Order of the Phoenix IS a letdown.

Harry Potter - Order of the phoenix
@camar_lyn (1028)
Singapore
July 29, 2007 1:19am CST
Don't you agree? I watched the movie and there were just too many scenes cut off from the book. Or maybe it is the book that is too long to fit in a movie? On the other hand, is it not the director that calls the shots? Was he the right man for the job? Were there just too many subplots which were excluded that the story seems below par compared to previous ones? Why was the Order of the Phoenix the longest book YET the shortest movie? Maybe JK Rowling didn't have much say in this movie? Movies can be very long and NOT be a bore. Lord of the Rings trilogy is a good example. Do you think Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix was good?
1 person likes this
2 responses
@sizzle3000 (3036)
• United States
30 Jul 07
I agree. The Order of the Phoenix could have been better. If you look at the first and second Harry Potter movies they were closer to the book then the latest ones. But when the third movie began to go into production the directors changed. I think thaat may be one of the problems. There are so many movies that are so long but are really good. Like GOne with the Wind and Lord of the Rings. It's sad to say that J.K Rowling doesn't have much to say in the direction of the movies. I think for what was there it was a great movie. But to watch the movies and read the books you'll be in for a disappointment. The books are better than the movies just because there's a mix of humor and sadness and adventure. When it comes to the movies though, they blame it on the budget and the length. The movies should be longer and include more scenes from the books. Just wait inless you already have read book seven. It was a wonderful book and I have not a clue how the producers will even come close to mastering it in a movie format.
@eden32 (3973)
• United States
29 Jul 07
Overall I liked the movie. There were some things I thought should have been included, but I understand that some things must be cut to make a novel into an under 2 hour movie. I did think at several points, that people who hadn't read the book are going to be completely lost.