is democracy good?

Canada
August 3, 2007 10:32am CST
in a country where flashy lights, hot dogs and paris hilton are more popular than world issues, can we really trust all of our votes to the hands of this disoriented crowd? throughout history, and even now, democracy has not done us good.. we can go back to the death of Socrates, the death of Alexander, the death of jesus, the crusades, the holocaust, the 2 times bush was voted in and even IRAQ. my point is, people are like sheep, throw some money here, flash some "bo-obs" there, and there we go, we got a group of guys willing to vote for you or the stupid things your willing to do.. money, nationalism and religion seem to be a couple of "temptations" people use.. in the case of iraq, it was all about nationalism and religion.. "we cannot have these islamic fundamentalists attacking our country!" do you know what i mean? what do you think?
3 people like this
4 responses
@sunshinecup (7871)
3 Aug 07
I think you make an excellent point and pretty much stated what I have thought many times. Sadly what is the solution? Remove voting rights from some? Who and what do we base that on and how do we enforce it? I agree it has it’s flaws, but what is better? With nothing to compare it to, at this moment my answer is yes, Democracy is good, but not great.
1 person likes this
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
25 Sep 07
Thank god for the electoral college and congressional power. We are not a direct democracy so... ""we cannot have these islamic fundamentalists attacking our country!"" -Is a true statement and not a mistake. Its not even an issue of nationalism or religion (the religion was an issue for those attacking, not the US).
• Canada
27 Sep 07
yes, and we cannot have christian fundamentalist sucking the life out of the constitution either.
2 people like this
@MrNiceGuy (4141)
• United States
29 Sep 07
Good thing Christian fundamentalists aren't in charge of the country and that isn't happening regardless so....
@posham (1236)
• Philippines
20 Jun 08
yeah, we are so proud that we live in a democracy but theory-wise, democracy is part of the negative types of government because it's actually "mob-rule". and we all know that just because the majority wants it, it doesn't necessarily mean that it's the right thing to do...
20 Jun 08
Sir Winston Churchill once said that democracy is the worst political system in the world - apart from all the others. That about sums it up. To get changes in the other political systems, you have to use either bribery or force. Democracy at least saves us from having a civil war any time a large segment of the population feel the need to remove the government.
@tigertang (1749)
• Singapore
20 Jul 08
I'm with Chuchill on this one. I mean, much as we may all complain about the democratic process, I can't think of any other process that has produced a string of relatively stable governments for so long. Admittedly, dictatorships can produce more efficient governments provided the top man is wise and benevolent. In Singapore, our top people have ruled for the past 43-years without anyone questioning their power and right to rule. They've done a good job in ensuring a prosperous, intelligent and hamonious society. However, we've been very lucky because the people at the top have remained intelligent, capable and most importantly un-corrupt. But how long can this state of affairs last? And I think the problem with benevolent autocracies is that people become so trusting or accepting of authority, they flounder when the authority figures become rouges. Singapore is lucky in as much as we have the trappings of the checks and balances of democracy. The ruling party needs to go for an election every 5-years and on paper they can lose elections. As such, they're kept on their toes, though the lack of teeth in some of our institutions can be damaging. Good people in power for too long, can become corrupted. Look at the African continent and to Zimbabwe. The Robert Mugabe who lives in luxury and terrorizes his citizens with violence and intimidation as well as 2 million percent inflation was once a respected peace maker who grew too in-love with his power. How did he get that way? There was no institutional check on him and he surrounded himself with people who always agreed with him - something that does not always happen in a democracy. People who grow up in democratic systems also tend to be more resilient. In South East Asia, the 'messiest' country is the Philippines, which is also the most democratic country in the region. Yet, Filipinos are the most self-reliant people in the region, who travel and seem able to make their living quite comfortably outside their own country. Democracy is not a perfect system. It often prevents an effective leader from getting things done. However, its the best system in keeping the powers that be on their toes and more importantly it makes people more responsible for their own lives rather than relying on a government to run things for them.