what do you like harrypotter--book or movie??
By Ravirocks
@Ravirocks (489)
India
7 responses
@icy_ice82000 (205)
• India
4 Apr 08
I find the books more interesting than the movies...in the books JK has described every scene properly n it feels as if its happening in front of our eyes...but in the movie they have not been able to include all the drama properly as it is in the book...if we read a book other than the 1st one ,we will still understand wat would have happened previously,thanx to JK... but if we see a movie sequel witout watching the 1st one,we wont understand wat would have happened b4...
Anyway the movies are nice..but books has its own charm...
@xavierkyle (223)
• Philippines
8 Oct 07
In my opinion, the books give more essence than the movie... i have seen all the HP movies and i particularly like the the first two-book adaptation because it follows what is on the book. the later books, although the story was great, there are scences from the book that were neglected. However, David Yates said that a movie is a different entity from the book..
@KumoriNeko (60)
• Philippines
17 Oct 07
I like the books better than the movies. The books have more details and the story is complete unlike in movie versions where the storyline is squished within a 2-3hour show. Some important and exciting parts of the novel never get a spotlight in the screen. Besides, when I read a book, the images that form in my mind are enough to consider as a "movie."
@icy_ice82000 (205)
• India
4 Apr 08
I found the books more interesting than the movies....In the book all the scenes are properly described n it feels as if its really happening in front of our eyes... in the movie they have not been able to include all the scenes stated in the book...also if we read a book other than the 1st , we still understand wat would have happened in the sequence b4 ,thanx to the writer.. but if somebody has not seen the previous sequels ,he/she wont understand.
But anyway the movies are nice....
@vkarthik210 (4)
• India
28 Sep 07
I prefer book rather than seeing movie. The author real talent was first explored through her books only. The way she has depicted the story leads to great impact all age groups around the world.
The movie was an awesome product from latest graphics technology and creativity from Art Directors. But it will never reach actual imagination of the author.....