Are we raising our kids correctly?

my kids - This photo was taken during a trip.
@sherinek (3320)
United States
November 25, 2007 11:32pm CST
I wonder! When i read discussions on myLot and the stories i hear everyday, I feel like kids are taking charge. Is this the weakness of parents? when we love our kids, do we miss limits. Is it bad to scold a kid and is it really bad to say no? My nephew on and off stay at home without going to school. His parents (my bro and sis in law) were too leanient on him when he was small and was going according to the book. But now, after 15 yrs, they have no control over him. I look at my two kids one 9 yrs and the ohter 5 yrs and so worried how they would turn out. We think we are going our best, but ........... Friends, do you have any advise?
6 people like this
12 responses
• United States
26 Nov 07
Hi Sherinek, Im not a parent, but I see people with their kids on a daily basis in public, and I do think kids have taken over in many households. I would have never dared to treat my parents the way I see some kids doing it today. They talk back, curse, do what they want and its just shocking really. Younger children throw fits and cry and scream and parents give in because they dont want to hear it. If discipline was in action, I dont think kids would act this way. You can discipline kids without abusing them or hitting them in any way. I think parents might think their kids will hate them, but Im sure their parents did things they didnt like and they didnt stop loving them. Things arent always going to be peaches and cream especially between parents and children. I can imagine it hard saying no to them, I have a hard time saying no to my hubby or freinds! But sometimes you have to say no, and the way you go about it makes all the difference. Bay Lay Gray xx
3 people like this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
27 Nov 07
Using the word no is not the problem. Problem is kids dont understand the meaning of that word because, sometimes parents say no and then after some convincing by the kid they say yes. So kids most of the time, throw a tantrum knowing that the parent would given in. This comes with parent not having time to rule the kids. They are just so busy or tired to go deeply into the problem and give a ruling in the first place. I feel pity for parents as well as kids.
2 people like this
@ssh123 (31073)
• India
26 Nov 07
Whatever you say, I would like to say BIG NO. We as parents are failing in our duty in not properly raising the children. It is probably due to present day busy schedule both the parents have. Whatever is the reason, if the child is not brought up properly, then it is the parents who are going to suffer in future. The old values like respect for elders, adherence to some principles of honesty, dedication, hard work are fading and now-a-days parents seem to be lacking interest or losing grip on children and if they do not spend time with children by correcting whereever they are going wrong, no one except parents are to be blamed.
@ssh123 (31073)
• India
27 Nov 07
Obviously handling youngsters means handling fireballs. So we got to express our genuine love and affection in the first place. Secondly with love and affection only we should try to inclulcate in them, the values. Once it is done from the beginning say from 4 to 15, I think let them learn from outside the realities. They always remember the parents for the good things they have taught them, because the world is cruel, disgusting. They will be able to adapt themselves to the situation with their originality. There will always some rotten apples in an apple tree.
1 person likes this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
27 Nov 07
I know! That is why i am this much scared of the future. We are trying our best. All talking, having quality time together, setting example, setting rules and regs, limits, etc etc are there. But still.... it is not possible for us to keep kids covered from the world. They have to face the challenges, they see the opportunities and freedom, they see various other things and we cannot stop. Only we can do is educate them about the repercussions. We try to do that as well. But how long and how much we can do it is the real problem i see.
2 people like this
@academic2 (7000)
• Uganda
26 Nov 07
Parents, I mean modern day parents are just too busy with the hussles of life than with the dynamics of parenting. In working families, where both mum and Dad leave home very early in the morning and come back deep into the night, when do they find time to teach and mentor their kids? Kids become little "Lords of the Fly" in the Home and they even start questioning the authority of parents. Parents should have time for their kids, to know who they socialize with and to say no to wrong peers. Parents should drive their kids a long a set of beliefs that make them grow into law abiding and useful citizens. Parents should attempt to bond with their kids and assert their authoriy over them. In my culture we dont spare the rod to spoil the child-my father was a loving man, but he did not hesitate to cane us for our transgressions-that made us grow up knowing that in the home it was he and mum who ran the show. In the west am told, caning a child is a crime and children are known to have taken their parents to court, this demands that parents find other ways of asserting their authorities over their kids in manner that permits the kid to accept their teaching, mentoring and authority.
3 people like this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
26 Nov 07
I am from Sri Lanka and we also very rarely use the cane as a thing to control. Not on the smaller one but the elder one cos he is old enough to understand. Kids now a days a difficult cos they see and hear more things and compare. We take time before going to bed to be with kids and share stories. Its a very valuable time. I take my elder one for studies and go through his books on a daily basis. Younger one starts school next year. I sense that i am going on the right path. but still i have my doubts cos the society is such, the kids learn enough and more unnecessary and bad things by the second.
2 people like this
• United States
27 Nov 07
"leave home very early in the morning and come back deep into the night, when do they find time to teach and mentor their kids?" My parents both worked and yet I was raised correctly and didn't turn out to be "Lords of the Fly." "my father was a loving man, but he did not hesitate to cane us" My father spanked us, too, but very rarely and it was for serious infractions. I may have gotten 6 or so spankings from my dad as a kid, but you better bet I remember them.
@kcbomba (616)
• United States
27 Nov 07
The white truth is that these whole controversy has been settled in th living word of God . "Train up a child in the way he should go , and when he's old - he won't depart from it" . Furthermore,"spare not the rod ,less you spoil the kid" . The Bible said children are bound in foolishness,the parents are the ones to pave a niche for their children ,but they've failed in their matrimonial tasks . Too bad, so sad , to see our society will be heading for a decadent one with such approaches.
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
27 Nov 07
I do wonder.... where did we lose and when did we stop?
2 people like this
@Rozie37 (15499)
• Turkmenistan
26 Nov 07
I believe that local churches need to have parenting classes. They need to teach the expecting parents from the word of God about raising their children properly. After all, it is the best instruction manual ever created.
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
26 Nov 07
Actually, they have programmes at school to educate the parents. We follow what they teach. Both my kids go to Catholic Schools. They always say not to say "no" but to divert attention, not to cane and to respect the kids. All these things we do. We know that a kid should be treated as an individual and respected accordingly. But, after doing all these, still the chances are...... the kids go wild at times.
2 people like this
• United States
26 Nov 07
Church sponsored parenting classes would never work in the U.S. The simple reason is that the U.S. is a state based on religious freedom. If parents are interested in raising their children with Christian values they should already be seeking to do that. The other parents who don't share those beliefs would not get benefit from these classes.
2 people like this
• Philippines
27 Nov 07
I cannot say that I raised my kid correctly all i know is that I try my very best to lead him on the right track I could that I raised him right if He has his own life.
3 people like this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
27 Nov 07
Thats what we all do dear gem, try and keep our fingers crossed!
2 people like this
• India
26 Nov 07
Well I think that kids are taking charge coz we are letting them to. We are giving our kids too many options, too many exposures to various media and we are too stressed out most of the time to sit back and take the rein in our own hands. In the case of your nephew…before his parents could discipline him, they thought of child psychology, counseling, state interference, peer pressure, bad effects of corporeal punishment, their own career (maybe) etc etc. In the midst of all this, they just let things happen hoping and believing that once the child grows up, he will be able to take his own responsibility. But children seldom take their own responsibility until and unless we teach them to…and for that parents need to combine indulgence and discipline in the right mix. Nowadays we hear so much about not hitting a child, not scolding a child, giving respect to the child etc. But we were not brought up that way. Our demands were met, new toys and candies were bought, we went for holidays but we also obeyed a certain line, crossing which was sure to mean a good spanking. We resented it at that time, but it put the fear of the parent in our minds. Counselors tell us that a child should not fear a parent. I don’t believe in it. By fear I don’t mean that the child should actually tremble all the time, but before the child does anything, h/she should at least think of the repercussions back home. We don’t fear our friends, so we can do anything and everything with them, neither are they bothered about our well-being (given that their maturity level is same as ours.) Similarly a child can booze with friends without fear, but if parents are strict at home, h/she will definitely give it a second thought before indulging. All in all, direct involvement in the child’s daily affairs is a must for every parent. We cant let a child act as a grown up and take all decisions when we know that children are not mature enough to be responsible.
3 people like this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
26 Nov 07
Thank you very much for a well versed answer. What you say is exactly correct. Children should realize there is a limit and if the limit is crossed, he/she would have to face the repercussions. Sure the kids should not tremble but they should have some fear to do bad things and should have enough respect for the parent. To inculcate these qualities in them is the challenge of today's parent.
2 people like this
• Philippines
26 Nov 07
i don't believe in physical punishment when it comes to disciplining kids...physical punishment will only traumatize their childhood...
• Philippines
26 Nov 07
Are we raising our kids correctly?
2 people like this
• United States
27 Nov 07
"traumatize their childhood..." Link? Proof? I was physically punished and I grew up fine. No trauma here.
@sid556 (30960)
• United States
26 Nov 07
Parenting is a very tough job. We can only do our best and pray alot. No it is not wrong to set limits and expectations for our kids. Parenting is a 24-7 job and I think most of us worry and wonder whether we are doing good enough.
3 people like this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
26 Nov 07
True. Praying we have to do a lot, which i do. Still the worry doesnt go away, may be my faith is not that strong when it comes to kids. Thanks for your comment.
2 people like this
• Philippines
27 Nov 07
dont be afraid of what your kids might be you said that you do your best best to raise them well....it is right to scold them ...why? so that they can realized whats right or wrong they do....
3 people like this
@blueunicorn (2401)
• United States
26 Nov 07
Although it would not be a popular option, I honestly believe the best way to take control of our kids again would be to go back to old fashioned family values. One of the parents could be at home caring for the household while the other parent worked to provide for the family. In this way the kids have someone at home when they leave for school and when they return. The kids feel that there is a parent watching out for them. It would mean a huge change in lifestyle for most (at least in the U.S), but it would be worth it. As families we need to learn to spend more time together, spend less money, want less "things", and start having a heart again. We need to spend time volunteering together and sharing ourselves with other people- not our electronic gadgets. I honestly think that the decline of the parental authority comes from two parent working households and the extremely high divorce rates.
2 people like this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
27 Nov 07
I fear it would be practical at all nowadays. One thing, both parents have to work to keep up to the living standards. It would be like heaven if we can start at the beggining. But.....?
2 people like this
• United States
27 Nov 07
You made my point right there, though. Both parents have to work to keep up the standard of living that we keep. If we would look at what is truely important we might see that the standard of living is what needs to change. We don't need to have 2,000 square foot houses for 3 or 4 people to live in. The gardener and the maid that go with that house could go, too. Then all the "toys" that people need to buy and the huge credit card balances could be brought down as well. With just a few attitude adjustments we could bring the kids back to being the main focus in our lives instead of all the "stuff".
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Nov 07
Be a parent first then be a friend. You have to set boundaries for your kids and not let them rule the roost. I see kids all the time backtalk and slap their parents around as if the kids were the wardens of the prison. The parents are supposed to step up and take charge. You won't damage an ego or bruise a psyche if you actuall parent and set limits and control the little demonic monsters. If I even tried to raise a hand to my mother when I was little, I wouldn't be around to hear about it. I got slapped whenever I backtalked and was disciplined where I have respect for others, know when I'm not in charge and do what I'm told. Too many parents are trying to be their kid(s) friends first rather than be parents first, friends secondly. Being friends with your kids is fine, but you also have to be authoritative in order for them to grow up not being spoiled brats.
1 person likes this
@sherinek (3320)
• United States
3 Dec 07
I agree with you. True you cannot raise kids according to the books.