Couple give up their adopted child after 7 seven years...
By aseretdd
@aseretdd (13730)
Philippines
December 13, 2007 8:47pm CST
I am in no position to judge this couple... but my heart goes to the child they adopted as a baby... they decided to hand her over to social workers because... they said... she didn't fit in with their lifestyle...
I don't understand how a child they nurtured, brought up cannot fit in the lifestyle she grew up for seven years... i think it is absurd... and there is a deeper reason why the suddenly decided to give up their adopted child...
I cannot imagine the trauma and sadness that the child is going through right now... this couple shouldn't have adopted her in the first place... i hate it when things like this happen to innocent children...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/worldnews.html?in_article_id=501281&in_page_id=1811
11 people like this
41 responses
@KissThis (3003)
• United States
14 Dec 07
Aseretdd,
When I read this discussion it brought back memories for me. I adopted two little boys. The older of the two I had in my home since he was thirteen months old. The younger one came to live with me when he was about a month shy of turning three.
One night I came home from work to find a message from the social worker asking me to call her back about an important matter. I was a little worried because we were getting ready to go to court to finalize the adoption of my older son.
I called her back first thing the next morning to see what the problem was. She asked me if I would be willing to foster "Drew" and eventually adopt him. I was confused. Drew had lived with that foster family since birth. I had just talked to the foster father the week before and he told me how great things were going. We were both scheduled to finalize the boys adoptions on the same day. The social worker told me that the other family had decided not to adopt "Drew" because he was making their lives to "stressful". The had "Drew" since he was a newborn, how could it take three years to figure out how stressful a child is.
As a parent I couldn't imagine even considering giving my boys back. Actually, at both boys adoption hearings the judge made a point to tell me there was a no return policy.
These people don't deserve to be parents to any child if they are so willing to toss their daughter away. I hope that this little girl gets a new loving family that will make sure she knows how much they want her and how lucky they are to have her for their child.
2 people like this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
14 Dec 07
Oh my... so this type of thing is actually happening around the world...social worker should put a tag on orphans which say "No Return No Exchange"... it is so so sad to think about this topic... i salute you for committing to your adoptive sons... there should be more of you out there...
What happened to Drew?
1 person likes this
@nupats (3564)
• India
27 May 08
this is awful...how can they suddenly decide that the kid does not fit in with their lifestyle..it took them seven years to decide that...this is the meanest thing to do..they shud be sent to prision for atleast seven years and not tried in the court for seven years after that release them and say they were arrested by mistake...it is the question of a small child how can anyone be so ruthless..God will punish them severely for doing this and i feel law shud also not leave them...Fine them make them bear all charges for the child till atleast 18 years...and God Bless the Child..
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
28 May 08
The sad thing here is that the Dutch government even supported their action... no matter how absurd the couple's reason is... but the world already decided that they are guilty of neglect... and for bringing distress to a child they adopted very very young... thanks for the response...
@SViswan (12051)
• India
20 Dec 07
What if their biological child doesn't fit their lifestyle?
I know of people who have biological as well as adopted children. In fact a friend of mine is going to adopt (they have a biological child and have no problems in conceiving). One of my cousins was refused a second child to adopt (she already has one adopted child) and the reason stated was that there were people who didn't even have a single child and she should be happy. The demand was greater than the supply. And to think people like the one you mentioned get to adopt a child and give it away like an 'old toy'! They should be sued!
@subha12 (18441)
• India
14 Dec 07
It is very bad to hear this news. How heartless people can be. If they were to give away the child why they adopted the child then? It is really unjustified. I hope they adopted it as child. when they have groomed it for 7 yrs, how the child can't fit?
its a shame.
@mcjeannie (703)
• Philippines
14 Dec 07
OMG!This story broke my heart.My hubby and I recently adopted.Ours is a different story.I have taken care of our baby six months in the womb before he was born, always accompany the biological Mom on his prenatal visits. We were there too when the woman gave birth, and I have our baby day 1 and to the present.We are glad, God gave us the opportunity to have him as a family and knew where he came from.
I read the story and I am saddened about it.The issue is, no facts have been divulge why the couple gave up the child!Must have been tough.But there are women who can't really mother children of their own...Several factors must have been affecting the relationship to the children because biologically it wasn't her.We love our adopted son, no matter he didn't come from me biologically.
Anyway, I am pretty sure the Korean community in Hongkong is angered by a perception of this act of this Dutch couple.Wonder in my mind, why did they have to wait this long...seven years? Don't know but it is strange!
Poor child, she doesn't have even a citizenship in that locality.I think Social welfare is stressed to find a loving family for this child.As for the child, she is the one who suffered, or traumatized for all this scenes.I hope and pray, the authority will soon find her a family and home.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 Dec 07
Hong Kong officials said that although the girl doesn't have a family or a citizenship... she will have a city that will love her... this girls story touched the heart of so many people from all over the world... and i hope that her adoptive parents will learn something from all this...
I am glad that all is well with you and your son... he is truely yours because you have been with since since day one... i hope there would me more like you...
@mcjeannie (703)
• Philippines
21 Dec 07
Thank you for the compliments.In our heart, my hubby and I loved our son so much, I wouldn't give him up for anything.
I gave up my business and my job this year in order to take care of him.
I pray that all parents who adopt will think a hundred times before adopting if they are capable parents in all aspect of parenting and to really love their adopted children as their own.
@roanne05 (1290)
• Oman
27 May 08
first of all, i think 7 years is more than enough to let the child adopt to their culture. to think that they got her when she was a baby. no adjustment is necesary because right from the start for all she can remember she is living with them and had their culture. so where is thier reason that the child cannot adjust? i really disagree with their decision. thay already have 2 biological children now? so what would people think? that they use the child while they are not having children yet? what a very bad experience for the child. i pity the child!
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
28 May 08
That is certainly a bad experience that the child would have to live with for the rest of her life... but last i heard... the Hong Kong government is doing its best to find a good home for her... and they even adopted her as a citizen since the child is not a korean citizen anymore... now was her papers as a dutch citizen ever completed... thanks for the response...
@Stiletto (4579)
•
15 Dec 07
Well my heart goes out to this child, the fact is her so-called "parents" have now had two children of their own and she is surplus to their requirements now. Disgraceful. However, another way to look at it is at least she now has a chance of being placed in a loving home with parents who truly want her and have her best interests at heart. If these people are as cold and calculating as to do something like this then she is well rid of them.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 Dec 07
Well, you are right... it is a must that we also look at the positive side of this unpleasant situation... when some reporters tracked don't former nannies... they said that the couple rarely talked or paid attention to the child... at least now she will have a chance to be in a more loving family...
@lovespecialangel (3632)
• United States
15 Dec 07
I couldn't finish reading that story. That is outragous! How can anyone do such a thing? That poor child. I can't imagine what she must me going through. I hope they can find a loving family that will take her in and show her the love that she so deserves. My heart goes out to her!
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 Dec 07
From the last news story i read... the girl is now with a foster family and social workers said that she is doing really fine and is getting along with them... Hong Kong also said that they will adopt her as a citizen...even if she doesn't have a real family... at least she will have a city to live in...
@teapotmommommerced (10359)
• United States
17 Dec 07
I could not read the whole story because it hurt me to much. That poor baby, child. how can a child not addapt to "the food or lifestype" when alls she knows is what they have taught her.
I want to take this baby and give her lots of love had patience.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 Dec 07
Well, i think that lifestyle thing is just a poor excuse to dump the child in socila welfare... they never thought of the media frenzy it would cause... there are a lot of families who volunteered to take the child so i am hoping that she will have a family that will love her to the fullest...
@enola1692 (3323)
• United States
27 May 08
this is sicking when you think of all the people out there that want children an can't have one I feel for that poor little girl
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
28 May 08
That is so true... a lot of people are not that lucky to have their own child or even afford to adopt one... this is why the action of this dutch couple was chastised by the international community... and set talks on stricter foreign adoption laws in Korea... thanks for the response...
@goinliveinfive (561)
• United States
12 Mar 08
Here's the thing, though: how do you know that the child was "innocent?" I don't think there's really any such thing and although there are tons of arguments out there that tell us that there's no genetic predisposition to behvioral issues, I can tell you plainly that there are children out there who, as they grow older, take on some if not many of the traits of their biological parents even if those parents never had any influence over them. My mother tells me that there are many things about me that are a lot like my dad and yet I barely knew the man and spent almost no time with him growing up. I wasn't in close contact with him until I was 17 but in that time I developed traits that were a LOT like his.
The fact of the matter is that this wasn't their kid it'll always stick in the back of my mind that the kid was given up for adoption for a reason. Find out a bit about the parents and you might figure out any number of reasons why these people couldn't live with those people's child.
And whether you trust it as a spiritual authority or simply respect it for its ability to make its way through time, the Bible addresses this issue in a manner that I believe fits when it says that "the sins of the father are visited upon the son, yea, even unto the seventh generation." That kind of tells me that your biological parents DO actually matter...
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
14 Mar 08
We certainly inherit the DNA of our biological parents... science already proven that... but with the case of the child and her adopted parents... the case is that when the couple adopted her... they took on the responsibility of being her parent no matter what... if they thought that they cannot accept her because of her biological parent or race... then they shouldn't have adopted her in the first place... thanks for the response...
@redbubbles (329)
• Philippines
19 Dec 07
is this as simple as that? are there no legal actions or process to this? how can they say that the child can't 'fit' in their lifestyle? she's just a child for them to judge such. are they partygoers, or rich or live like a king and a queen for them to say so? the child has been with them since she was a baby and she could have adopted their so called 'lifestyle' already because she grew up and live with them all through her seven years.
and with regards to the social worker's department, is the process as simple as that. is this an acceptable reason? i hope they must look deeper into this. they should have known and realize the effect this could inflict to the child. after all they are social workers!
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
20 Dec 07
I don't think there are laws against returning an adopted child... but i think there should be... last i read, this couple was called back to their country to explain their action and that there is now a clamor for asian countries especially south korea to tighten adoption laws...
@hotlezq (7)
• Trinidad And Tobago
7 Mar 08
I'm in a position to judge because that could of been me but thank God it wasn't.
Do you have any idea how they screwed up that child, now every insecurity that child experience would be associated with I wasn't good enough for my mom & I'm not good enough for anyone.
That's just cruel, you carry her for a test run for seven years & now that they can't accommodate her, she's returned to the lot.
Are there any laws to protect the innocent, what would it take for goverments to impliement laws or guide lines that will stop vultures like these people, isn't there a law they broke so they can be prosecuted.
My heart goes out to that child, to be abandon by your parents is one thing, but these people just crushed her little heart.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
10 Mar 08
I tried looking for articles about the child... but couldn't find any... but the last time i read something about this news... seems that the couple's decision was supported by their government... but the Hongkong government is doing its best to give the child the loving home she deserves... thanks for the response...
@raclie (1732)
• Singapore
28 May 08
wow...
thats really bad...
but i can relate to a certain extend on how they feel...
my mom is a foster mother and when we are really naughty like always fighting with the
my mom will threaten us that she will want to quit being a foster mom.
so if she is like that than i feel that she is doing something like what you said."behave yourself or you will go!!!"
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
29 May 08
You have someting a little in common with that adopted child... but i think your foster mother is just saying... but she has no intention of giving you up... being a parent can be exhausting... so there is a need for the kids to understand how their parents feel... thanks for the response...
@angelface23 (2494)
• United States
14 Dec 07
yes I agree that is terrible.. When you adopt a child you are taking on the responsibility of raising them for the rest of their life. They are a part of your family. I think it is so selfish of them to give up thier child because it doesn't fit in with their lifestyle. That's a bunch of crap. I would take that child in with us in a heartbeat if I could. I mean didn't they even take into consideration what this is going to do to that child's mental health??
@wisedragon (2325)
• Philippines
14 Dec 07
I agree that is an absurd excuse. Before adopting, parents need to think carefully about the responsibilities and consequences because once you adopt, you have complete responsibility over that child regardless of her or your "lifestyle". How stupid! Couples who are not willing to adjust their "lifestyle" should not be allowed to adopt!
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
14 Dec 07
This is the best thing that could possibly have happened to neglected, and unfortunate child!
This crass couple didn't bonded with the child in 7 years. They had No love for this child whatsoever!The child was just a nuisance. Now at least this unloved child has a chance of being adopted again by a couple who can give the child the love, and the Home, that he/she deserves!
@dreamy1 (3811)
• United States
14 Dec 07
I used to teach preschool and I had a little boy in my class who was adopted. He was a little bit of a handful at four years old and had a difficult time in class with keeping still and learning. You could just tell he would have some problems in the future The same thing happened adoptive parents gave him back to his biological parent because they couldn't handle him.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 Dec 07
It is so unfair for people to treat difficult children like a christmas gift gone bad... my uncle and his wife adopted a girl who grew up with a skin disease that is really draining their finances but they never thought of giving her back... adults are the ones who can understand and the children are the ones who need guidance...
@clamarco808 (312)
• United States
14 Dec 07
I could understand if the couple gave her up cause they weren't able to provide for her but not fitting into their lifestyle is just not right and I don't think they should be able to adopt again. I pray that this child finds someone or a couple that won't toss her back out once they get tired of playing house.
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 Dec 07
I agree with you... last i heard, the South Korean government is considering the tightening if not banning foreign adoption of children in their country... the diplomat couple who gave up their adopted child were called back to their country to explain their action...
@aidenofthetower (1814)
• United States
14 Dec 07
It is angering. I would say that there isn't a single good excuse for giving her up, and certainly not the "She doesn't fit in with our lifestyle." I can't believe those people were allowed to adopt and that they have kids! My heart goes out to her. I can't imagine how that will leave scars. First she has the fact that she is adopted in the first place a situation hard for most under normal cercumstances and then there is the fact that the family that adopted her didn't want her anymore when she was seven. That is really disgusting.
Of course the first thing I said when reading the article..."I'll take her!"
1 person likes this
@aseretdd (13730)
• Philippines
19 Dec 07
A lot of people already volunteered to take her in... and from what she has gone through... she deserves only the best that life could offer... from what i read... the city of Hong Kong already adopted her as its citizen since she doesn't have a concrete citizenship...thanks for the response...