How Do You Punish Your Child/Children When They Misbehave Badly?

@Puffer (92)
Singapore
August 13, 2007 11:47am CST
I guess being a stay-at-home-DAD facing 3 kids whole day long are more than enough to handle. When my 7-year old boy and his 6-year old brother fight, throw tantrums, being defiant etc, they can really turn the house up-side down. Sometimes I would lose my patience and turn into a really foul mood. The only effective way to deal with them for now would be through caning. Whenever I take out the cane, the boys would stop immediately and beg for forgiveness. Although I make sure that I don't hurt them bodily (I only cane on their buttocks), I know this is not going to work well to teach the kids. I've read up and seek advice, such as using the time-out method as a form of punishment, but sometimes I just lose my patience and blow hot. Do you parents have such experiences? Care to share your ways in dealing with your kids' unruly behaviour? I really wish my boys could grow up quickly enough to learn to curb their tempers and behave well.
3 responses
@cher913 (25782)
• Canada
13 Aug 07
cudos to you for being a stay at home dad! we used to spank our girls when they were younger, but now we make them sit on the stairs for a time out...having them banished to their rooms is not punishment as they have a plethora of toys there...the stairs there is nothing to do... try and count to 10 before you get upset, i know its usually easier said than done, but it does help.
1 person likes this
@Puffer (92)
• Singapore
13 Aug 07
hi, Yes I've heard of the counting method...I would very often forget about this when I'm angry. I've been a SAHD for almost a year now, I wonder if this could be the reason - facing naughty kids all day long without any leisure and social life.
2 people like this
@vinzen (1020)
• India
14 Aug 07
Hi, sorry to hear that you have to under go all this and that too alone, single handedly, and i agree things do get tough at times and we tend to loose our patience, but i dont think that caning or screaming at them would be a good solution. As kids maybe are scared for a while, but then they get so used to all this that even caning or whatever measures that you are taking now, will have no effect on them. I would suggest, what i used to do with my two daughters ( though girls arent as naughty as the boys) Was the time out method, or even give them a warning and there after take serious measures, like stop them viewing their favourite Tv programmes, or stop their treats for a week, or stop their favourite food etc, anything that they like or love to do, put a stop to that. So i would suggest that maybe you can try these measures and see if they work too.
@vinzen (1020)
• India
14 Aug 07
Thanks for replying, and i hope that my advice will be of help to you,and i would like to know, if you did try this method and it worked or not, thanks and bye, wishing you all the best.
@Puffer (92)
• Singapore
14 Aug 07
you are very right to say that the kids will get used to those corporal punishments metted out on them. i felt the same too and somehow i knew it just wasn't right to punish them like that. i'll try out your methods you've suggested. now i must think of what they love most and use that as a deterent. thanks so much for the advice. really appreciate it!
@Tanya8 (1733)
• Canada
14 Aug 07
Hi there, I have a couple of book recommendations: http://www.amazon.com/How-Talk-Kids-Will-Listen/dp/0380811960/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2/105-8174579-5203638?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1187058453&sr=8-2 and http://www.amazon.com/Playful-Parenting-Lawrence-J-Cohen/dp/0345442865/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/105-8174579-5203638?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1187058509&sr=1-1 The first book suggests tons and tons of ways to deal with specific discipline situations using natural consequences instead of punishments. It gives you ideas of things you can say when the kids are acting up, so that you're more likely to stay calm and teach them instead of reacting to them. The second book has really helped me pull myself out of negative moods and change the atmosphere in my home. I find that I'm happier and the kids are better behaved, when I take things less seriously and humor to solve problems. My husband travels a lot, and I don't have much access to babysitters, so I also struggle with keeping my temper after I've gone too long without a break. I certainly find that if I can control my own reactions, that the kids are easier to be around.
@Puffer (92)
• Singapore
14 Aug 07
hello Tanya, thanks for sharing. I'll keep a look out for those books you've recommended. I'm sure they will provide me with good knowledge and ways in becoming a better parent! I've just realised that I shouldn't use the word 'punish'. 'Discipline' should be the better word to use for my title! Thanks again for taking time to share here.