Youngest and spoilt?
By joshua_w
@joshua_w (501)
Malaysia
September 19, 2007 3:46am CST
Do you feel that our parents give more love and attention to the youngest in the family? Are they spoilt? Spoilt in the sense that they're more loved, more pampered than their older siblings. This is not to be confused with spoilt brat per se.
In where i lived, many people feel seems to have this conception that the youngest in the family will get preferential treatment over their elder brothers and sisters.
"Hey look, here's the biggest chicken drumstick and mummy is going to give it to your little sister here. Don't look at mummy this way. And after lunch, go share your toys with her. Try not to fight with her again ya."
"Hey, your little brother will definitely like this sports shoe. What do you think son? It's a little expensive but it will look good on him, i think. Should i get a pair for him? Hmm, maybe i should. I can keep it for his birthday."
"I know it's been an hour already but it's still early. Let's wait for a little while more, ok. We can't start without your little brother. You know how he is. He works so hard. Maybe it's the traffic. Oh, he must be so hungry by now. My poor boy!"
What's your take on this? How was your experience like then? Or do you think the eldest are the spoilt ones. What about the middle ones then? From a different angle-if you're a parent, do you tend to er, indulge your youngest child.
2 people like this
10 responses
@sephrenia (567)
•
19 Sep 07
I've been guilty of doing this and being the eldest child myself, I should have known better. When I only had my daughter, i lavished time and attention on her like you wouldnt believe, she was, and is, my angel eyes. When my son was born though I changed without realising it. I started giving my son more attention because he was the youngest and he obviously needed more help and attention than my daughter (roll eyes here) and I found myself expecting her to be more grown up and set an example. I started giving her chores to do, like keep her room clean and help me with her brother or share her toys with him and what have you.
I didnt realise what I was doing until my daughter started doing stupid things like telling people I beat her because she wanted my attention. It came to a head when I had to go through a police investigation as well as one by social services in response to her allegations. They took my daughter to a psychiatrist who pointed out that she was feeling unloved since my son came along and it was a shock to me. I honestly didnt realise that she was feeling neglected. I thought I had been treating her the same way I always had. The police and social services dropped their investigations and we started going to family counselling together.
Since then I make more of an effort to include her in what im doing or I jump into what shes doing to see if i can help and shes become a lot better behaved since then. I don't know if anyone else has been the same but thats what happened with us.
2 people like this
@joshua_w (501)
• Malaysia
19 Sep 07
That is indeed an extreme case. Going to a psychiatrist for a child is not something Asian people do, as we're still very conservative about these things. We would try to settle family problems among ourselves, without outside help.
From what you've written, children tends to be very sensitive to their parent's love and attention ya. She must have really felt neglected for her to do the things she did. Well, it's good that you've managed to settle this. All the best to you and your children then.
1 person likes this
@chym1101 (169)
• China
20 Sep 07
Hello,joshua_w. What you say is prevalent all around the world maybe. It is no doubt that parents love their every child, but maybe then think the youngest is the weakest, so they care about them more.
I am lucky. I have a brother 7 years younger than me. But my parents don't do as you say.If there are things both I and my brother want, they will tell us to share. So we are getting on well.
1 person likes this
@chym1101 (169)
• China
20 Sep 07
hello, johua_w. Thank you for your kind tip. I know that as we get older there will be more and more things effect the relationship between we and our siblings. But I will try my best to love my brother as what I do.
From your information I know that you are Malaysian. I learn about Malaysia from books and movies, and I think it is a very beautiful country. I hope a chance to travel there!
@subha12 (18441)
• India
20 Sep 07
Hmm..
Let me answer point by point.
I am unmarried.
I was the oungest in my family.
I must say I was little pampered than my elder brother who is 7 yrs older than me.
But the case is that when the situation came of real
caring and all, my brother always got the preference.
I even remember this,
when I was still in junior school,
papa used to tell that he is making the house formy brother and all these stuff.
I have also heard before I came my brother was very much spoilt and my mom sys first child is more spoilt.
@AmbiePam (92798)
• United States
19 Sep 07
I am the younger sibling, and I wasn't given any more privileges that my older sister. In fact my sister was given more slack than I was. This could be because she was always very outgoing, and they didn't have as many concerns about her, as they did me, because I was mostly quiet growing up.
@joshua_w (501)
• Malaysia
20 Sep 07
That certainly debunks the notion that youngest are spoilt by their parent. It's true that a person who's more outgoing or extrovert inspired more confidence in people. Whereas a quieter child would always make her parents worry a little more. I should know, i'm the quiet one myself.
@anonymili (3138)
•
19 Sep 07
I am 4.5 years older than my brother and we're both in our 30s (erm me not for much longer). I have always felt my mother favoured my brother more in the way that he is very spoilt and he was living at home till 2 years ago when he moved in with his girlfriend, whereas I moved out when I first got married at 25 and have lived away from them ever since. My brother was the one who mum always treated like a little kid so much so that he didn't even pick up his clothes from the floor or put them in the washing machine. She changed his bedclothes up until he moved out when he was 33, how sad is that? I have never resented him for any of this stuff although it was amusing watching his girlfriend get him trained into cleaning up after himself.
What I have resented over the years though (only slightly) is how my parents treat him like a kid, to the extent that my dad used to open my brother's mail and discuss his bank balance (or lack of it with me). I kept telling my dad that mail addressed to someone was private and my dad would say "As long as he's living under MY roof..." bla bla bla! I thought this was really out of order and my brother would get mad about it but would never mention to dad directly that he had a problem with it. You might think that is a problem with my parents but it was because my brother was so spoilt by them that he had this poor attitude to money and even though he is an IT consultant and earns a fortune he still manages to have huge debts on his credit cards even to this day! When living with mum and dad he didn't pay rent, he didn't pay anything towards food or bills so when he moved out and was faced with a mortgage and bills, it was a huge shock to the system and he continued with the same level of social life as before except now he had much more outgoings. Parents have to try to teach their kids the value of money - spoiling them when they live at home only makes it worse for them later in life.
1 person likes this
@anonymili (3138)
•
21 Sep 07
Oh I totally agree that parents have a real responsibility to teach their kids the value of money. My brother at 35 earns almost one third more than I do and he is still constantly in debt. How can I manage to still save 25% of my salary each month and still have money spare and he can't? It just shocks me that I am more financially sensible than he ever has been...! Thanks for commenting back on my response :)
1 person likes this
@joshua_w (501)
• Malaysia
20 Sep 07
You had me totally engrossed in reading what you had written here. Some people never grow out of their comfort zone. Many still depends on parents to make decisions for them. I guess when one is young, parents do have the right to spoil them with more love and attention. But when children grows older, then every parent must strive to inculcate independence in them.
Sometimes, we do feel sad for our parents because in their old-age, they still need to look after their children like little kids. And what's sadder is that those children never really appreciate all the things their parents did for them. They take it for granted even.
I do strongly agree with you that it's never too early to learn financial lessons. Schools don't teach them. So, who else but the parents who have the most influential position to teach them this. If one do not learn this, how could they teach their children then? It can become a repeated cycle.
1 person likes this
@lucy0713 (32)
• China
20 Sep 07
I'm the elder daughter of my parents,and I have a brother.When I was a student,I didn't feel anything of what you said.But from last year on,when I gratuated from university and had my first job,I began to realize the more love to my brother from my parents.They gave more pin money and allowed him not to do housework.Sometimes I ask myself not to think such more,and pay more attention to my brother just like my parents.I tell myself that he is my little brother whom I should take care of.With the conception,I feel better.
I wonder what's your opinion?
@kalav56 (11464)
• India
3 Nov 07
This is such a common topic that would be valid in any household where there are more than one offspring. I have seen examples of both. And while on the topic, I am also reminded of what my mother has told me once. She is the second of ten children and apparently, there was a boy born after 4 girls. Now, all at home[ a huge joint family with uncles ,aunts, grandaother etc..,] were clearly partial to this child and if one banana was given to all children two would be kept for this darling son of theirs. Ironically, the story did not continue after he became an adult[obviously I am not referring to as mundane a thing as that perishable banana but regarding love and affection , it was the daughters who stole that. ]
In many cases I have seen that the eldest is given undue respect and importance at the expense of other children and this person, while not qualifying to be termed a'spoilt brat' , becomes a bit high handed and domineering.
I agree with the statement once made by a lawyer friend of mine-that parents, for reasons unexplained, identify themselves with a particular child . However, they would never accept this. That the children would have to accept this was his statement.
I have alsways voiced my opinion very strongly on this even with parents of my students.They always used to complain of one child and praise another. They were forcing one child to be in the shadow of another and this will never work out once they are adults. Like the example you had quoted in that'emotional account' discussion of yours[incidentally, that was a lovely metaphor]the elder brother would have taken this to heart and would later get alienated by recurring similar incidents.
But, is there justice in the realm of human beings? What everyone does becomes totally subjective and people give umpteen justifications for all the stands that they take.
@wisedragon (2325)
• Philippines
19 Sep 07
I am the youngest in our family. In my younger years my parents definitely did try to spoil me. But I'm really not the type of person who likes that so I would always resist it. I hate being spoiled. I wanted to learn to be independent and take care of myself. I wanted to be able to deal with my own problems. I wanted to be able to fight my own battles. I wanted to grow up a responsible adult.
So I think parents will always try to spoil the youngest. It's up to the child if he/she will take it or not.
@williamjisir (22819)
• China
19 Sep 07
I was the youngest one in the family. I feel that it is somewhat like this. Now I am a father of only one child because of one-child policy in China. I think that if I had another one child, I would be the same like my parents because the youngest need more more attention as he is more ignorant than the elder one. And the elder can also help the young one to help care for him and teach him more and so on.
1 person likes this
@joshua_w (501)
• Malaysia
19 Sep 07
Aha, you're talking from experience then. Maybe you're right in saying the youngest always need more attention since they're well, the youngest. And the elder siblings does have the responsibility to look after them. It's the same everywhere, right?
The one-child policy was also practiced in my neighboring country, Singapore some time ago.
@latsmom (824)
•
19 Sep 07
Ifound taht also but, now that I have grown older I look at things a different way, I mean with teh first child you try and do everything right, the dicipline, always pushing them to the next level, be it walking, colege, uni ect, also I have watched my own mom when I was younger I used to see it as favouritism, but now I think that as parents get older on a whole they do get softer with their children and dont bother so much with teh dicipline, my brother gets loads more now tahn I did whe I was his age but then my parents are also older and much better off and in a better position to do so. Maybe with teh youngest parents think that it is their last chance if they have no intention of having more children to get it rigt this time so try their best to give the final child everything they were unable to give the eldest, plus with the case of me my younger sister and brother, now that my sister and I have left home, I can only imagine their is much more moneyto go around.
1 person likes this