CSI: miami VS CSI: new york which do you like most?
By jHoEn16
@jHoEn16 (2043)
Australia
October 6, 2007 9:51am CST
i love both... but if i really have to choose i like CSI:newyork more simply because i like thier way of investigation and i like all the character..
a month ago, ive heared on the news that CSI:miami is the best.. and now CSI:newyork was never been air on win television... :(
how about you guys? which of this two series you like the most?
4 people like this
16 responses
@raijin (10345)
• Philippines
6 Oct 07
I prefer to watch more of CSI: New York, because I I'm more familiar with Gary Sinise over David Carusso. Though I'm not an avid viewer of these two series, I watch more of "New York" whenever I could.
I believe "Miami" was more ahead than that of "NY" and that's what I watch back then but when Gary Sinise was introduced and "NY" was aired, I concentrated more in it.
I also loved their CSI: crossovers, where NY and MIami worked together to solve a particular case that involves both their States.
2 people like this
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
7 Oct 07
i love melina the curly hair girl in new york? thats why i like that show than miami... but since win didnt aired the newyork anymore i dont have any choice but stick to miami and cometimes the csi vegas... its the original one right?
ive never seen newyork and miami worked together... i hope i can watch that...
thanks pal for sharing
@pagli84 (1850)
• Netherlands
7 Oct 07
i personally like the original las vegas one the best. i guess its a tie between new york and miami. i find the characters on both to be a bit fake, especially callie in miami. she really doesnt know how to act at all, and she needs to work on her facial expressions. but i love investigative shows like csi. i watch all of them: csi, law and order, house, shark, cold case, medium, close to home...i should have gone into that field haha.
1 person likes this
@carlaabt (3504)
• United States
6 Oct 07
We watch all three of the CSI's at our house. Every week, my husband asks me if they are going to kill Horatio (David Caruso) on Miami, because neither of us like him. The show would be so much better if he left!
My favorite character out of all three of the shows is Danny from New York. I think I like the original CSI slightly better than the New York one, but it's pretty close. They are both much better than Miami, though.
2 people like this
@jHoEn16 (2043)
• Australia
7 Oct 07
hahahaha... the first time i watch sca:miami i hate horation too... i dont like him being in the show... but later on i find him funny... the way he react and take his glasses...
on the other side i like danny on newyork and i just start watching the original csi so i dont know yet wether its nice or not
thanks for sharing
@maddysmommy (16230)
• United States
7 Oct 07
Which one is the original series? the one with Grisom, Sarah and that lot, thats the one I like! I think that is the first series before the others came out.
@patgalca (18390)
• Orangeville, Ontario
7 Oct 07
Though I stay up late to watch the midnight reruns of CSI:Miami on Friday and Sunday, I much prefer CSI:NY. David Caruso does bug me and there is something very different about those shows that I can't put my finger on. Buy it bugs me. I don't like it as much as the other two. Now in the reruns they are showing episodes with Speedle and I love him. He makes the show tolerable. I love all the characters on CSI:NY.
1 person likes this
@recycledgoth (9894)
•
16 Oct 07
I'm a great fan of the original series and enjoyed Miami when it hit our screens. I haven't watched much of NY but I do like Gary Sinese. If I had to chose I would probably have to say Miami
@roniroxas (10559)
• Philippines
7 Oct 07
i like CSI New York better because i loveeeeeeeeee Gary Sinise.
@jcj_111776 (3216)
• Philippines
7 Oct 07
hi jhoen. If I have to choose between the two, I have to say I much prefer CSI: New York. I don't know why but I don't like how David Carusso portrays his role.
But if you have included CSI: Las Vegas, this one will and always be the number one for me. I've seen their series from season 1 to season 7, the finale. And I can't wait for its next season.
@galoforce (263)
•
7 Oct 07
i cant realy decide between the csi's they are all top notch, though i dont really like the regular csi as much as the others.
@crazy_ol_lady (1014)
• United States
7 Oct 07
hi jhoen16,
CSI Vegas is the all time best!!!! Maybe it is because it was the first one out! If I had to pick a favorite of the other two, then it would have to be CSI NY. I can tolerate Gary Sinise, but Caruso to me leaves a lot to be desired.
Happy posting..
@crazy_ol_lady (1014)
• United States
14 Oct 07
maybe because David Caruso is being promoted as "all that". I think it is a lot of hype to get people to watch CSI Miami.
@ailema4ever (2668)
• Finland
7 Oct 07
I actually love most CSI: Miami and Las Vegas rather than New York, but I like the three of them anyway. I'm just more familiar with the characters of Miami and Las Vegas. ;-D
@shiloh_222 (5479)
• Philippines
7 Oct 07
hahaha... could i have the third choice? i love among the three CSI is the original: CSI: Las Vegas... Especially the characters and plot...William Petersen plays his character to the hilt... hahaha... but i like Miami more, if i have to choose between the 2... good day
@foxygirle (376)
• Philippines
7 Oct 07
o like CSI better than Miami and New York.
I find the character and plot of the original CSI better and how they handle the crime scene and investigation better than the 2 CSI. I never liked Miami, they are doing police work rather than investigating and the girls of CSI Miami are more like models than crime scene investigator.
