Do you believe in the doctrine of inclusion?

United States
September 27, 2007 9:25pm CST
Do you believe in the doctrine of inclusion, which claims that all religions are equally important and that hell is purely man's creation? Although a Christian and believe my religion is the most vital, I have practiced this sort of idea since age 16, which is one of the reasons you will often find me defending, to some degree, other religions. I just believe that when people even believe in the existence of a Supreme Being - God, it makes a big difference in their thinking; therefore, I tend to embrace people of other religions - Yesterday, September 26, 2007, I visited Unity Church of Christianity on Unity Drive in Houston, Texas, to hear famous charismatic TV minister Carlton Pearson, whose emphasis on the idea of inclusion cost him his TV ministry and most of his charismatic and pentecostal friends. It was queit an experience! When Bishop Pearson faced oppositions for his new belief of inclusion, I had boycotted most Christian TVs and radio stations (because I found no just cause for them supporting W. Bush in invading Iraq), and therefore had not really followed Pearson's troubles. Thus, when I read that he would be in Houston, I made sure I went to hear him for myself - Except for lowering his voice, some, to mind the practice of Unity Church (where meditation is said to be often silent, seeing members are of various denominations), Carlton Pearson was still witty Carlton Pearson: He still preaches between music, is still very charismatic and still sends the crowd into standing ovations. The major difference I noticed (and maybe it was just because of the premises used) was that, although he referenced the Bible, he did not give out any Biblical reference passages. And once or twice, he spoke of a Biblical passage as "as alleged in the Bible," something that even I have on some occasions have done. Well, you can check out my started discussion "Let us move Israel to Antarctica" and my comment in "Does religion teach intolerance?" However, unlike Pearson, I strongly believe that there is indeed a hell (which very possibly could have been created by mankind), and people will go there not because the loving Creator sent them there, but because of their very own evil deeds! Nowadays, I sometimes even think that hell is right here and right here on earth! What are your thoughts on the doctrine of inclusion? Do you think non-Christians or people of other denominations are loved by God and will be saved? And, do you truly believe that a God who loves the world so much so that HE sent HIS only begotten son will send people to hell?
3 people like this
6 responses
@scribe1 (1203)
• United States
22 Dec 07
God loves everyone unconditionally and to assign human attributes to Him, such as anger and hate, is in actuality, creating a false god. Humans are evil and believe in stupid things such as the devil and evil spirits. We are here to learn how to love. And there is no such thing as one correct religion. All religions have merit. (I used to be Catholic.)
• United States
22 Dec 07
Scribe1 - "... and to assign human attributes to Him, such as anger and hate, is in actuality, creating a false god." Scribe1, now, this is a very good topic for a debate.
• United States
21 Nov 07
dear netsbridge, we are all eternal, we have eternal souls, that's why when God gave is "free will" he also gave us the opportunity to love Him or not...but He is so KIND that He also gave us reincarnation...so we have many lifetimes to develop our love for Him...stanzi
• United States
21 Nov 07
Now, Stanzi2007, why would an Omnipotent, Omniscience God choose to give us reincarnation rather than simply ascertain that we are exactly what He wanted and wants us to be? Is this concept not more time consuming, and for what purpose?
• India
28 Sep 07
In Bengali, we have a saying which goes like this: where is heaven, where is hell, who says that they are far away…they both co-exist here on this earth itself, within each of us lives God & Satan. Though I am unaware of a Doctrine of Inclusion as such, I am a firm believer in Spirituality and not Religion (they are eons apart of course). Spirituality is somewhat similar to the doctrine you speak of and to me, there is no religion greater than humanity. I am born Hindu and I would not change it for anything on this earth as it is more of an identity to me than anything else, but apart from this, I have respect for every religion on this earth…even Islam which is drawing a lot of flak these day. But religion has to be in the pure form and not adulterated by human greed, politics, insularity, conservativeness and all such clutter, which it in not meant to propagate. And all religions in their pure exalted form connect you to the Supreme One that’s for sure and therein steps in Spirituality. It is something beyond the narrow confines of religion and somewhat a step just after the Doctrine of Inclusion.
• United States
29 Sep 07
I find it interesting that Christians are not yet responding to this discussion. Well, that is something to think about!
@suspenseful (40192)
• Canada
19 Dec 07
The doctrine of inclusion is false. It is the duty of Christians to tell others of the reason for hope that is in us, and why should there be a reason for the hope if being a Christian is like anyone else. Now if someone is a Muslim or a Jew or one of the other religions, if he prays to God to show him the way and God intends for him to be saved, God will send missionaries or people on his path, but they will not be Buddhists, or Brahmans, etc, but Christians who will tell him that the only way to be saved is through believing that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and also son of man, that HE is wholly God and wholly man. I know many will hate me for saying this, but I do not want to be the position of God berating me for keeping silent. And there is a hell, God intended it for the evil angels (also known as demons) but those who are against HIM will be cast into it as well. I do not know about the people who came before Jesus Christ was born. I am sure that there were some who were not Jewish who rather knew that God has a son and there is a Trinity and they lived their lives as if they were HIS children. And no quoting me.
• United States
11 Oct 07
I agree that all religions are equal and no one is right or wrong. We all have our own path in life and only us as ourselves know our true path. I think that Jesus was a man jsut like you and me and that man decided to make him a God to benifit themselves to control us. I think that he could of been a very enlightened soul sorta like buddha but that was it. I just follow my heart b/c my heart never lies. I read and study a little bit of everything and take what my heart tells me is the best way. Man wrote the bible, many man wrote the bible, all of those man where differant and had differant values and beliefs that is why there is so much conterversy in the bible. To add to this Man decided what was in the bible and Man decided what wouldnt be in the bible and Man tell you to follow it. I think people need to stop listening to man and start listening to there heart. I believe this is where God would be telling you what is right for you.
@yougreat (150)
• China
28 Sep 07
if we believe all men and all women are created eaual and meanwhile you also belive jesus christ is the true savior,so i belive GOD can love us all,but what about hell?where will hell will pend,i also believe there is no hell,God may let us face our feelings,all things lie partly in what you think about other people's words,further in detail i believe God will protect us,i belive God deeply,but God is fair,and everybody want to be an incarnation of God,But who can be him,i only just sole admire him