what do you think of regifting?

@winterose (39887)
Canada
February 2, 2008 6:20pm CST
I just wrote a very personal article on another site and I will share it here. you can on this site say if you think regifting is okay or not, here is my article Some of you may not agree with this article, and that is fine, just don’t tell me, I am upset enough as it is. So let me start from the beginning. Many of you know that gather gift certificates are useless to internationals; Only Americans can redeem them. But I am from Canada, and like other internationals here on gather we work, we participate, we write our articles, and we do it because we have made some very good friends here on this site and we love them. I have been a member of gather for two years. I had accumulated close to 30,000 useless points. Many of you know that I live well below the poverty line and I am on disability currently. It goes without saying that I could really use those points but I can’t. I have many friends that have helped me out financially as the years went by, some are from gather, some are from Storytime Tapestry my e-zine. Without them I would be a street person and I am not exaggerating one bit. Until recently I have been concentrating upon “big bad gather admin” and the injustice of not having a system set up where I could use my gift certificates like Americans can. After all I earned them! One certain friend that I have that I met from yet another site has helped me out a lot over the years. That I thank her for from the bottom of my heart; but it always bothered me that I could never do anything for her other than be there for her through emails. Like most emails friends she lives far away. She does live in the states though. Then one night a light bulb went off in my head. I could use my gather points for some good. Even though I couldn’t use them myself I could give them to people that I love that live in the states. I automatically thought of this friend, I wanted to give her something back. No not in the sense of paying her back, but just giving her something. It made my heart feel good that I could do this for her. It made me feel good that I could give to another human being again because this has always been my nature. Knowing that she gives everything away I told her how important this way to me to GIVE HER SOMETHING., and I asked her to promise that she would not give the gift certificates to anyone else, this had to be for her. She agreed. She thanked me, she was happy and I was happier. It made me feel good that I could give her something. The night that I offered them she was feeling really down and I had made her feel better by doing this for her; so she said. So we were both happy. Today she tells me she wants to give it away to someone else. She just does not get it. First of all she is breaking her promise to me that she would use it for herself, And second she is regifting, It is like saying to me your give is not important enough for me to keep it I will give it away. I told her she is taking all the joy out of it for me. It was very important to me that I gave that gift to her. I could have given those gift cards to any number of people but I wanted her to have them. She told me she was not taking the joy out of it, how does she know, is she me? She is also returning them to me now. She has no capacity to understand she is ripping my heart apart by doing that. But now I understand why nobody gives her anything, because they already know she will just take their gift and give it to somebody else. Regifting hurts to the person who put her heart and soul into the gift. Many of my friends have also felt the same way as me when their gift so lovingly given was tossed aside or given to somebody else. We may not always get gift we like or can use, but please don’t be so callous as to just give it to somebody else. Earnestly try to find a use for it especially when it is a gift certificate and you can buy whatever you want with it. Yes, you are doing something nice for the person you are giving to, but you are hurting the person who loved you so much to give it to you in the first place. Especially when they asked you promise you would not give it away.
3 people like this
10 responses
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
3 Feb 08
I can understand how you feel, not knowing anything about Gather I assume it is something where you can choose what you want, so really she could have done that but i must be honest even though I know how it hurts when you give a present to someone then they give it away maybe for various reasons I must be honest to say I have done it in the past as I have been given a couple of things that have just not been me, for example i don't like the colour green and won't have it in my house except for my plants, now a friend a few years ago gave me something green and she was well aware of my dislike for the colour a couple of years later I gave it to someone whom I knew would love it and at the time I was short of money so it made some-one happy and save me buying something when I couldn't really afford it....but I see where your coming from with your friend....
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
3 Feb 08
it was a gift card, she could have bought anything she wanted to her liking. and she knew it was important to me that I give her this, and I wanted her and only her to use it. I would not have given her something green if I knew she hated the colour green that would be stupid as far as I am concerned. I wanted her to have something from me, it was so very important if she gave it away she has nothing from me.
1 person likes this
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
3 Feb 08
I can understand your hurt...very much.
1 person likes this
@tyc415 (5706)
• United States
3 Feb 08
I can see why this person broke your heart and probably your trust in them too. If she had not wanted them in the first place then she should have told you or she might could have said "oh thank you so much but do you mind if I give them to someone else who could really use them at this time more than I need them". My heart goes out to you. It is like a slap in the face isn't it? It is great that you have such good friends that have helped you out in your hard times. Please don't let this upset you more than it already has.
2 people like this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
3 Feb 08
thank you hon I agree
@chertsy (3798)
• United States
3 Feb 08
First I like to say that has to be the sweetest thing that you did for your friend. I think if I was in your shoes I would feel really hurt that after I took the time to give this gift and then have my friend turn around and say she was going to give it to someone else. Now if my friend was straight forward and said she was going to use it on her kids, I wouldn't be hurt as much, because that's how my mom is, and that's how I am. This past Christmas I received a total of $100.00 from my inlaws, I really didn't need anything but my husband told me to at least get something so I can say I got something. I got a purse on sale so all I paid was about 10 bucks. I used the rest on my family. A couple of years before that I received about the same amount, I got what I honestly needed and that was a vaccum and used the rest on my family. I like to receive gift certificates at stores that has everything from clothes to food. Even if I get one that doesn't have everything, I will still use it on my kids. You have every right to be upset, if you promise something to someone. You should uphold your promise, also if you honestly know your not going to be able to keep that promise, then you shouldn't agree to that person in the first place. Especially after hearing that this person took great deal into finding the perfect gift for your in the first place.
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
3 Feb 08
she is giving it to the mother of one of the handymen she has, i just can't understand that.
1 person likes this
@Fishmomma (11377)
• United States
3 Feb 08
I can understand why your upset about her wanting to re-gift. She didn't understand that you wanted her to have a gift from you and when she used it that she would think of you when using the gift card. I received a gift card from somebody from a site that I post on and really love the mug. I think of this person every time I have a mug of water. I'm sorry that this happened to you and hope life gets better for you now. Best wishes
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
3 Feb 08
I told her it was not just a giftcard to me it was my heart and she gave it away.
@whyaskq (7523)
• Singapore
10 Feb 08
Yes, regifting hurts if I come to know of it. Hence, I am particular about gifts I give to my friends. I am not sure it is more hurting if the gift was sold off through ebay within months after giving it away.
1 person likes this
@raydene (9871)
• United States
3 Feb 08
Hi Winterose Hope to not offend you but I do not see gift giving that way.. First if it's a gift..once it is given it no longer belongs to you and you can take that to court and will not get your giftback...I know because a friend here just went throught this with a ring given her by an ex...She still has the ring! She can now crush,burn or give away the ring and the giver can not say a word! Second if you are making a deal with someone and if they do what you you will reward them it is no longer a gift..it's payment for a deal made. Third I have given away many gifts that others gave me..I loved the gifts but someone else had a use or need for them more then I did...If you bake a beautiful pie for me because you care alot about me I will accept thet pie with my mouth watering but if on the way home I see someone starving..well you know I won't get a bite.. Also if someone give me something and I won't use it I can not stand waste so I would give it to someone.. I think your heart was in the right place wanted to give the cards to her but I find it a bit controlling to tell her what to do with them.Please don't be offended..If you truly want to give her something that she will enjoy let her give them away because that may be as enjoyable as recieving them..I for one love to give and I find alot of different ways of doing so..I would give you my last mouthful if I thought you needed it no matter who provided it for me..I would hate to think it would hurt my friends..Most of my friends know me and we are all like this so we don't hurt each other gifts.. Honey, God has given us so much and he wants us to regift what he has given so freely..that is why we call them gifts from God oxxoxoxoxo
1 person likes this
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
4 Feb 08
it may of been resolved if she acknowledged my feelings instead she refused, she couldn't care less, so I guess you and I will have to agree to disagree on this issue,
@crazed_moma (1054)
• United States
3 Feb 08
Well I'm going to borrow an Oprah saying here "if I give you five dollars it's your business what you do with it, you can pee on it for all I care" lol I hope that's accurate because that's how I remember her saying it. It was a very sweet thing of you to do. And I understand why your hurt. I think I would be too. I do regift but only if i know the person who gave me the gift will never know. As for her giving it back to you, you can't use it! Try not to take it personally. It's obviously just the way she is.
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
3 Feb 08
oprah saying does not apply in this situation, this was me giving her something that was very important for me to do, she knew it we talked about it, she promised she would keep it for herself, and then broke her promise. when something is so important to you friend you don't trample over their feelings like that. Oprah would be the first person so say how friendships are important and you care about your friends feelings when something is very important to them as this particular situation was to me. If i gave her a million things it would not have made any differece but I wanted to give her somethign so badly and this is what she does with it. I would never have done that to her or anyone else if I knew how important it was to them
@wrongway (277)
• United States
3 Feb 08
First of all let me say I am so sorry she hurt your feelings and broke her promise to you. A promise should not be made in the first place if you do not intend to keep it. That was very wrong. A gift should be accepted in the manner it was given. With a feeling of joy, pride and love, and an understanding of what it means to the giver to be giving it. That is not to say it should not be regifted, only that it should be understood what it meant to the person who gave it to you. I have always believed that it is better to give than to receive and I have often regifted items that I could not use as it made me feel wonderful to be able to put a smile on someone's face. However I have never regifted something I have promised to keep or use in a certain way. I understand your feelings as I have lived most of my life scraping for money and feeling like I had nothing to give but always had people giving me. I wanted to be able to do what so many other people do without having to worry about the cost or always being the one who declined going somewhere because I didn't have a nice gift to give due to lack of funds. It can be very emotional for us when it happens. Even though she was wrong since she promised not to regift, try to understand why she may have wanted to do it. Perhaps she too can not afford to give that often and it gave her the opportunity to give a gift. I know I tried not to let a lot of people know what condition my financial life was in because I was embarrassed and felt I was inferior and a failure. She may have had a very good reason for doing it, even though it meant she was breaking a promise. If she really is a good friend, don't let a mistake like this take that away. What she did may hurt but losing a good friend would hurt more (and longer). I truly understand how you feel and would probably feel the same way but I hope in time you can forgive her.
1 person likes this
@gemini_rose (16264)
3 Feb 08
You did a nice thing for your friend, you sat and thought about her and did a nice thing just for her, and I am sorry that she has done this awful thing, it seems very thoughtless of her to me and she hasnt considered your feelings at all and I can understand why you are hurt, I would be too. I have experienced something similar myself, although it actually amused me rather than hurt me which is perhaps a good thing! I bought my mum some piggin ornaments over a period of time, because she went through a stage of collecting them. I would hunt down the funniest ornaments I could find for her, and I bought my dad some of his favourite aftershaves in miniatures for christmas. Recently they told me they had opened an ebay shop and so I went on to have a look at what they were selling and can you imagine my surprise when the things that they were selling were the very gifts I had bought them!! The best part was my dad actually had the cheek to complain when they didnt sell for all that much on auction ha ha! But like I say I didnt feel too hurt, oh well maybe a little!
@MarkFly (15)
• China
3 Feb 08
Hi,could you tell me what's the 'regifting' means?
@winterose (39887)
• Canada
4 Feb 08
it means somebody gives you a gift and then you turn around and give it to somebody else, you don't like it enough to keep it for yourself