Who is likely to speak first.....

@dpk262006 (58676)
Delhi, India
October 25, 2007 5:06am CST
Two unknown women are sitting together at a place and two unknown men are sitting together at that place. In your opinion, who would start speaking with each other first…….will pair of women start talking to each other or will men start talking to each other first? Please share your opinion/thoughts with appropriate reasons. Thanks in advance.
7 people like this
18 responses
@woodlin (158)
• United States
25 Oct 07
Honestly, there can be no logical answer to this. On one hand you have woman, she who loves to gab sitting across from another woman. What gossip does she have? I wonder where she bought that jacket? Then on the other hand you have 2 men who don't care about gossip, fashion or what not. Hey did you see that game last night? Wow, man it was awesome. Can you believe Bush did such and such? Man, my wife is such a nag! I think it just depends on the people. Are all 4 of them outgoing? Are 1 or more of them shy? Are any of them deaf? Are any of them mute? Are they gay? or straight? Do they know each other? If they are sitting together then it has to be assumed that each set knows the other person they are sitting with. I would say that there is an equal chance that the women will start talking first as the men. If they are sitting together, they must have a meeting or are out to socialize with each other. Therefore, conversation probably sparked before they even sat down. :) This was quite interesting, thanks for the brain meld! hehehe Have a good one!
2 people like this
• Abernathy, Texas
26 Oct 07
Well thought out answer. However, whose to say that the men - straight or gay, may want to gossip ( I know plenty) or talk about fashion (I know a few) or women who want to talk sports ( I know plenty). Me personally, I don't like to gossip, talk about fashion or sports. I think you're right they're are too many variables. Any answer we give based on on gender, will be based on pre-conceived notions, or gender based prejudices. We need to know about the individual personalities to decide this. Although I'm not sure what straight or gay would tell us, I think the rest of your questions would tell us more about personality and thus predilection to speak or remain quiet.
@woodlin (158)
• United States
28 Oct 07
hehehe.. I did no mean to sound as though I was stereotyping. I do apologize.. I re-read that and it does sound as such.. LOL.. I am a woman and I HATE fasion and would much rather talk about FOOTBALL!!!!! I was just trying to get to the point that I don't see a logical answer here unless you try and actually test it. Hey, I might make that a project for my kids. I home school them and this would be a good little study for them to do. :)
• Abernathy, Texas
28 Oct 07
Actually thats a great idea. One of the reasons I lean towards homeschooling (besides instilling a love of learning rather then the ability to memorize, regurgitate for a test then forget it) is because you can utilize real life situations instead of just sitting in the classroom. What would this be under - socialogy?
@SViswan (12051)
• India
2 Nov 07
Even though women talk a lot, they are wary of strangers and usually do not make the first move with unknown people. And knowing that a woman might take it the wrong way, a man might not speak to a lady he doesn't know. Unless, both the men are introverts, I am assuming one of the men will start speaking to the other man first.
1 person likes this
@SViswan (12051)
• India
13 Nov 07
Not necessarily. I, for one, wouldn't make the first move and I've travelled alone and never seen a lady make the first move to talk. It's always been the man especially when I've been alone.
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
8 Nov 07
Suppose only two women who are unknown to eather are sitting, then in that case, do not think that they cannot keep quite....for long....and one of them will break the ice to set the ball rolling. Have a great diwali! Deepak
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
8 Nov 07
pl. read 'eath other' in the first line.
@apsara60 (6610)
• Israel
28 Oct 07
Hello deepak, This discussion can have many answers, but I think it all depends on the mood of a person. If person is internally happy and relaxed, then he cannot remain quite for long time, no matter man or women. But if person is worried and depressed and engrossed in his own thoughts, then he would like to sit in silence rather than indulge into unwanted conversation in which he has not interest at that time. It also depends on education and maturity of people. Usally educated matured people think twice before opening any conversation, while simple people may start any conversation just for time pass and then forget about it. There was a time when it was said that two women cannot stop talking........but I think time has changed.....you really cannot say who will break the silence first.
1 person likes this
@apsara60 (6610)
• Israel
24 Mar 08
Thank you very much for BR deepak
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Thanks for your thoughtfulness and imagination and for enriching the post. Your views are quite interesting and I agree with your views. I agree that time has changed ...and anything can happen. :):)
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Nov 07
The women They always have something to share or ask and alot of times are more open than guys
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
8 Nov 07
Thanks for supporting my views! I am delighted.
@artemis432 (7474)
• Abernathy, Texas
26 Oct 07
I think its hard to say. I saw an answer that said maybe the women have something to gossip about. The men may want to talk sports. Not all women are gossipers - I have no interest in talking about other people or about fashion and such. However the women might want to talk about who won a recent football game - who knows without making a blanket statement about gender? Some men like to gossip and talk about fashion - and they're not necessarily gay. Who knows, maybe the men will talk to the women or vice versa. I think it all depends on who is shy and who isn't. Who feels like talking and who doesn't. How can we make this choice without making an unfair statement about gender? I could say women tend to be more verbal and social - yet they're are so many men who are just this - outgoing, verbal and social. So I can't really say. I would need to know about the personalities - the individual personalities of these people - not just their gender. Hey deepak - hope you're doing well.
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Amy, I am fine. Thanks for enriching the discussion with your interesting thoughts. I appreciate your views and liked it very much. Have a great day to you! Deepak P.S. - it appears to me that you do not feel like replying to my PMs???????
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
8 Nov 07
Amy! Thanks very much!
• Abernathy, Texas
1 Nov 07
I 'm pretty sure I've replied to all of your pms although I haven't gotten any in a few weeks. I don't address the picture exchange though because it makes me a bit uncomfortable.
1 person likes this
@icon_001 (584)
• India
1 Nov 07
In more likelihood,the Women should start talking first. But the Women may be from a very different Region or Age and Men may not have so many differences. So it just might be possible that Men start talking to each other. It is all chance & Luck .
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
your line of thinking and mine appear similar, but see the other responses also, others have also given very interesting answers. have a nice day!
@ssh123 (31073)
• India
25 Oct 07
Obviously it is women who start off with giving a half hearted smile to other women and keep talking instantly. Men give a doubtful look, if otherman responds, he gives a smile and I am sure whether they really start exchanging pleasantaries.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Sada, your line of thinking and mine appear similar, but see the other responses also, others have also given very interesting answers. have a nice day!
@emarie (5442)
• United States
26 Oct 07
It honestly depends on the person if the 2 (men or women) are shy, then they probably won't speak to each other unless they see something they can talk about. I think this works with both men and women. My husband is a chatter box and I'm not, but studies have shown that women normally talk more then men. So you'll have to take in the rest of the surroundings. Where are the sitting? Why are they there? If I had to make a cold guess...I would probably say the 2 women since woman can relate to each other more.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Thanks for sharing your views. It made interesting reading. Have a great day!
@luzamper (1357)
• Philippines
29 Oct 07
It depends upon the characters of those 4 people. There are women who are timid and so they will not approach first whereas there are men who are aggressive and so they will approach first. And so it all depends.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Thanks for sharing your views.
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
25 Oct 07
I believe that the men will start talking first because they get restless a lot faster than women. One man will say to another, so have about those Dodgers, or Lakers, Knicks, or whatever sport is going on at the time. I know for me, I can be quiet around strangers for a while. Men don't have as much of a hard time striking up converstation as women do. Women tend to be more insecure in these situations.
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Thanks for sharing your views. It made interesting reading. Have a great day!
@subathra (3519)
• India
26 Oct 07
since i travel in bus regularly i have seen mostly its the women who talk with another women even if they dont know each other..but cant say that men does talk with other men..They do but the one likely to speak first are the women.. on several occasions i have found my co passengers talking to me while travelling and i speak only few words as i dont feel much comfortable in talking to someone totally strange to me..
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Suba, your line of thinking and mine appear similar, but see the other responses also, others have also given very interesting answers. have a nice day!
• China
28 Oct 07
Well,ob my point of view,both of them will have the possiblity to speak first,it all depends Normally,I think the women will speak first maybe because they will have so many things to talk with.for instance ,the common family chores the children and so many topice they can choose . however, as for men they are more considerate ,they are more carefully in choosing the talking topics..
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Oct 07
Hi DPK! Well, I think the men would start talking first. I think this way because men arent so competetive with one another as women are. Some women feel intimidated by other women simply because of how they look. Im not saying all, but in my experience this is what takes place. Men are too simple to let that kind of thing get in the way of holding a conversation. And lets face it, men always have sports to talk about! I guess it could be possible that each of them both speak with eachother! There would be no man or woman doing it first. But Im thinking your asking for one or the other here. Bay Lay Gray xx
1 person likes this
@dpk262006 (58676)
• Delhi, India
1 Nov 07
Thanks for enriching the discussion with your interesting thoughts. I appreciate your views and liked it very much. Have a great day to you! Deepak
@koolezzi (14)
26 Oct 07
hi i would say that pairs of women will start the discussions first cause womens are eager to talk share there talks and feelings and emotions with any one and if she got a women partner she will immediately start to talk as men can controll there emotions and feelings and will never say to any one unless he wants to and i would tell you that women cant be quite for much time unless she is upset or something have happened to her men can go without talkin but womens cant go without talking or without sharing there feelings
@youless (112481)
• Guangzhou, China
26 Oct 07
I think the gentlemen shall speak at first. This is common.
1 person likes this
• United Arab Emirates
29 Feb 08
I think women will start talking first. Sometimes it can be the opposite. But, normally women tend to be more talkative than men. Well, it depends on the situation. Have a nice day!
• Philippines
26 Oct 07
definitely women. its because we are born with it, women are chatters. if you notice even in the powder room, we tend to chat with those people we dont know. women love to chat more than men.
1 person likes this
@suzhou (67)
• China
26 Oct 07
I think the two unknow women would start speaking with each other first. Because the female compares excels to exchange , moreover they like exchangeing .In my impression,the man like silencing. Do you think so?