Harry potter and the order of phoenix the movie...did you think it was good?

January 3, 2008 10:04pm CST
I watched the movie and honestly the book was way better sure the movie saves a week of reading but it wasen't all that great they ditched all of the magial lessons beacause i know in the book hagrid showed them how to fly those thingys and that was nowhere in the movie it would have easily been a bit more better if that was in there... so what do you think?
3 responses
az03r4
@az03r4 (913)
• Indonesia
4 Jan 08
Hmm, I don't know. I've never been watched it, however. But, my friends told me that it's not very good and it's better to read in on the book version. ;)
xxkimimaruoxx
@xxkimimaruoxx (124)
•
6 Jan 08
your friends are right...very right
az03r4
@az03r4 (913)
• Indonesia
7 Jan 08
really? so, what's the different between them? my friends also told me that they satisfied read the book, b'coz the story's complete, and within the film, it's incomplete. Some parts's being cut...
xxkimimaruoxx
@xxkimimaruoxx (124)
•
8 Jan 08
alot of parts were cut out in the movie so it wasen't as great as I though it would be
gem170104
@gem170104 (172)
•
7 Jan 08
The books are always going to be better than the movies because the books are so long and detailed. I think you almost have to view the books and the movies as two separate things as if you've never read the books like my partner your going to really enjoy the movies, if you have read the books your never going to enjoy the films as much as you could. I think that with the exception of the last book you should watch the movie before you read the books (if you haven't already) that way you'll enjoy the film to the best and then extend on the enjoyment by discovering more in the book. But after that slightly lengthly ramble....I did quite enjoy the film yes lol. I thought it was a lot better than the last one.
xxkimimaruoxx
@xxkimimaruoxx (124)
•
8 Jan 08
I think the last one was better cuz I didn't exactly like seeing cho and harry make out that was just kinda gross im not immature or anything its just they don't make a great couple
tryxiness
@tryxiness (4544)
• Philippines
4 Jan 08
The movie was ok. It showed the brilliance of Daniel Radcliffe's acting. The movie is ok. But I love the book more because the book has details that were never shown in the movie. :D
xxkimimaruoxx
@xxkimimaruoxx (124)
•
6 Jan 08
yeah he's a good acter I just wish it was more interesting I also liked the book better