White and Yellow, what's the difference?

@Kythe42 (1412)
United States
October 26, 2007 4:16pm CST
Ok this has been bugging me for awhile and I'm hoping someone can answer this. Certain cheeses like american and cheddar come in white and yellow. I'm wondering if anyone can tell me what the difference is between the white and yellow cheeses? As far as I can tell, they taste the same, but there's gotta be some difference between them that makes them a different color. I've asked many people and know one knows the answer. Thanks in advance to anyone who can clear up this mystery.
6 responses
@raychill (6525)
• United States
27 Oct 07
I always think it's so weird when I go to eat some chedder cheese and it's not yellow! It's only cause I'm so used to yellow. A friend of mine in Australia eats all organic and natural type foods. So when I went to visit her I had all the same stuff as her. So of course, they only had white cheeses. I was never sure why cheese is dyed yellow. I mean, why does it need to be yellow? it doesn't really change the taste. But every time I buy cheese at the deli I always ask for yellow American. Why? I grew up with yellow American and it just seems weird to ask for white American. However, I was once a culinary arts major. Yellow cheese seems to sell more and is more popular. So that is why they dye cheese. Most cheeses are actually dyed with Annatto...which is funny because it's actually red, not yellow.
1 person likes this
@Kythe42 (1412)
• United States
27 Oct 07
Thanks for all that info, it was very informative.
@jillhill (37354)
• United States
27 Oct 07
I think the white American is just missing the food coloring. I don't think it makes a difference it's just that we are used to seeing it yellow. If you find out more let me know.
1 person likes this
@jbwala (10)
• India
27 Oct 07
I think its differ in test.
• United States
27 Oct 07
I thought this a good question so did a quick search. One source said that if cows graze on grass which is the briight green seen in summer the milk is slightly darker than pure white resulting in a more yellow color (I am not too sure about that). However, several sources (including a university in Michigan, not MI State) say that the cheese is colored with annato or onnato (spelling was different in different sources) seed, which would be a spice. I regret that my granddad, who made his own is no longer here for me to ask. So, that's the info I found. Personally, I prefer yellow cheeses, they tend to taste sharper to me.
• China
27 Oct 07
sorry ,i don't know. but i like both of them
• China
27 Oct 07
sorry ,i don't know. but i like them all.