Very NON - PC !

United States
December 30, 2007 9:32am CST
At the risk of being called racists and bigots for merely reporting the truth, the murder statistics by race for Baltimore for 2007 have been reported. At the link is an interactive graphic that allows displaying locations of murders by race and/or type of murder. These are brave people to publish this chart. http://essentials.baltimoresun.com/micro_sun/homicides/?range=all&district=all&zipcode=all&age=all&gender=all&race=Other&cause=all&article=all&show_results=Show+Results I attribute the large disparity by race in the number of murders committed not to any racial proclivity towards violence, but to the welfare state destruction of families. How about you? To what do you think is the cause of the vast majority of murders having been committed by one race more than any other? What should be done? BTW: Baltimore's statistics are not much different than any other major city of which I'm aware.
10 people like this
10 responses
@Destiny007 (5805)
• United States
30 Dec 07
The facts speak for themselves. It is common knowledge that the more crowded and poorer a community is, the more crime there will be. It stands to reason that violent crime will be up in these areas as well. Although poverty does not cause crimes, learned attitudes and habits do... as do the feelings of hopelessness and the inability to change living conditions and circumstances. Certain places are called "the bad part of town" for a reason, and these places are where the most crime and poverty exist. By no means is racism the reason that certain ethnic groups have a higher prison population although there are those would would like us to believe that.
6 people like this
@AD11RGUY (1265)
• United States
30 Dec 07
Obviously, this map shows reported crimes within the area, so I can't see how anyone would come to the conclusion that there is something racist about it. It is just statistical information. As to why there are so many murders, I'd venture to say it is the hopelessness that is propagated by bleak outlooks on what they as individuals and as a group can attain in their lives. There is a certain reverse racism in the black community. If one does well in American life, they have "sold out" to "whitey" and that is grounds for "disownment" from the race and/or retaliative action from those who don't believe in sell outs. Then there is the general issue of a "brudtha" shouldn't have nice things in general, from nice cars to nice looking women, God forbid a woman who is white. Grounds for retaliation all on its own. I fear that there is a certain security in believing that they cannot have a "nice" life and thus they collectively do whatever to keep the "nice" out. Add to it the general non acceptance of African-Americans in this country and they conclude "Case closed! We can never have what we want because we are unacceptable here!". It is a deep seated, unwritten, underlying mindset, instilled at birth, reinforced in the family and community and sealed by the all too popular racist attitude of many Americans, primarily white but also from a lot of hispanics as well. Not having any exposure to a life that is free of this mindset, they literally have no reason to believe it can be different and continue to propagate the mindset into the next generation and thus the cycle is reborn. It's devastating to see the strength in this belief and the damage it causes, and with leaders like Jackson and Sharpton condemning anything that can be perceived as "losing our roots", let alone the segregationist speeches by Farrakhan (i.e. "We should all get on a boat and go back to Africa" - which is just what Duke wished we would do several years before), I have to say that I see the proliferation of this attitude coming to an end on the eve of when Hades freezes over. I wish I could see a light at the end of the tunnel, but for now, I cannot.
4 people like this
• United States
30 Dec 07
Thought provoking responses, both of you. Thanks.
5 people like this
• United States
30 Dec 07
The areas that are high crime areas on that map are highly populated Black neighborhoods. I hate to break it to you but the reason there are so many murders in that area is because people who live there don't care. The ones who did left.. the rest are happy "slinging" and being locked up over and over again. To them the more you get locked up and the more you sling the higher your status is.
2 people like this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
31 Dec 07
When I pulled up the link I only got a map showing 2 stabbings.
3 people like this
• United States
31 Dec 07
Try it again. It is interactive with settings at the top. You can specify type of murder and races of the perpetrators. It sounds as if you looked at the map with race specified at 'other' and the type as stabbing. Try all races and all murders and the map gets covered with markers.
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
31 Dec 07
Your right, it was set to other. What race exactly is specified as other BTW? Alien?
2 people like this
@urbandekay (18278)
30 Dec 07
Well, there is nothing racist in quoting statistics as long as you don't as some do, use statistics like a drunk uses a lamp-post; not for illumination but support. Nor is is your conclusion racist, it is however unwarranted without further supportive elements, sure the source may show a relation between area and type and frequency of crime committed but that's all it supports, it reveals nothing about causative factors. You could argue there is a correlation between the areas and welfare but that would not be sufficient since you would also need to show that it was this correlation was the only significant one and not, for instance a correlation (If such exists) between the areas and the condition of the property. (Not that I am arguing that that is a causative factor.) all the best urban
3 people like this
• United States
30 Dec 07
Of course, what you have said is true that nothing about these statistics goes to what is the cause. I am merely asking people what do they think is the cause? Not that I'm asking anyone to prove what is the cause. That could not even begin to be done here. I do think it would be interesting to see how many are brave enough to offer an opinion. I certainly agree with you that welfare as the cause is not even indicated by these statistics. I base that on the rest of my life experience. How about you? What do you think could explain these statistics?
5 people like this
@urbandekay (18278)
30 Dec 07
Opps. 2nd sentence I mean 'hear' not here. all the best urban
2 people like this
@devilsangel (1817)
• United States
30 Dec 07
Well given how I grew up in that area I can tell you why. The people there don't care.. as harsh as that sounds its true. Downtown Baltimore is suppose to be one of the biggest tourist spots on the East Coast.. yet it is the dirtiest place I'd ever been. There's trash everywhere, rats in the subways, people peeing in the subway.. they just don't care. Whats funny is Baltimore has two parts.. Baltimore City and Baltimore County.. I live in both areas... if you live in the County.. its like living in a whole differnt place.. Clean streets, little crime..(no more than any suburban area) I just don't understand how people who live in the same place almost live two diffent lifestyles.. Whats really sad is when driving you can tell when you've left the County line and crossed into the city.. its just that obvious.
4 people like this
• United States
30 Dec 07
I really do not understand either how people can live so close together geographically yet be so different in life style and attitude toward life in general. We can try to understand it, but that's the best we'll probably ever do.
5 people like this
@adforme (2114)
31 Dec 07
Hello redyellowblackdog, This is a very difficult subject to find an answer to or analyze. In my opinion, murder is committed as an act of desperation, anger, hatred, even mental instabilty. What makes one think they can take the life of another person without being in war, or in an effort to protect themselves. I must say that race does matter and; I think blindness and a total disregard toward the plight of others, and a system that literally creates desperation, and destroys the lives, hopes, and economic prosperity of certain groups is to blame. Welfare is not necessarily where the blame should be placed. Innocent children and poor parents should be helped. There have been success stories from people on welfare who have grown to lead happy, healthy, fruitful, and productive lives. Some of these murders see no way to improve their lives and situations which leads them to hate, hurt, and become dangerous. I would suggest that there are no answers to solving this problem due to the complexity of the problem. To me, possible causes are self hatred, ignorance of economic and social issues which makes me come right back to my thought of a system that has been in place to benefit certain groups while leaving others behind and lost killing self esteem which is essential for indivdual responsibiltity; thereby, encouraging such things as dysfunctional families, crime and violence.
4 people like this
• United States
31 Dec 07
Thank you for your consideration and time in writing about this difficult problem. You have given us much to seriously consider.
3 people like this
@ParaTed2k (22940)
• Sheboygan, Wisconsin
31 Dec 07
I wish someone would do a study on violence down to the neighborhood level. My guess is that we'd find that most of the violence in the US happens in a handful of neighborhoods.
3 people like this
• United States
31 Dec 07
One of the things I have learned in researching things is that most studies you can think of have been done. Often times the results are not anything people want to hear, so the results are not in the popular press. How many people read social science professional journals? Not many. I suspect the study you suggest has been done and the results are what you think.
1 person likes this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
31 Dec 07
The reference to Baltimore City versus Baltimore County is very similar to the circumstances of a suburb in Sydney, Australia called Redfern. I have been out of my country for some time now so am not 100% sure of its current status; but basically Redfern is an inner city suburb surrounded by multi-million dollar properties that was decided to be a re-housing area for aboriginals. In the past there have always been stories in the news ranging from riots to assaults in this specific area; even to the point of statements being made that there are areas that even the police won't enter! I too find it interesting that there can be such disparate differences in areas of such a close proximity to each other. The Baltimore map you provided shows a mass concentration of black related deaths in such a concentrated area of Baltimore; whereas white, hispanic and other deaths are few and widespread in comparison. One thing I cannot comprehend is that if the problem is so statistically and geographically obvious, why is it not addressed heavily?? It is undoubtedly a combination of welfare destruction, ignorance and a misalignment of priorities from a government and police standpoint. Zero tolerance, increased police presence..... even just a stronger community focus overall would surely make a difference? Personally I find it quite shocking that there can be such a glaringly obvious trend happening!!! It would also be interesting to know how these statistics have changed over the lastr few years or so? If it is a constant growth pattern under the same statistical and geographical representations then the bureaucrats of the City of Baltimore should be disgusted with themselves.
3 people like this
@James72 (26790)
• Australia
2 Jan 08
Interesting comment. "Drawing attention to the problem is seen as racist!" Sad but true and I agree. Statistics don't lie; the mapped out representations don't lie..... NOT responding or doing something about an obvious race related issues is more racist than acknowledging the truth with a view to correcting the problem. Makes the term "political correctness" a complete oxymoron.
1 person likes this
• United States
30 Dec 07
Well there would be only one difference in my state and that would be "hispanics" I put quotes around that because they aren't really from spain, don't know why we call them hispanics. This state is being overrun by MEXICANS. There would be way more under the "hispanic" drop down menu in our major cities. Oh and not even legal citizens, these are illegal to boot. Drunk driving crimes being one of the most prevalent.
3 people like this
• United States
30 Dec 07
Yes, I know what you mean. There is a town about 50 miles from here with this problem. They have more 'hispanic' customers at the police station as a percentage of their population than any other.
5 people like this
@AD11RGUY (1265)
• United States
31 Dec 07
Regarding why they are called "hispanic", from Wikipedia: During the 1970s, the United States Government defined the term hispanic to identify Latin America individuals and their descendents, living in the U.S., regardless of race. For further reading, should you desire: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hispanic
3 people like this
• United States
30 Dec 07
The cause? Ignorance breedig ignorance. You have a young black kid born to a black man who only knows how to steal and murder to get what he wants. That kid grows up, thinking this is right and steals and murders. Years later, he has kids of his own and they learn that the only way to get what you want is to steal or murder. Their friends pick up on this. Their family picks up on this. And pretty soon, a violent cycle has began within a race or a culture. Blame upbringing. Blame poverty. Blame the parents. Blame the government. But you can't blame anyone but yourself. You hold the key to what you become. You can be raised with racists and grow up to respect all religions. You can be raised with people who would rather steal and murder for a living than put in an honest 40 hours a week to purchase that new DVD player or that new pair of shoes. The individual is to blame. Not the race. Not the government. Not the white man. White people are not forcing the black races to shoot and murder each other. White people are not holding the black man back. The black man is doing a bang up job of that on his own. The black man gripes that the white man gets the good jobs. Sure he does! He went to college. He paid attention in class and graduated. I'd give a high paying job to anyone of any race as long as they are qualified. There are billions of dollars available if you're black for scholarships, financial aid and free money for colleges, yet only a fraction of that is used. Furthermore, the white people, such as myself, who wanted to go to college are only given on average one third to a half of what the average black kid gets for public aid or assistance for educational purposes.
2 people like this
• United States
31 Dec 07
A passionate heartfelt response spoken with complete honesty of feeling. Thank you for your response.
3 people like this