is it possible to be a good parent without being a hypocrite?
By Jared
@CanuckPrince (1052)
Halifax, Nova Scotia
January 6, 2008 4:55pm CST
im sure all of you can at some point in your life remember a time you thought your parents were being hypocrites.. possibly in your teenage years? :D anyways im a parent now and im wondering if its at all possible to be a good parent without being a hypocrite
3 people like this
5 responses
@myworkid1987 (755)
• United States
7 Jan 08
my dad was hypicritical when i was younger. he smoked ciggerettes and i was the only child who ended up picking it up also and when they found my smokes they took them from me cuz of course i was under age to be smoking. I know they were just watching out for my health but he smoked so. lol when my daughter gets to that age and if she starts smoking i think i will let her since both me and my husband do but we arnt gonna buy them for her.
@zigzagbuddha (4601)
• United States
8 Jan 08
Yeah, I never went in for that do as I say and not as I do crap. I was open and honest with my kids and always encouraged them to make their own decisions about stuff, including what to eat. It turned out well as my kids are now grown and we are best friends, in fact we call ourselves the 'holy trinity'!
My daughter doesn't smoke, but my son does. He was snagging my cigs for awhile when he was about 9, and when I'd run out I'd hit him up for some of them back. He only smoked for a little while then but picked it up again when he was about 17.
1 person likes this
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
smoking is something ive already sorta been a hypocrite about.. i smoke.. i havent told my son hes downright not allowed to smoke but i constantly tell him he should never try it even once and how it can make you sick etc etc.. if he did smoke id probably take them from him too unless he was at least 16 (i dunno why you gotta be so old to smoke but you can drive at 16 so you must be mature enough to decide if you wanna smoke).. i hope none of my kids ever smoke and id even like to quit but i dont see it happening anytime soon
@zigzagbuddha (4601)
• United States
6 Jan 08
Yes, I do. In fact I think it's not only possible but very important that you do.
One of the areas that I first encountered that issue was when my kids started swearing like I do. I never tried to control their communication but I did explain to them that most adults didn't feel the same way about it that I did, and that if they were going to tell their school teachers to phuck off they might find themselves in a bit of trouble. (Mostly I did home schooling, but they both went to public schools here and there.)
1 person likes this
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
hah ya i guess swearing is probably a first for many parents to encounter.. my son is really good at not repeating words hes told he shouldnt use.. one of his first ever words was sh!t though haha he was mocking his mom when she dropped something on the floor.. it was comical!
1 person likes this
@zigzagbuddha (4601)
• United States
8 Jan 08
Hehehe, I can hear it as plain as if I had been there!
I have a funny story, but it's not about swearing though. I was at my mother's house (the one who talks through an entire movie) and I was reading to my son who was a couple of years old I guess. Anyway, my mother kept interrupting, she was sitting on the couch next to him and every other sentence I would read she would butt in for some reason or other. My son, little imp that he was, asked her very politely to be quiet because he wanted to hear the story. She ignored his request and again interrupted in the next sentence or two and he hauled off and smacked her right in the mouth!!! (And he had never been hit to have that as an example either!)
Man, it was hard not to burst out laughing, and I couldn't bring myself to 'correct' him, because it really was what I would have liked to have done myself!
1 person likes this
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
haha isnt that awesome how kids are so honest and blunt and just do what theyre thinking sometimes.. and yah i have that problem sometimes where my kids will do something they should probably be in trouble for but i cant help but laugh.. my wife tells me not to laugh at my daughter quite a bit actually haha i realize its bad encouragement but some stuff is just too amusing
1 person likes this
@wmaharper (2316)
• United States
7 Jan 08
I do think it's not only important, but also imperative. There will be times when we all make mistakes, and our kids need to know that we do. I think we should be real in front of them. My youngest three is not allowed to say the words shut up or stupid, because i feel it's not appropriate for someone his age. I have said those words here and there in front of him, and when he notices, I always apologize. I want him to know that everyone messes up, and it doesn't make you a failure, just human, but we can always try to do better next time.
1 person likes this
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
both of my kids so far are very well behaved.. we actually get comments from other parents asking whats our secret and such.. strangers in restrauants etc bicker about how our kid is quieter than theirs.. here comments like 'why cant you be more like that kid' which is an ignorant thing to say to your child by the way.. your kid is the way you raised them so why didnt you raise them like my kid is the question you should be asking! haha anyways.. i try to watch what i say around my kids too although i do swear from time to time they've so far not mocked it to the point of using it in their own sentences..
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
before anyone gets the idea in their head.. i dont swear at my kids.. i swear in regular conversation with others while my kids are in the house or backyard or whatever.. they overhear.. in comparison -- the odd one that slips out while my kids are around its extremely clean conversation.. where as at work in the factory we use more swearing than english.. you thought truckers had bad mouths? the only people they get to talk to regularly are us factory workers they drop off and pick stuff up from.. i do very well around my kids for swearing! haha
@barehugs (8973)
• Canada
8 Jan 08
The Gospel of teaching kids is,"Do as I Do, Not as I Say!" If this procedure is followed there will be nothing hypocritical in your teaching.
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
i can do the 'do as i do' but not the 'do as ive done in the past' haha :D
@betsyraeduke (2670)
• United States
7 Jan 08
Hmmm...my parents were not good parents anyway, so I can't use them as an example; but I won't get into that...Anyway, good question, it makes you think. No, I don't think it's possible to be a good parent without being somewhat of a hypocrite. I have seen that some people have responded by saying that they would not be a hypocrite because they would let their child do something just because they do it; but I am not so sure that is what I would call good parenting, so, no, I don't think it's possible. I think a good parent tries to get their child not to make some of the same mistakes that they did, to do that you would of course have to be a hypocrite to some extent. I think it is important to explain to them why you don't think they should do whatever it is though, or why you don't want or allow them to do whatever it is; even though you do it or did it. I don't think that telling them, "because I said so", like some parents do, is a good answer. No one understands or excepts that as a reason. Why should people expect their child to understand or except that as a reason?
1 person likes this
@CanuckPrince (1052)
• Halifax, Nova Scotia
8 Jan 08
its a very rare occasion i would say to my kids 'because i said so' i love explaining myself to people and most of the world doesnt listen but kids hang off every word parents say at such a young age and i want my kids to know why things happen the way they do.. and i want them to continue asking why this and why that because id rather them ask me than someone else who might not care for their outcome in life so much :) but ya i think youre right i dunno if its possible to be a good parent without being a hypocrite..