Plight of women

Injustice - Injsutice in Saudi
India
November 23, 2007 12:49am CST
I read in todays news paper that a 19 year old women in Saudi was punsihed for being raped. She was gang raped and when she took the matter to the media, she was ordered to be lashed for being in the car of an unrelated man and also taking the matter to the media. She was also imprisoned for 6 months, While the culprits were sentended to 2 to 9 years of imprisonment. How far is the law of the land justified? What are your views on this? In india there was a protest at Saudi consulate in Mumbai
4 people like this
16 responses
• India
23 Nov 07
I can't question the law of saudi government because i am not a citizen of that country. also you have not mentioned if saudi people opposed to such an act by their government. first of all, the raped victim should have taken the issue either to the police or to the court. if police is not taking any action, and if their country's court can't help her then she can ask help from government and/or from human rights commission. instead of taking these actions, if she talk to media directly, then her motive is questionable.
• India
23 Nov 07
Although her motive was questionable, why should she be ordered to take the punsihment. If we assume that she had motives behind taking the scene to media - that implies that she is guilty, so based on this assumption she alone should have been punished while the accused should be left. It is evident that she was subjected to indecency. What if she takes the matter to media or not? i feel she did right by doing so else a dirty compromise would have been reached and nobody would have known tha barbaric act.
• India
23 Nov 07
hi sandeep, first of all, I can't question the law of saudi government due to reasons i have told earlier, so i can't comment on the question why she is ordered a jail sentence. secondly, if she is having a motive, it does not mean that she is guilty as you have guessed. guilty depends on what motivated her to take the issue to media without knocking the door of justice first, and who is there at background. it is only upto the court to find these truths and that's the reason why i said her motive is questionable.
• India
26 Nov 07
Yeah you are right in a way and i didn't think from that perspective. Am any way following the story in cnnibn. I will check out what finally happens.
@mansha (6298)
• India
23 Nov 07
I also read the story and I also read reporters comments on it where he says countries like UK and USA can not protest including India in lod voice as Saudi is the largest exporter of oil so they can actually do whatever they want to with their women. I think unles the women decide to change their fate nothing can be accomplished by meagre muffled protests.
@mansha (6298)
• India
1 Dec 07
I wish women themselves had more sense then to succumb to such cruelty. Mother is one person who can change society if she wants too, I hope young mthers of saudi arabia are more forthcoming then their own moms.
• India
27 Nov 07
You are absolutely right. As long as they allow such indictments, they suffer. It is they who have to protest first
1 person likes this
@subha12 (18441)
• India
24 Nov 07
It is very very bad. I can't say the laws in our country are very much justified, but it is also not this much grave. It is a shame on human race. the women was raped and now she is imprisoned for 6 months, in those countries the law and all is very shameful.
• India
27 Nov 07
Rather than feeling ashamed of such inhuman practices, they are very proud of their law. What a pity
@dreamy1 (3811)
• United States
23 Nov 07
I read about that the other day it's just unimaginable that women are treated like that. I'm glad this girl was brave enough to stand up and say that this is not fair and let the world know what's going on. She is very brave and she may be an inspiration to other women to stand up and fight.
• India
23 Nov 07
Thre is this lady from bangaldesh named taslima. She wrote a book condemning few practices in her society and this raised furore among the extremists. How come these extremists do all such disgusting things in the anme of a sacred religion?
• Philippines
23 Nov 07
Wow. That's really unfair. I mean, she was the one who was raped and yet she was still punished?! Poor woman. I hope they release her. Only the rapists should be punished. And I think 2 to 9 years would not be enough. Rape is such a nasty violation of human rights.
• India
23 Nov 07
i sometimes wonder how the lamakers could come out with such absurd laws
• Brazil
23 Nov 07
É eu penso que ficando num lugar desses é muito bom, passar o dia
• China
23 Nov 07
this is the first time i heard the things like this, how it can be,i dont think it's something about the law justice, i think there should be some subjective problems in it,like the hunman relationship factors involved,or maybe in the real situation, there must be some mistakes in the one who was reaped.if this is not equally judged by the law, that's misery side of this society.
• India
26 Nov 07
this is the sharia law (generally followed in Islamic countries)
@bcl_me (582)
• Philippines
23 Nov 07
Oh, do not feel pitty for this people...I've rode a bus one time and the sitting next to me is a female a working woman...and she keeps on hiding her cell phone on her bag and then after a minute she will get it out...and what do you know her arms are touching my hips and really she's not ashame to do that...I think most women are like that they work to look for s3x on the street...
@drannhh (15219)
• United States
26 Nov 07
I sure hope there was a protest! I suppose many women had to walk to the protest, though, in order to avoid being in the car of unrelated men. Officials in most countries do things to try to discourage women from reporting crimes, but for that to happen in this day and age is very tragic.
@faith210 (11224)
• Philippines
23 Nov 07
Hi sandeep_t! I heard so amny stories about women being raped there, some were unfairly deported and the culprits are still in their country grinning with the experience they had. I just hope that someday the evil things they did to these women will come back to them a thousand fold. I hope that woman will recover somehow and things will somehow be better for her. I know there will be a lot of us women who will be praying for her. Take care and have a nice day. :)
@roberten (3128)
• United States
23 Nov 07
Where is the justice? Where is the common sense? Shame will drive people to do all sorts of things. We can make a difference one person at a time. Love and tolerance is the key; if we could only put ourselves in the other person's place, maybe we would make different choices. People are the same, yet they differ as much as there are sands upon the shore...one person at a time is the beginning of change. Let us begin the process of chain as individuals.
• United States
23 Nov 07
dear s...that is so tragic, i will pray that she can recover not only from her violent rape, but also what her government did to her. may women all over this world, unite and take back our lives from the hands of dishonest men and corrupt governments...may God protect all woman, and keep them in His loving Hands. please take care all women that can read this, you are the vulnerable ones of society, you and your children...stanzi
• Brazil
23 Nov 07
Bonita foto!
• India
23 Nov 07
I can see thats its unfair and also dumb. But they gave her the punishment because: - she was in the car of an "unrelated" man. (and women have got very strict rules in Saudi) - we don't know who that was. so maybe this led to her being raped. But still, I don't think she should have been lashed and imprisoned. It adds to her pain(at the heart).
• China
24 Nov 07
i have heard about many unfair things,but this kind of unfair thing i never heard about.she is a victim,what should we do is to protect her,take care of her,not punish her.to be raped is a harm to her body and soul.how can they do that to her,where is the law???
@furion1 (272)
• Philippines
23 Nov 07
That is so weird. Why would they punish the victim? I think they should only punish the rapists and not the girl. So what if she went to the media to report? It is because she wanted justice, not punishment! There are a lot of times when the media could help out and that is why she went there. I think they should reconsider the judgment and release her. It is just too unjust to punish the victim and I know she is in too much pain.
@bishu_sinha (1457)
• India
23 Nov 07
This activity is a black spot of any Nation. It should immediate stop and we should coperate to delete tis word from dictionary.
• Canada
23 Nov 07
This is disgusting!!! Laws in those friggin countries need to change. It's no wonder why we end up with illegal immigrants.