Who Sang It Better?

I prefer Rihanna's version. I like the fact that I can dance to it, clean to it, and have an all out good time to her version. Rihanna's version is also more catchy. Now Mandy Moore did a good job for her style, but her version was something I could sleep to, meditate to, or have playing softly in the background at study time.

they both a different version.... i love rihanna's version and i even put nice dance step for my band.... but when i heard mandy moore's version i can sing her version on hotel...it is cute.

i love rihanna's version coz its more powerful and its danceable. i like listening to rihanna and singing like her coz she sounds so sexy and i wanna sound sexy. LOL

I'm not much of a fan of this song and while I really liked Mandy's voice in her rendition of it, Rihanna's version is better. I just don't really like this song it feels too laggy.

Yeah I just saw this a while ago in yahoo. I heard Mandy's version and it was pretty nice i guess but i like Rihanna's better probably because I could dance to it. But Mandy did a really good job.

i think mandy moore, she sounds more wishing and hopeful. also tranquil. apple.

I like Rihanna's version somewhat better but was surprised the slower version of Mandy Moore's was really good also.This type of rainy evening fit perfectly.