Anderson or Nani.?.?.?

defantly anderson, hes passing is superb and he is so mature for 19y/o. Nani is a smartarse and is immature on the pitch, he needs to stop diving and having a sook. just my opinion.

both are upcoming talents.... in the match against arsenal...nani might have been a better choiced as he was in a better goal run....he was striking well...had good midfield presence... anderson was not too impressive by standards expected of a brazilian player ... football is a beautiful game...nani and anderson are expected to be doyens of the same.,.. some clubs like chelsea may get some results playing hard football... but the beauty of the game is in players like ronaldinho...robinho...in song .. nani's goal in a friendly ..a beautiful flick over the goalkeeper made me his fan...but anderson has been consistent and impressive at porto too...both are good but on the day ..i might choose nani over anderson...more mature more composed... manchester united rules... let football stay beautiful.....

As an ardent United fan, I'll go for both. Both are tremendous talents, and have lots to improve on. Anderson has shown a more consistent brand of fotball, while Nani has shown spectacular game turning flashes. We all remember how well Christiano has come along in the last couple of seasons. If these two make even half the progress that Christiano has, we would have a terrific time supporting Manchester United!!

It gotta be Nani...he's got some skill to do the damage...

nani is my pick. his start for united was better than anderson. anderson seem nervous playing for united but he's not that bad. nani shoots better but he needs to practice to shoot like a bullet...like ronaldo

Have to go for Anderson... more of an all-round game. Nani still has his moments though.

i love manchester united and for me each of the member of the united squad are great ones..i think this is a foolosh question to ask to united fans

well .. its a very difficult choice .to make .. both are extremely talented and gifted players .. nani .. an attacking player with his dribbles n all whch can give nightmares to any opposing team defence .. n Anderson .. thwarting the attack .. of opposing teams .. a very strong midfield player are both the future of manchester united .. well . if to choose between the two . then i would vote for anderson .. he has played very good against big side in the premier league.. showing maturity and his strength in defence n keeping the ball . nani had also been impressive but once or twice he shows his inexperience ..

Any chance to select both instead? Both are very good young players. I am sure they will both be a great assets for Manchester United for years to come provided they avoid injury and can maintain their performance. Anderson is a brilliant playmaker and have good passing skills which in the long term will surely replace the legendary Paul Scholes position in the squad. While Nani is a good winger who has similar skills with his Portuguese counterpart Cristiano Ronaldo. He already scored 2 brilliant goals for Manchester United so far and what he needs to develop now is his crossing skills.

I would say Nani has started better in the Premier league, but i think that Anderson is starting to improve and will eventually be the better player. I think United, after a shaky start will go on to win the league with the amount of firepower they have at their disposal.

NANI all the way if my only choice are them. Anderson has his moments but very few between