taking a break from a relationship?

November 27, 2007 4:34am CST
Hi, If ur partner asked for a short "break" from your current relatioship, 1-would u agree or disagree? 2-What's your "IDEA" of a break and would you acutually think about the reason that your partner's request? 3-Is it justifiable if your partner slept with someone else during THAT break? *state your honest opinions please..
2 people like this
9 responses
@mensab (4200)
• Philippines
28 Nov 07
first, i will suspend my decision and listen to her story why she is asking for a break. if there is a valid ground to grant her request for break, then i will definitely give her what she wants. afterall, i would support her in any decision that she would like to make. if in my evaluation that there is no valid reason for a break, i will talk things out with her. if that does not work, then i will yield to her request for a break. to me, break is a suspension of relationship that in anytime can be recalled with both sides deciding. therefore, it is not justifiable for someone to sleep with other person. it is never justifiable. it is cheating. the person is also cheating him/herself.
28 Nov 07
My friend. You are a wise human being. i have rated you positive for your response. and i agree with you on the way you would handle it. i thank you so very much!!
1 person likes this
@rsa101 (38166)
• Philippines
27 Nov 07
For me when in a relationship you should always have that commitment with each other to be faithful and honest with one another. If your partner would be involved with someone that only means he/she is not committed and is not worth keeping anymore. Just my opinion abut relationships. There is no such thing as a temporary break or something to that effect.
28 Nov 07
dear sir, i thank you a great deal. the word commitment says it all. commitment CAN be a frustrating thing in ones life. commitment alone does not help if NOT accompanied by love. to some having a break is a relief from commitment, which means they do not love you @ all. i thank you again. very much.
1 person likes this
• Saudi Arabia
28 Nov 07
hi there.. 1- For me having a break from a relationship means it became boring.. and for me I either try to make it interesting again or get out of it if I lost hope and faith in it... 2- The only break I believe in is break up... 3- If I accepted having a break I think there have to be conditions.. if me and my partner agreed on it; then I dont have the right to be angry.. but if not this will certainly be the break up... Nice topic :)
30 Nov 07
1- maybe, but dont you think your partner needs sometime "off" of everything. too much pressure can lead to explosions. 2- u might change ur mind in that. as u r saying that not of experience. 3- thanks.
1 person likes this
@lucky_witch (2707)
• Philippines
29 Nov 07
I believe that if someone would ask foe a break then maybe he would need time. It is ok with me but of course I want to know the reason why. It is normal to ask about it. But sleeping with another woman, I dont think so. I would think that he ask for a break because he want to sleep with another girl... and if thats the case... he could say goodbye forever to me.
30 Nov 07
but isnt that what he wants? for him to say good-bye for you forever? would u easily grant him that?
1 person likes this
@mabelk (208)
• Germany
27 Nov 07
I think I would agree although I can't see my partner asking for a break even a short one. If there will be one of us who will ask for a break, I think it will be more likely to be me. If ever there will be one, maybe it will only be like giving each other some space or time to for one's self but no third party please...
28 Nov 07
Mabe, thank you so much for your reply. U have a way to state things simple and clear. I agree, a 3rd party is a big NO. i have sent you a PM.. have a nice day :)
1 person likes this
30 Nov 07
and i did my turn in replying to you. thanks so much.
1 person likes this
@mabelk (208)
• Germany
29 Nov 07
Your PM has been responded to.
@Kate324 (46)
• China
28 Nov 07
I have been asked for "a short break" by my partner,because he felt nearly choking when we always together,he just needs free time to handle some troubled matter,and can make me unworried about that.Also I have did the same thing before,ask for a short break,but I know the basis is that we trust for each other.So,I can agree that if he/she can give your reasonable answer. But if my partner slept with someone else during that break,something unusual must be happened,I will be angry with that,and I think there is no justifiable for him to do that,so I cannot accept and will say goodbye to him.I don't care what is the reason,but I cannot accept that bad things occurs to my mind and remain it for a long time,so I will let him go away.
30 Nov 07
just like that, u will let him go away? that is really nice of you dont you think? some people "use" that excuse to do everything and everything they want. not just to reflect and subtle and that is dishonest. how could they even do that? and may i emphasize that even if it was an official break up, the actions after that isnt justifiable either and to let someone "just" go away. i thank you for your response.
1 person likes this
@royanne (372)
• Philippines
27 Nov 07
i think i would agree to that because i think every relationship should have a break even for a moment specially if one of you feels suffocated. its something we all should do to think about the things we have to do in life. or maybe he/she is just having doubts about himself and needs to think it over. it's somethings he needs to be sure about. and here is the thing here a break is like a test of your love for each other because if your partner still comes back after that it means that he/she loves you very intimately and he has found that out in your absence. i think it is not right for you to judge your partner that he/she has slept with another person cause we never know. maybe he just needs time and space for himself. right? so i think if ever that happens reflect about your feelings too. and maybe your just carried away by the intense feeling you feel that you didn't realize you we're choking him/her. ^_^
28 Nov 07
i agree with you in some way. sometimes ppl need "space" but that does not justify sleeping with another. I thank you for your reply.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 Nov 07
of course i would first need an honest answer for asking the "break".... if it's honestly reasonable, then i agree. but that doesn't make it justifiable that my partner slept with someone else ! i mean what is that????? checking grounds or something ?
30 Nov 07
hello, i agree with you if there was a reasonable explanation, it would be ok. and about the ground checking thing, i really hope it wouldnt be the case. i thank you for your input.
1 person likes this
• United States
27 Nov 07
I would totally disagree. If they suggest in a short break it means the same thing as breaking up in my dictionary. If we are broken up then there shouldn't be any reason why you can not go out with anyone you want and do anything you want because your free to date now. In my opinion if you want to break up just say so do not ask for a short break, what the heck is that? How can you have a short break? I mean if I was tired one day with my kids or hubby can I tell them I want a short break from being a mother or a wife---NO. So why is dating any different. Just my opinion. Good luck.
28 Nov 07
Hello, thank you for your response. i used to think exactly the same. but sometimes there is so much pressure that sometimes partners cannot handle. call it distance loss of hope. THAT pressure will lead to an explossion and an end of the relationship. is there some sort of way that the 2 cam meet in the middle without actually going 2 to extreme of an actutal break-up?
1 person likes this