Do you believe about virgin Mary?
By bunmi2501
@bunmi2501 (465)
Nigeria
2 responses
@kundalini444 (194)
• Italy
21 Jan 08
The actual dogma is much more than this: Mary gave birth to a baby through an intact hymen. She is a virgin before, during and after the birth!
This is what catholics believe. The only way I can regard such a statement is as a "myth" not a "truth".
In my opinion, Christ was just an illegitimate children of Mary and a roman soldier named Panthera, but Joseph accepted the baby as his own and everybody invented the myth about a "virgin birth".
There are several historical studies upon this.
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
22 Jan 08
I do believe in the virgin birth of Christ. She was overshadowed with the holy Spirit. With God all things are possible. There is only one Son of God so there no need for a second virgin birth.
@kundalini444 (194)
• Italy
23 Jan 08
Do you believe that Mary was phisically intact (i.e. a virgin) AFTER giving the birth to a baby? Without any evidence or explaination of that? Just because the catholic church says so? (And it never said that before 20th century, so it is a relatively recent dogma)
1 person likes this
@deebomb (15304)
• United States
23 Jan 08
I believe she was a virgin before the birth of Christ but No i don't believe that she was intact after His birth. I also believe that she went on to have normal relations with her husband. We don't know or it wasn't recorded if she had other children after Jesus was born.
