Would you get back together with an ex-bf / ex-gf ?
By silverlocket
@silverlocket (122)
United States
December 2, 2007 8:49pm CST
Ok... granted, if we are talking about an ex partner we assume that at one point the relationship did not work for one reason or the other.. sometimes different personalities, conflict of egos, lies and betrayal, cheating. or simply for reasons that weren't your or your partner's fault ( like moving, distance, work, family..etc).
Is true that SOME people MIGHT be able to change with time.. but is not a common thing ..Taking all this into consideration, would you give that person a second chance ? What makes you think that this time things will actually work when they didn't on the first trial ?
4 people like this
14 responses
@ladyluna (7004)
• United States
3 Dec 07
Hello Silverlocket,
Not only would I, I did! We are now very happily married. We've been back together for 10 years, and will celebrate our 6th wedding anniversary later this month.
Hubby & I dated for nearly four years when we were in our 20's. I was in college when we met. He had just returned from overseas. He's just two years older than I. Yet, when he returned to The States, he was ready to settle down. I, on the other hand, was ready to start adventuring. I did not wish to settle down where we grew up. So, despite the fact that I loved him dearly, I broke it off and moved away.
Nearly a decade later we got our second chance. To this day we each regularly thank the other, and our lucky stars that fortune shown down on us twice.
For us, though the personalities and values were a right blend, the timing -- or our level of maturity was not. We're both quite confident that had we stayed together back then, that we would not have lasted. It took time, separation, experiencing other people, and each of us maturing before we were really able to appreciate the other as a best friend, spouse, and life partner.
Does it work this way for everyone? No, I don't believe it does. However, for me the key was that we not only remained amiable through the apart years, we also both consciously or unconsciously compared other people to each other. For example: If a guy asked me out on a date, I would find that after the date, when I was alone, I would be comparing the guys traits to Hubby's. Of course, by that time, there were 2,000 miles and many lifetimes worth of experiences between Hubby & I. Neither thought that we'd ever get a second chance. But, we're sure glad we did!
2 people like this
@Ravenladyj (22902)
• United States
3 Dec 07
for me it would depend on the ex, myself, how much both of us have changed, whether or not we can see eye to eye about WHY we split in the first place and so on....I have gotten back together with ex's in the past including my husband and sometimes its worked out for a time, other times it was a huge mistake and other times still like with my husband it was a good idea and has held water ya know....Mind you I'm in a more stable, secure and headstrong place now than I was in my teen yrs and 20s...Back then I was still carving my own way in life ya know...now that I'm approaching 40 and have been, seen and done all I have in life I read ppl very well, know what I will and won't tolerate from anyone in my life and am set in my ways..Compared to back then, I now KNOW whether or not getting back with an ex would work out or not if that makes sense rather than back when I was younger and I just HOPED things would work out....
2 people like this
@cdv102 (132)
• United States
3 Dec 07
I did get back together with an ex, and basically the same thing that happened the first time around happened again, and it hurt twice as much. It was a big mistake, unfortunately. What made me think it would work? Well, he did make it sound like he had changed a lot over the years we were out of touch. And I guess I just wanted it to work so bad that I ignored my instincts. The good news is we're friends now, which is nice, and probably all we were ever meant to be.
1 person likes this
@silverlocket (122)
• United States
4 Dec 07
Thank you for commenting CDV :)
I know that once something has happened and history repeats itself, the pain is double.. But I understand that when you hear someone telling you "Ive changed" you keep wondering, is it true? could this be real this time? what if...?
I guess is only fair to give someone a second chance as long as the first time didnt cause major wounds, just have to be more careful as to not let the heart think ahead of the mind..
All in all, I don't think you regret doing it right? Like you say, you gained a friend :)
1 person likes this
@cdv102 (132)
• United States
5 Dec 07
Yeah, all in all, I'm glad he's still in my life, so I can't regret it. But I definitely would have saved myself a world of grief and heartache had I been a little more cautious the second time around. Plus instead of spending so much time and energy on a relationship that was doomed not to work out, I could have been out there finding someone who really wanted to be with me. Oh well. That's how you learn these life lessons, though. It taught me a lot about myself and what I want. And he's someone I will always have love for, so I'm happy that we have been able to maintain a friendship.
@darkaeon (465)
• Portugal
3 Dec 07
hi, thats a really interesting topic you are talking.In my opinion i would never get back with and ex girlfriend because if we broke up it was because something was not right and if we got back something like that would probably happen and it would be bad for both and if we just stay friends nobody gets hurt. Hope your having a good time here at mylot and that you continue to post intersting topics like this one ;)
1 person likes this
@silverlocket (122)
• United States
4 Dec 07
thank you Darkaeon for commenting, I'm glad that you found the topic interesting :)
I guess you follow the motto of "why fix something that is already broken" .. I guess we all take different paths in our lives depending of the situation.. I for once, know that there are people in my past that I would rather have as friends now than get back together, because like you say, by doing so we would take the risk of make things the wrong way and ruin a friendship..
On the other hand, I guess there is always that one person that when you think about her/him makes you smile, because the memories weren't that bad ;D
*mwuah!*
1 person likes this
@mandy_27 (67)
• Australia
3 Dec 07
no, I dont think that it will ever be the same as it was before you parted, I think that there will be dout in the persons mind that broke it off.
If the relationship parted due to moving or distance than maybe it is possible to get back together but for any other reason, i don't think that the relationship will work as there will be trust issues.
1 person likes this
@silverlocket (122)
• United States
3 Dec 07
I agree with you, once the trust is lost there is nothing else to do for a relationship.. the mere foundation of one is the ability to communicate clearly and honestly with your partner.. but once the relationship has hit a dark spot it is very difficult to have a new-fresh start.. i think in a way the past always comes back to haunt you..
1 person likes this
@Joel24_2007 (9)
• Philippines
3 Dec 07
maybe if there is a chance in a two lovers to be back together and live happily ever after...
2 people like this
@kokopelli (4842)
• United States
3 Dec 07
i just go back with an ex if he is not, for me, a real ex yet. i mean, if there's no one new with him or with me from the time we broke up. however, once i've started a new relationship, i knew that the last one will never work again, so there's no second chance for us. if i can still see hope, then i'll still be free, quietly waiting for him and me to go back together.
i don't give up easily on my relationship, i put so much patience, endurance, and love in it, that once i decided it's over, then it means i've already given my all, that i've reached my limit and it's really over. that means there's nothing we could do about it anymore.
1 person likes this
@wisedragon (2325)
• Philippines
3 Dec 07
If I'm not in love with anyone, yes I might consider dating an ex. Then we'll see where it goes from there. If it feels good then we should give it another try. If not, well
1 person likes this
@missak (3311)
• Spain
3 Dec 07
I think with this question you're assuming a classical relationship based on the idea "and they lived happily ever after". Well, if we go this way, I would say (in general, of course, because each case is a whole different world) that such a person won't really work, you can stay all your life returning and leaving back...
But in my personal opinion, what really counts is not the "ever after" but the moment, so I would say that if I find a reasonable oportunity to share a nice time with that person, I won't even reflect on what's to come, just let the things go on and enjoy the present time.
@silverlocket (122)
• United States
3 Dec 07
Well I do like your opinion.. I too think it might be about the precise time on which you are with that person .. but I don't believe on the happily ever after.. fairy tales are just empty assumptions that often end up letting people know (the cruel and hard way) that reality is far from that.. But back to the subject... don't you think that sometimes the illusion of what might be is the thing that makes you go back to those certain moments with someone ??
And once you realize things are just the way they were before, you end up thinking that it was all a waste of time ...
1 person likes this
@palonghorn (5479)
• United States
3 Dec 07
I've been married (and divorced) three times, would I ever actually consider getting back together with any of them......no. It didn't work before and since then I am a different person, as I'm sure they are too, I do keep in touch with my last ex-husband, because he still lives near our youngest daughter and I live 1600 miles away now. As for the first ex, I haven't seen nor spoken to him in 27 years, the second ex I haven't seen nor spoken too in 7 or 8 years, but I do know that he is remarried, if they haven't divorced lol. Quite frankly, I'm with a wonderful man in every sense of the word, and should we ever breakup........he'll be a hard act to follow, and I'm not sure that there is another man out there that could fill his shoes.
1 person likes this
@nkhanna (922)
• India
3 Dec 07
hi silverlocket.i guess even if my ex was not that kind of a person who would change with time,i would rather not give him another chance and the reason is that the person is the same.his abits and those things which made us apart would still be in him.so rather than to make both of ours life get into mess,i would prefer to be single.i truly believe that love relations once broken leaves a strain.so better to move ahead without that person in life.
1 person likes this
@silverlocket (122)
• United States
3 Dec 07
thanx for ur response nkhanna (btw is that an arabic name?)
i also think that once a relationship is over, whether you try to fix it with time, the feeling is not the same.. i find it hard to believe that it can turn out to be better or perhaps you would be able to try but always carrying some "sentimental luggage" .. :)
1 person likes this
@fanji008 (775)
• China
3 Dec 07
Hi,there! Well,I think this really depends on the reason that the two got separated.If the love doesn't work or the two know exactly that they don't fit each other at all,then maybe it's not very likely that they'll go back together with each other.If there're some other reasons like distance or work and the like,then it's possible that such problems don't exist and they get back together again.The point is that the love doesn't change and there's no problem with the affection between each other.The only think that hurts is the reality which the two had no solutions in the past.But maybe they have solutions after some time,then the second trial may work:) Thanks for your discussion and I wish you all the best^_^ Have a nice day!
@silverlocket (122)
• United States
3 Dec 07
Thank YOU for your comment :)
I too think that at times it is worth giving a second chance to someone that is if the reasons for the breakup didnt leave scars or trust issues like a betrayal or abuse.. Nonetheless, it is important to keep in mind what you say, if the affection or sentimental issues havent changed then things might work.. Now if the two hurt each other in a deep way, i guess there is no point on fixing something that is already broken ;)
1 person likes this
@honnasiri (30)
• India
3 Dec 07
i would personally have no problem with it both sides favour such a move. it may be a little awkward if she/he is the one then so be it. there actually nothing you can do about it
@getback2me (7)
•
3 Dec 07
Hi,
I feel that if it doesnt workout at the first place, probably it never works in the future. Perhaps the partners will try to work out the things a little here and there, but it can never ever be the same.
1 person likes this