Federer Vs. Nadal who is the best?

I generally agree with your ratings, but I think you have underrated Federer's forehand. I think it should be a 8 0r even 9. Also, if there is any rating for grace, then Federer gets 10!! For ruthlessness again he gets 10, because once he gets going he simply gets going!! Nadal though gets another 10 for determination. Cheers! Ram

records say fed is far ahead of rafa for now.

The shining neacon of another year of excellence from record-breaking Roger Federer hlit up what has been a murky tennis landscape in 2007. The superb swiss completed the season with a fourth title victory from five edition of Master Cup, crushing Spain's breakout player David Ferrer in a straight-sets master class in Shanghai. The world number one, whose reign at the top of the table passeed the 200-week mark late last month, agian claimed three of the four Grand Slams, lifted eight trophies and complied oan untouchable 68-9 record. His goal for 2008 will be to finally get over the top and calim a french Open title for the first time in his career. He also stands just two titles aways from the all time best of 14 majors achieved by Pete Sampras, a goal that could also be obtained over the next 12 months. But one thing I have to say about Nadal is that his is "STILL KING ON CLAY"

it seems roger,who is much better in volly,serve forhand,though raphal has more enthusiasimang he is the king at ROland Garros.i would give goger 9, 10,10,10,9,8and raphal 10,8,9,9,9,9 the competition betten them makes tennis more dazzling,compeitive,and prodigious.no matter who is the best,they are both the major rivals to each other.i hope they can keep confronting each other forever hoho:)

I dont think about this points....But i can say that federer is the best.... But coming to clay courts nadal is the king....no one can beat him on clay courts including federer......But federrer play at all type of courts...so,he id the best...

I guess Roger Federer is the best. He had bagged many titles already. And he is good in whatever court surfaces except clay for it's Nadal's forte.

I do not yet understand the game but I do watch and fond of watching, in TV. I don't think I would ever understand the rules, just interested in sports and watching them.

You are right Federer is better than Nadal, But my ratings for them is slightly different. Nadal vs Federer enthusiasm 10 9 Stroke 9 8 Serve 7 10 volley 8 9 Forehand 8 9 Backhand 6 9 Clearly Fedrer is better than everyone in this era. What i like about Fedrer, his aces and his cross court back hand, and his back hand slice shot, and what i s great about nadal, his approach to reach vey ball.

I would say that Federer is better. I agree with you ranking list, (The one you made) but I think that Federer has a better Forehand than 7 maybe 8 or 9. If you have seen Federer´s mathes you have probably seen his great forehands! But isn´t Nadal injured? (I´m just wondering)

For me, Federer is better than Nadal. But actually, it depends, Nadal is really good in clay courts. While Federer is good in all courts most especially grass courts. Usually Nadal wins if the game is held on a clay court but there are times when Federer can beat him in a clay court. So I think Federer is the best cause he is not only good in grass courts but also in othe courts.