Do children need to learn to read and write anymore?
By ESKARENA1
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
February 22, 2008 4:33am CST
With the advent of electronic communication and audio books et al, I am coming around to the idea that we no longer need the basic literacy skills of reading and writing. Anyone say why they are still important? can we finally rid ourself from the tyranny of literacy?
11 responses
@whiteheather39 (24403)
• United States
22 Feb 08
I strongly disagree with you for a multitude of reasons.
If we do not at least have the basic skills and there is a power or Internet outage we will have a society of morons walking around.
What a disadvantage to daily living (survival) if we could not read the written word.
Not to be able to curl up in bed with a good book without being plugged into an electrical connection..PLEASE!
Etc., etc., etc., etc.!
IMO I think this discussion happens to be the most idiotic one I have yet read on myLot! Thank goodness I was taught to read and write!
1 person likes this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
•
22 Feb 08
well thank you for your critics assessment, the most idiotic one on mylot, hey? mmmmmm now that is a honour indeed
blessed be
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
23 Feb 08
You don't need to be "plugged in" to something to read a book. I've read several books on my iPod.
Despite your number of posts, I guess you haven't been on MyLot all that long. There are more "idiotic" discussions than this one for sure. Although, I think you used the wrong word and probably meant something else.
@whiteheather39 (24403)
• United States
23 Feb 08
Pigglies....I have been a member of myLot for 15 months, my command of the English language is very good and I meant idiotic, of ourse I could have used stupid, dumb,
unintelligent, etc., etc.
@clowdine (1402)
• Philippines
22 Feb 08
Definitely reading and writing are still needed. They still can't do away with following instructions that are written and correspondence is still part their way of life to communicate. And for me, literacy is not tyrannical (maybe through the course of earning it) but once you did what it takes to get it, it becomes a liberator.
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
•
22 Feb 08
for sure, however the tyranny of the learning for many is enough. All it needs is inexpert teaching to make it a tyranny for life. Can we be rid of the tyranny of literacy?....we can but only by getting rid of the many too many bad teachers
@clowdine (1402)
• Philippines
24 Feb 08
I got your explanation and I must say it's a witty one. And based on my personal experience there are "educators" who really waste their students' time. That includes my teacher in the second grade. So, it's just right to say literacy per se is not tyrannical in nature but only when the one that is tasked to provide it at any given time is a bad teacher and just keeps on asking the mentees to do taxing activities that are beside the lesson.
1 person likes this
@cr0ssf41r13 (866)
• Philippines
23 Feb 08
You have a point here, but you see, ESKARENA1, reading and writing are necessities in life. Reading is a necessity even in the advent of electronic communication. Writing also needs to be learned most especially because some jobs require writing skills.
1 person likes this
@season0907 (671)
• India
22 Feb 08
Hi ESKARENA1,
I think you have forgotten completely that it is basic literacy skill that is responsible for todays growth and invention of electronic media.Everything is to be taught - even to know through electronic media.Basic literacy is like a foundation to multistoried building and with out the foundation the building will collapse.Like wise for a humans achievement in whatever profession one has to start from basic literacy.
Good Luck.
1 person likes this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
•
22 Feb 08
but...if the information is digitally recorded is there really still a need to read it?
@mrtimharry (1180)
•
22 Feb 08
I still beleive that the majority of people need good literacy skills to get a decent job.
Aside from that I wouldn't want anyone to miss out on the pleasure of reading a good book because they couldn't read.
1 person likes this
@Pigglies (9329)
• United States
23 Feb 08
I'd have to say that reading is definitely still important, and I can tell you why as someone who has limited reading abilities. Writing might not be as necessary (especially cursive), due to typing, but reading definitely is.
I have great difficulty with reading. Especially with glossy textbooks. Most textbooks are not yet on audio. Some can't be on audio. Try to find a way to put organic chemistry in audio format. You can't. Handouts aren't on audio unless someone does it for you. A lot of books are never made into audiobooks. Even if they all were, there are always signs and other things you need to actually read.
I read almost all of my "fun" books on audio now. If it's not on audio, I probably won't read it. It takes me an hour just to read 6 to 10 pages. I'm sorry, but there aren't many books I find interesting enough to perservere through all of that. I'm currently reading Larry Adler's autobiography because it isn't available on audio. I've been reading it for I think over a month now, and I'm only on page 50. I have another book started that I've been reading for well over a year, maybe over 2 years. It is 400 pages and I'm finally past page 300. Reading just isn't fun for me unless it's on audio. I can listen to 6 hours a day of audiobooks easily. It is just so much faster to read on audio that when I can do it, I greatly prefer it to physical reading. But still, I have tried my best to perfect my actual reading skills so that when I do need to read something (like a restaurant menu) I can, even though it is a slow process.
@arkaf61 (10881)
• Canada
23 Feb 08
Of course it's still important :)
I don't want to have some machine reading to me, I want to read myself. I don't want to have some software adding for me, I want to know how to do it myself.
THe day that the machines and the software fail, I will still be able to do what needs to be done :)
The pleasure of being able to read and write can't be substituted by any gadget even if I use the same gadget to help me at times.
@grecychunny26 (9483)
• Philippines
27 Feb 08
I think they still need to write it, here in the Phils people even the youngs are required to write on their own hands. In school there are forms that the children are required to write using their hands and the teachere will just explain the procedures to them. And by writing also we can form our own signature which makes every person unique. What will happen to us if there is no energy , the computer will not work how can we resume of what we are doing...I think we have to be literate in writing and reading still.
@WhiteDoveLost (139)
• United States
22 Feb 08
... What is wrong with you. Would you be making this post if you were not able to read/write?
I'm just so bothered by this. If we have microwavable foods should we not learn to cook anymore? We have fake plants should we not plant anymore?
You are so wrong in that thought. I hope this is a joke.