Should children be protected or educated?

January 15, 2008 5:49pm CST
Reading a few posts about the recent attack on a five year old girl by three 7 - 13 year old boys, I noticed a lot of people saying children should be shielded from the evils of the world. There are two main and opposing views on this; 1) That children should be shielded from 'bad things' and adult themes in every way possible because children should be kept innocent. 2) That children should learn of these things to better prepare them to make the right decisions in adulthood and to inform them of the dangers they could be exposed to so that they can avoid them. My opinions generally fall on the education part. Education provides knowledge, and knowledge is power... or, to use snazzy buzz words, empowerment. If a girl knows about people, men, who prey on girls then she is better prepared to avoid them. With education you can also teach right from wrong. How can a child know that something is 'bad' if it has never encountered that thing before? Opinions?
7 people like this
15 responses
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
16 Jan 08
Eventually your not going to be there with that shield. What are they going to do then? My kids are educated. They've even been trained in how to disarm or avoid & gunman. The youngest is so good at it she's likely to make him shoot himself. Hopefully they'll never be in one of these situations but at least I know they won't make themselves an easy target.
2 people like this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
18 Jan 08
Well we had a generation that was overprotected & look what happened. Once out on their own they were defenseless whiners that were easily preyed upon. At least we learned from it.
1 person likes this
18 Jan 08
Education to the extreme! lol It seems everyone is all for educating children against danger, rather than trying to shield them from it.
• Philippines
16 Jan 08
like what my father always tell me, "education is the best protection." he also said that as early as possible it is best to equip the child with a sense of survival and teach them how to differentiate right and wrong; evil and good. if we leave it until they are "adults" it will be very hard to penetrate through them because they are way past the developmental stage. education mixed with moral values, love and communication is our best weapon, i daresay. adults tend to underestimate our capacity to observe and understand. try us! hehe because if a child isn't educated at home, he will pick it up in his environment - which pose a bigger threat.
18 Jan 08
Your father seems a sensible man. Yes, the right and wrong aspect comes into it aswell.
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
20 Jan 08
I'm definitely on the side of education here. Considering my own childhood, and those of people I've met through shelters, victims services, and post-traumatic stress disorder support groups I would say: there is simply no guaranteed way to keep a child safe. No matter how much you love your child, how well you take care of them, and how much you shelter them, there is going to be some point at which they leave your sight. It might be school, daycare, babysitting, visits with relatives, visits with friends; there is eventually going to be some reason they are away from you. No matter how well you think you've chosen people to trust with your child, there is always a possibility that something will go wrong. Therefore, the only way to really help your child is to prepare them for the possibilities. Let them know what is and isn't acceptable. Let them know how to react if threatened, abused, or in a dangerous situation. Otherwise, they won't know what to do when they wind up in a bad situation, and you quite simply can't always be there to protect them.
1 person likes this
@lecanis (16647)
• Murfreesboro, Tennessee
20 Jan 08
It should be a normal part of childhood, yes. Education is partially preparation for life, whatever stage of life you're at, from my point of view. Though knowledge for its own sake has value too. However, I also believe that many people, given no other options, will self-educate in one way or another. Whether that's through messing thing up royally and then having to figure out how not to do so again or through looking around them at the world, or through gathering knowledge in more scholarly ways. Or all three, like me. I suppose that applies more to children who are neither sheltered nor educated, just left to their own devices.
1 person likes this
20 Jan 08
Would you also agree that education is simply a part of childhood; preparing someone for adulthood. An uneducated child can never mature, and will always be in that childlike state. Do people agree? Seems no one wants to stand up for sheltering children...
1 person likes this
• China
20 Jan 08
Hi,there,ShardAerliss, I do agree that the children should be educated rather than protect them from the "bad things"as u mention. In my point of view there is a saying that can well illustrate what I mean that is "we learn by burned fingers(we may not learned by burnrd fingers but can lean never to touch a hot stove again)"..If we don't experience something or if we don't suffer from something we may never grow up.. Actually, shielded from the parents is one way to protect the children from something bad,however,one thing that can't be avoided that is one day she/he will enter the society without the parents and it is certain that the parents can't keep them company during their life-time..They should learn to deal with things by themselves ..How can these gain?Of course by learning.. Molly;-)
1 person likes this
20 Jan 08
Hey there, thanks for the reply. Exactly; the parents will not always be there to offer protection. How can people leave their children exposed in such a way?
• United States
16 Jan 08
I believe that children should be educated. It can be what saves them from doing something bad. I belive that parents should be straight forward with there kids be open and honest. I my self do not have kids but I educate my younger cousin so he doesn't make the same mistakes I have made.
2 people like this
16 Jan 08
It seems that people who have made mistakes in their lives are more inclined to believe in education over protection. I have no kids (and as far as I'm concerned never will) but my nephew will be well educated. not just by myself and my partner, but by his mother and his grandmother. I expect he will get much the same education in these things as I did.
• India
24 Jan 08
It is true that education is one way where we can prevent such happenings and cruelties.on the other side exposure should be given to children by parents about good and bad to make them prepare to face such consequences as in this world there are both good and bad ,we have to prepare our children for facing the worst and at the same hope for such cruelties stop and everything around us are turning good...Hope for the Best and Prepare for the Worst!
1 person likes this
29 Jan 08
Brilliant final thought there. Thanks for the reply!
• United States
20 Jan 08
Children need to be educated. Really, if kids don't know what to look for, and what kind of people they may encounter, how are they ever going to be streetwise and understand what to do in a situation that may be tough? They may end up actually getting into trouble instead of avoiding it. Now, I'm all for shielding children from telling them everything gory when they are especially young and only letting them know what they need to know at certain ages, but not telling them anything is really just setting them up for trouble later on.
20 Jan 08
Thanks for the response. Another vote for education there.
@Buchi_bulla (8298)
• India
22 Jan 08
In my opinion children should be taught about everything so that they will know what is evil and can prepare themselves in case of coming face with them.
22 Jan 08
Another one for the education vote. Thanks for the response!
• United States
16 Jan 08
I am a firm believer in educating children. How can they know what is happening if they are never told of certain things. Knowledge is the best lever for keeping kids safe.
16 Jan 08
This is what I think. Yet so many people seem to think they should be 'protected' until adulthood. But if they are 'proected' then how do they know what the adult world involves? How do they even know how to be a 'good adult'? And thanks for the response.
@Arkadus (895)
• Canada
22 Jan 08
Number two's the best idea. If they know about that kinds of stuff they Yeah I'm more for education. If they know what's going on there's less of a chance of them falling into one of those situations in the first place. Of course some could argue that if they have that knowledge there's the risk they might run off and use it... but your ending statement is also true, and really who would you rather have them learn these things from the parents or a practicing pedophile?
29 Jan 08
Great final remark there! Thanks for the response.
@atchmon (140)
• Philippines
16 Jan 08
children should both be educated and protected. In educating them, it must be in the proper way, or else they might interchange right from wrong..
20 Jan 08
Show them right from wrong, but make sure you instill in them that such and such IS wrong? Again another vote for 'the best of both worlds.'
16 Jan 08
i think children should be educated to survive in the present generation
18 Jan 08
Only in the present generation?
• United States
16 Jan 08
THis is my very first post, so please bear with me. I struggle with this same issue all the time. I want to protect my kids but I also want them know certain things. BUT, I wouldn't put my child in the cage with a lion to teach them that lions are dangerous. Making them aware and exposing them to things are different things.
20 Jan 08
Welcome to MyLot! Is it a fine line between showing what danger is and exposing a child to danger? Perhaps in many circumstances, and is it always something to bear in mind.
@madlees (1377)
• India
30 Jan 08
Education is necessary to children, be it , they are girls or boys. They have to have knowledge. Somethings like the way to move with other people, to avoid strangers etc should be taught to them in these days. They have to learn things like strangers or for that matter others, trying to touch them etc They should know that they have to avoid those 'bad people '... But please do not ever tell them all the gory stories which happen around and scar their soft, gentle minds. They'll get scarred forever. So I am for shielding them, as also for education in necessary subjects.
30 Jan 08
Hey, thanks for the reply. Many people are promoting both education and shielding be used in conjuction. Seems a strong logical answer.
@twoey68 (13627)
• United States
8 May 08
To be honest, in today's world, I believe that the more informed kids are the better they are able to protect themselves when adults aren't with them. I've sat down and taught my Nephew about not going into strangers homes, about perverts and have even taken him to a website that shows all the registered child molesters in our town. Why? Because I'd rather that he knows about them then think that everyone is good and decent and end up running into a child molester. In a perfect world children get to stay innocent and untouched by the terrible things in the world but if you pick up a newspaper or turn on the news you will see quickly that this is no where near a perfect world. **AT PEACE WITHIN** ~~STAND STRONG IN YOUR BELIEFS~~