlesome. You mentioned that they don't learn from the mistakes and keep repeating them. I think you and your husband would well within your rights to tell them that you aren't going to bail them out. After all you and your husband didn't bring these kids into the world.
@nicolec (2671)
• United States
27 Jul 07
Have you talked to your husband about this? If you are afraid of making a fuss between you and your husband's family, then I would start with him. tell him how you feel and that he should talk to the kids or the mother. If that doesn't do it, then yes, you have every right to say something. Especailly since it seems you are spending money and time on these kids. Think of them as your investment, you want to get out of them more then what you are putting in. Good luck.