are you in favor of what so called "ARRANGED MARRIAGE?"

@jHoEn16 (2043)
Australia
July 29, 2007 8:15pm CST
we cant deny the fact that before, arranged marriage is in... it always happened on my relatives... if your parents told you to marry this person that you dont know or u know but u dont like, what are you going to do? does this marriage involved money?
6 people like this
17 responses
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
2 Aug 07
I believe in it if I were in the past generations where women are not allowed to go out of the house and the only way that she could marry is if her parents would look for a husband for her. But these days, in modern times when the both women and men are educated, and have more than one way to get to meet someone, I don't think that works very good now. Plus the fact that before, people are obedient with their parent's wishes, unlike now people are no longer that obedient. Divorces are rampant due to the fact that people would no longer be contented of their 'self-chosen' partner, how much more if you didn't choose the person? =)
1 person likes this
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
6 Aug 07
i came from the philippines too... at tulad mo pilipina ako lol... its just that my grandma tell me about arranged marriage coz it happened many times on her relatives... and i was just wondering how the relationship work when they both stranged to each other? thats why i did it as a topic just to hear any opinions from mylot users... and it helped me a lot... thanks for the responce...
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
2 Aug 07
good answer laydee.. now grt your reward lol... thanks for sharing
@laydee (12798)
• Philippines
3 Aug 07
Oh, thanks for the best response vote. I honestly didn't expect it. I really appreciate the gesture. Thank you so much. By the way, are you part of a country where 'arranged marriage' is rampant? How did you go about it? Nice topic friend. =)
• India
6 Aug 07
Every situation has its pros and cons and arranged marriage is no exception. In Indian culture, where free mixing of sexes is still frowned upon, arranged marriage is the norm for many families. Both the bride and the groom’s families ascertain each other's pedigree, social standing, financial positions and family background, before such marriages take place. So it provides some security against marrying a stranger from a totally unknown family background. Love marriages, on the other hand, do not take into consideration family background, social standing and financial positions. Lovers from different social and financial backgrounds get married and then, in many cases, such marriages result in disaster. There is no sure-shot formula for a marriage to succeed, whether arranged, or love. In all cases, it’s a gamble. But all in all, I would definitely feel scared to go in for an arranged marriage. As it is, my in-laws would be unknown to me, on top of that, if my husband was unknown too, I would feel like a fish out of water!
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
6 Aug 07
so arranged marriage usually happened in india? hmmmm... but atleast youre not into it... thanks for the responce
• India
7 Aug 07
Oh yes, very much..good mama’s boys and respectable girls don’t fall in love, here in India. Most families don’t accept it and honour killings are very much a part of the sub-continent. I am not into it, neither do I support it.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
8 Aug 07
oh i see... now i know why most of mylot users from india who responce to this discussion are infavor of that... coz its natural there your place.. thanks for the responce
@ramalot (295)
• India
30 Aug 07
Now after going thro' so many incidents in various media what I think is it is better if one prefers lovely arranged marriage ie love marriage with the acceptance of elders.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
31 Aug 07
thanks for the responce ramalot! have a nice day ahead
@Calais (10893)
• Australia
1 Aug 07
This is actually becoming quite popular now..The people are saying its because there is no expectations on the other one..
@Calais (10893)
• Australia
1 Aug 07
There was a segment on the news here and they said that it is so popular now and the success rate is brilliant, people from other cultures tend to not do this when they come to Australia but they are starting to do it now..
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
2 Aug 07
wow! i thought this only happens in asia lol... thanks for the responce
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
1 Aug 07
really? in which particular place this kind of marriage were popular? coz all i know this is popular before... thanks for the responce
• Kottayam, India
30 Aug 07
For most of the Idnians arranged marriage is preferred best.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
31 Aug 07
hmmm i totally understand now... ive watch that marriage and prejudice movie? i like it! its nice and i understand now why arranged marriage is prepared best in india... thanks for the responce elshaddai123
• Philippines
4 Sep 07
i am not in favor in "arranged marriage" because for me a good marriage is gonna be the foundation of a new family.. and it should start with love, no pretentions and most of all with two persons who knows each other very well, understands each other and loves each other. Just a point to think about.. there are lots of failed marriage coming from two people who thought they were inlove and were ready to build a family.. how much more if the couple doesn't know each other well and were forced to this so called "arranged marriage"?
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
4 Sep 07
very well said mhackie24! married should start with love and better know each other... most of arranged marriage end up divorce but there were also others that work... if im going to be on that situation that my parents will arranged my married i would say "NO" and fight for it... i wouldnt want to be with the man i dont love and at the same time i dont know thanks for the responce
• Malaysia
8 Aug 07
I think I can never marry to a person whom I don't love. If the marriage is arranged, I will have doubts and most probably I would reject even if my parents forced me to go on with it. Marriage is a lifetime commitment, and I want it to be worthwhile. Therefore, I want love to be there in my marriage. Of course money plays an important role too in a marriage.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
31 Aug 07
atleast you will fight for your feelings and happiness... i am so proud of you... thanks for the responce
• United States
8 Aug 07
Here in the States, we are free to marry whomever we want. And my parents wanted me to be happy , married or not.So I wouldn't be forced to marry someone I didn't want to. But if I were from a society where it was a tradition to have your marriage to be arranged, I would marry whomever they choose.Because the family would come first.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
8 Aug 07
thanks for the responce.. nice to know that family comes first for you... and i respect your points of view
1 person likes this
@youless (112507)
• Guangzhou, China
6 Aug 07
It doesn't a matter whether the marriage is arranged or not. The point is they love each other deeply. If the marriage is arranged, perhaps you don't have to worry whether your marriage will be dissagreed by your parents or his/her parents. If you love each other, too. Then this marriage will be nicer.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
7 Aug 07
yeah thats right... thanks for the responce
@devilsangel (1817)
• United States
6 Aug 07
I don't agree with arranged marriages at all. I was suppose to have an arranged marriage, but I decied not to. I was suppose to get married when I turned 21 to some guy my dad picked out for me when I was like 3 yrs old. Well at 18 I went into the military and I got married while I was in the military. After my divorce my dad still wanted me to marry this guy and I refused. I didn't know him and had met him once when I was a baby. I told my dad that as muc has I love and respect him that I choose who I am going to spend my life with not him.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
6 Aug 07
youre a brave one! you make me proud of you for fighting your right to choose the guy you love to marry... i hope the other girls that has the same situation would do the same as you did... thanks for the responce
1 person likes this
@senthil2k (1500)
• India
3 Aug 07
For me, its the life after marriage is important, not that the marriage is either an Arranged one or Love Marriage. Because, there are equal number of failures and successes in both Arranged and Love Marriage. Its the understanding between the couple is important, rather than the type of marriage.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
3 Aug 07
hmmmm... you have a point senthul2k.. thanks for the responce
@LadyDulce (830)
• United States
2 Aug 07
There are benefits and drawbacks to an arranged marriage. Many of the ancient arranged marriages in which the daughter was prized and adored, the parents would choose a man and she would have the final say on it. In an arrangement such as this, I agree, especially when it was customary to marry young. What 12 year old really knows what he or she wants? However now that it's common to wait a quarter of a century before marriage, I definitely believe the young adult should choose for him or herself. Back in the day, this was the age many parents would be when they first started looking for suitable mates for their children. I would trust my mother or step-grandmother to choose a mate for me, but not my dad or stepdad. My most successful relationship was actually one set up by my grandmother (she's an immigrant Korean, so she's very used to playing matchmaker for her female relatives). We're still close to this day. It really just depends on the person and the environment. I don't think I'd have a problem living and sleeping with someone I had met only shortly before the wedding. Love is an action, it's something you do. When they say you'll grow to love someone, they're right. Much like our children; we know we love them at birth, but it doesn't really feel like it. We have to get to know them first. Love grows, it isn't just an overnight thing. That one's called infatuation or lust. Blessed Be
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
2 Aug 07
why you dont want your dad to choose for a man you will marry? thanks for sharing
@rinkub (231)
• India
3 Aug 07
Actually, I belong to India, and here arranged marriages are considered real marriages.Though things are changing now, arranged marriages are still very much prevalent. Parents or families, anyone ranging from a great grandpaent of 90 years to a college friend who's just 18 can bring marriage alliances for their near and dear ones. In arranged marriages, generally, everything from language, province, state, caste and even sub-caste is expected to match! It is also generally believed, that arranged marriages are more successful and last as against love marriages. There are so many factors that are often quoted for the success of AM and the failure of LM. For instance, in arranged marriages, since families are involved there is a certain accountability that a couple has or that love marriage is often looked upon as an act of irresponsibility towards the family and society. In love marriages, since the expectations are high on either side and since the couple is insulated from family interferences(or so its believed), chances of the marriage breaking up are higher as the couple do not try adjusting or compromising. I'v had a love marriage but believe me I feel that our sense of responsibility is far higher. Yes, there have been disillusionments, but we have learnt to sort it out somehow. In India, people fall in love after marriage and think its a most wonderful thing as husband and wife get to know one another gradually, and thats where the charm lies! But for me, whether its love or arranged, a marriage is a tremendous responsibility, a commitment, and something one has to make an effort to keep it going on a daily basis.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
3 Aug 07
wow... first time i heared about falling inlove after marriage! but you were right, marriage is a big responsibility, a commitment... thanks for the responce
@bhappy2 (327)
• Australia
8 Aug 07
I believe in freedom of choice, particularly who I will spend my life with. The problem is, many marriages don't work because we make decisions about who we will marry romantically not logically. When parents arrange a marriage the will ask them selves, 'can this person take good care of my child', 'will this person be able to provide for my child financially' and 'will this person make my child happy'. I am sure parents don't always get it right but, statistically,arranged marriages are less likely to end in divorce.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
31 Aug 07
you're absolutely right! arranged marriage will end in divorce... except the others that knows how to adjust themselves for that situation... if the parents will arranged the marriage they should also think of the hapiness of thier son/daughter... thanks for the responce bhappy2
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
30 Jul 07
I won't agree with arranged marriage not because it is not in but it hinders your freedom to love who you like to love. I think marriage should happen between two person who really loves each other and is willing to be together. If marriage is arranged and there is no mutual consent between the couple I do believe that the marriage is a hoax and should never be allowed just so the parents have agreed or arranged it.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
1 Aug 07
correct! thanks for sharing rsa101
@juliefaye (1214)
• Philippines
1 Aug 07
Arranged marriage are part of some people's culture. I think of it as unwise arrangement as we can't simply live with strangers. Much more to sleep with a complete stranger. There were reasons behind these cultures and i don't know much about it. One thing for sure, i'm not in favor of it.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
1 Aug 07
thanks for the responce juliefaye... i agree
• Philippines
30 Jul 07
arrange marriage happens in certain cultures. it has been a tradition to them. however, it doesn't really work for most. some of them end up separating after quite some time. yes, more often than not, it involves money. in other cases, it's one way of protecting the family business and/or properties. i don't think that my parents would ask me to be in one. our culture don't practice such. but if ever, i would tell them that i will only marry the person whom i love.
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
30 Jul 07
yeah great! hahahaha it's nice to married the man that you love thanks dolce_vita78