umbrella versions
By cutie12024
@cutie12024 (17)
Philippines
January 29, 2008 8:38am CST
guys, have u heard about the other versions of rihanna's "umbrella"?...one is the acoustic version of marie digby, the other one is mandy moore's version...i heard there's also jojo's version of that song...which do you think is the best??? (rihanna excluded)
2 people like this
5 responses
@kel1483 (986)
• United States
19 May 08
There is a version by Scott Simmons. I really love that version. I also have the Mandy Moore version and the Rihanna one. The Scott Simmons one is kind of acousticy and sounds real emotional. I like the dancey-ness of the Rihanna version.
@secretbear (19448)
• Philippines
21 Mar 08
hi cutie!
i have only heard of Rihanna's, mandy moore's and.. i forgot the name but its a guy who sang it. i haven't heard of marie digby's version. i don't even know who she is. ^__^;;
but as far as the versions i have heard, i say, nothing beats the original. i love Rihanna's original version of it. its catchy and danceable. i actually like the part "ella, ella eh eh.." mandy's version is too slow. i don't think the lyrics fit for a love song or a slow song for that matter. and i don't like the guy's version. i think the changes in the lyrics are just ridiculous!
@tikkuy (34)
• Australia
2 Feb 08
I've heard both the Mandy Moore version and the Marie Digby version, as well as Rihanna's original. I don't think I could really choose between them; Rihanna's is certainly more upbeat and you can dance to it, while Mandy's is more powerfully sung. Then again, Marie's is very soft and relaxing. So I guess it just depends what mood I'm in or want to get into.
@savelife (516)
• Philippines
28 Mar 08
u know what i really like dis song and i hav dis attitude dats look for other versions.. and i found alot of them! there's like reggae, rock, slow, techno versons.. i didn't expect umbrella wud hit incredbly....i most definitly luv marie digby's versoin..she soo cool..cute too.. just only wid u tube she became u famous.. great job!