Anti-Christian Anti-God

I don't know anything about this movie specifically, so I can't comment on the movie specifically. I do have one thing to say about this, though, as I have seen a lot of negativity about this movie. No one jumped up and down arguing about "The Chronicles of Narnia" when it came out. And that is CLEARLY a Christian movie disguised as a children's film. What is the difference? If someone doesn't like the idea behind a movie they should choose not to let their kids see the movie. But they shouldn't stop others from allowing their kids to see it. And they shouldn't judge others for seeing it, either. I'm sorry, but I just see this as a double standard for Christians. It is okay for Narnia to be hyped the way it was, but it is not okay for this movie to show it's view. I have a problem based on principle.

You should really check out the website for the movie. It explains more about the plot. The people in this story do not live in our world--it is an alternate world where god is senile and not taking care of his creation. (Actually I got that from lovely ladies that have actually read the books--many whom are Christian and never noticed the anti-god thread of the book). In the books Lyra (the little girl in the story) ends up going to confront the evil religious leaders that are kidnapping and torturing children. Torturing as in removing their souls which live on the outside of people in this world (as animals). She wants to stop this. I'm not sure how they kill god or why other then I have heard he was senile and uncaring for his creations and was letting them suffer. This isn't about killing "your" god it is about killing an uncaring god of another world. Yes the author made a comment about his books being about killing god but did anyone ever stop to think he was just trying to get publicity for his books. And in the end, even if that was his intention that doesn't mean you have to interpret the story that way. I know the Chronicles of Narnia was written by an avowed Christian to hopefully teach Christian values to children but I have seen the movie (haven't read the book yet, though) and didn't see any of that. It was just a fanciful tail of talking animals and brave children. Again, this isn't "your" god, it is "a" god that happens to resemble your god. And I don't see your point about it being "allowed" to be shown. It is a children's book (for ages 12-17--I looked on the cover myself) and was made into a children's movie. Why? Because not everyone in the world is Christian and believes in the Christian interpretation of morals. I, for one, am looking forward to seeing this movie with my children just like we watched Narnia together. I am also going to buy the books when I get some money.

I think it should be up to an individuals discretion if they want to go see a movie or not.If They feel it's offensive,then don't go watch it,but hpw can you ask if such a movie is allowed to exist? Every movie will contain something that will be offensive to a group of people. You can't just expect them to ban movies left and right. Nobody forces you or anybody else to go see a movie you find despicable. I do respect your choice to not want to have anything to do with this movie,but give people that want to see it a choice. By banning it, that choice would be taken away.

I don't believe in Anti-Anything. We should Learn to see the Perfection in all things in God's world.To this end children need to be shown and taught the full picture. The Catholic Church routinely brainwashes kids in their religious schools and will say publicly," If we can get them by 6 we can keep them for life!" This is not a teaching where kids can see both sides of an issue and join in a discussion, rather its an indroctination. Its very obvious where the church is coming from, what with the problems they are having recruiting new priests, and the coverup of the child molestation scandles. We all abhor murder and bloodshed, and most would shield their kids from it, but its important that both sides of every issue be shown and discussed. Christian faithful will not be duped forever. More and more are rebelling every day, (hense the critical shortage of Priests) I thought the article you included was quite one-sided as well. I for one, think all relgions including atheism, should be introduced and debated by children and unbiased teachers. Remember there ARE 2 sides to every story, and more than one way to get to Heaven!

I do not like the idea of any childrens book, movie, or whatever killing God. The best way to portest this is have nothing to do with it. Do not go to the movie! Honestly, I would like to see the movie, but do I think my 5 year old is going to want to kill God if I take him to see this movie? No. I seriosuly doubt I will see it. I am broke. Anyway, There has been many religous movies in the past few years. I guess Hollywood feels they need to kill it.

You know, it's not really something I actually think about. I do believe in God, but you have to remember that a movie is fictional as well as the story. All you have to tell your kids is that it's a make believe story. I think it's up to the parents to tell the kids what is real and what is not. Freedom of speech still exists and always will. If you don't like what the story or movie are about then don't bother with it. It's ok to feel what you feel, but not everyone will see it the same way.

People can say that it's "just a movie" all they want, but it's not. If you read what the author of the book says, you can see his intent behind the books and movies. I have no problem with movies that are fantasy (in fact, it's one of my favorite genres)but when someone starts trying to turn children away from God, then that's where I draw the line. I will NOT be taking my children to see it, nor will I rent it. They will be told that they are not allowed to watch it and I will explain why. I think it's underhanded that this is being marketed as a "children's movie".

Fictional movies you say?!?!? Remember that some stories has true and meaningful basis. Like the Da Vinci code. Why has Dan Brown Written that movie is because of years research not by him but by other historians.