Can Everyone be a Winner all the time???
By skinnychick
@skinnychick (6905)
United States
February 9, 2008 6:38pm CST
This discussion stems from one of my other discussions where a good point was brought up in the land of political correctness. This one just peeves me because it's so ridiculous.
Noone loses anymore- everyone is a winner. This holds true really in young kids when they set out to do something especially around school. Kids try to do a given activity thinking it's a contest but in the end every kid gets a prize.
In my opinion, this can really hurt a kid because as we all know not everyone wins in life. If the kid never loses how can they become better at anything, they will just think they are good enough and never aim for higher goals.
In this respect (and most others frankly) we are really being hurt mainly our kids are being hurt in this "politically correct" world.
Do you think there should be definite winners and losers when it comes to our kids?
Maybe you think the opposite and agree that every kid should win?
All opinions welcome..
Thanks for reading.
2 people like this
8 responses
@cynicalandoutspoken (4725)
• United States
10 Feb 08
I will kick my 5 year olds butt in Go Fish and make him cry. I will get a better score on DDR when I play with my 11 year old and piss her off. I will win a race faster than my 6 year old on a PS2 game. I am not one of those people who let there children win. When I beat them and they get upset I tell them that not everyone wins all the time and when you lose at something you should just try harder the next time and the more times you do something the better you are going to be at it.
With children who don't win first place to get prizes makes me mad. I entered my avatar in a Sunburst Baby Pageant. She came in 1st place but all 11 other babies in her age group all got trophies too. Even though she got a bigger trophy and paid admission to the state pageant I thought it was unfair.
If we don't challenge our children to better themselves then we are just asking for them to accept the mentality of "even if I just skate by it will be just good enough."
Not my kids, no way!
Great discussion +
1 person likes this
@skinnychick (6905)
• United States
10 Feb 08
Thanks for stopping by. I say make them compete too and win on their own. They will be better adults for it and that is what we all want from our little ones- strong, smart, caring, and loving adults who work for what they will have! :)
@CoupleinLove (31)
• United States
11 Feb 08
the more stuff i run into that you have writen the more i cant help but think you have sumthin wrong up in your head girl. what kind of mother beets there kids at a game and makes em cry? i mean come on. who else think synialnoutspoken needs to have her head exmined?
@SViswan (12051)
• India
11 Feb 08
I'm with Cyn on this one. I play fair...I don't beat them at a game on purpose. And it actually works because my son tries harder next time and beats me to it. And he's also learnt to take defeat gracefully.
I like my child to be a winner and maybe sometimes you have to defeat them so that they work harder.
In fact, I've even asked his teachers at school to give him second place or no prize at all when I feel that he's getting it easy. Well, they haven't done it....but he kind of took it for granted that all prizes were his! And it did seem like that because he won in everything he participated in (which was all the competitions that came his way). What I didn't like was that he won without too much effort (because other parents didn't challenge their kids)...he didn't have much competition (except two kids) and I thought that wasn't how it should be.
@mlhuff12 (797)
• United States
10 Feb 08
Yes, but not necessarily. I have played sports my whole life. And one team wins and one loses. Hovever, I believe that in whatever you are doing and you gave everything that you got, knowing that would give them some sort of accomplishment and good feeling, then yes you are a winner. But I am sure there are a lot of people out there that do the very least to get by. And those are the losers.
1 person likes this
@skinnychick (6905)
• United States
11 Feb 08
Very nicely put! Thanks for stopping by and adding that insightful comment to this discussion!
@SViswan (12051)
• India
11 Feb 08
Good discussion. Well, my son has competitions where only a few kids win...but the thing that worries me is that HE wins everytime. I think he needs to lose sometimes too. He expects to win all the time...though he does say that participation is the main thing and not the prize. But I could see that he was a little upset (which is natural) when he didn't win at some non-school event. Fortunately, with two experiences he realized that he can't win all the time and he seems to have taken it in his stride.
Earlier he would get upset even if he was unsuccessful at things he was doing (nothing to do with competition)...instead of trying again he would stomp off and I had to teach him that sometimes people fail in the first attempt and maybe he needs to work a little harder.
I feel there should be a balance of both. If it is the effort that counts, then all kids can be the winner....but overall I feel that the competition is good and children will strive to better themselves. But the point here is that the competition should be healthy and about doing the best one can and not about beating another.
@skinnychick (6905)
• United States
11 Feb 08
Thanks for the compliment and great answer.
It sounds like your son is doing well and coming around. Starting to understand concepts in winning and losing better...awww growing up. :( But the good part is that he is growing up healthy in the mind..very nice.
Thanks for your response
@jithinsb (518)
• India
10 Feb 08
well..i don't think that every kid can be a winner every time..Every kid has got his own pace and speed of grasping and doing things,but it is often seen that parents push them and put them in pressure just to come first in the heavily competitive world..It can't be blamed on the parents alone because every parent would like to see his/her child to be a winner,not a loser.It will do only good to the child also.So i don't exactly know how we can solve the entire problem and I think every parent should thin for them self and find out the solution..anyway I have seen a hindi film called "Taare zameen par" ..it shows this problem and is really heart touching in which a father imposes pressure on his second son who is too poor in studying to be like his elder son who is very brilliant..in the process the child becomes too pressurized and slips out of the reach of parents..and one of the child's teacher finds the real talent in the child and bring it out by encouraging him and being with him..it is a suprb film..every parents should see it...
1 person likes this
@twils2 (1812)
• United States
11 Feb 08
Hello Skinnychick,
For every winner there is a loser. Losing makes us try to be better, if we win all of the time, whats the point in even playing. When kids start out in sports, they are out to show that they are better then everyone else. If they all win a prize, that kind of takes something away from the ones that won. Just my two cents anyways.
Take care, Terry
@skinnychick (6905)
• United States
11 Feb 08
It does absolutely take away from the winner and their hard word. It also I think takes away from the loser because they don't learn good sportsmanship. Nice thoughts- thanks for coming by.
Have a nice one!
@sabbathandruth (567)
• Canada
10 Feb 08
yes i think there should be winners and loosers
but i dont think that we should let children run it in the loosers face or anything or make them feel like they suck!
1 person likes this
@skinnychick (6905)
• United States
10 Feb 08
I don't agree with taunting after they win either- that's just mean.
Thanks for your response
@lkbooi (16070)
• Malaysia
10 Feb 08
Totally agree, not everyone wins in life. Yeah, a kid who never loses will always think that he is superior and couldn’t be bitten. He will be contented with what he has achieved and never try hard for any improvement. As he has grown up when he encounters any failure definitely he will never be able to take it. He will become deeply depressed and loses confidence in life. So I regard failure at early stage as an immunization for any difficulties encounter in life in the future.
@skinnychick (6905)
• United States
10 Feb 08
"So I regard failure at early stage as an immunization for any difficulties encounter in life in the future."
I love this line and this was very well said unles of course that someone is over the top politically correct.
Thanks for the insightful comment