Is dhoni a good captain?

we cant access him from just a single tournament.he has a good future as a captain.his marks as a captain will get furnished based on his team management and co ordinating the team members tht they have to work as a team

A captain is as good as his team only.Why we consider Saurav as the best captain....simply because under him,the team was most successful in terms of performances.Dhoni has got a cool head,can inspire the other team-mates and can bring the best effort out of them.Plus,he himself is performing too.All that makes him a good material for leading the side.The future results will only decide whether he is good or not.But my best wishes with Dhoni.

well . its too early . to decide . whether .. dhoni is going to be a good captain or not . wel . he has made a very gud start by winning the 20-20 world cup .. but .. hows he gonna perform in the longer version i.e. 50 overs game remain to be seen .. hey .. its only the first odi that india lost . theres still 5 more games left to be played :)

Well mate...i want to say that all matches are fixed.... dunno abt ur views....but this is what i feel... so it doesnt matter as to hw good a captian he is.....see if its fixed that India has to lose then dhoni will lead the team in that way....and if its fixed that India has to win the match,then He will captian the match n team accordingly... so basically i wanna say that the true captaincy doesnt reveal out...and gets bogged down under the match fixing scam....

Its not correct to judge him only in one series.Lets see how he handles future cup further

i hink he not as good as ganguly. under him team his winning because player are in the form not due to his capataicy. just to have his own importance he made ganguly to sit outside, still he was in form so in my opinion he is not good he pays more attention towards saving his captaincy and to rule over the team then making strategy against team