A friend in need…!
By kamran12
@kamran12 (5526)
Pakistan
February 27, 2008 11:52am CST
Imagine that you have a friend who has deeply fallen in love with some girl/boy. The problem is, you somehow know for a fact that the girl/boy in question is not honest with your friend and may even harm him/her. You also understand that it’s not your position to tell your friend what he/she ought to be doing, plus you fear losing his/her friendship as he/she is deeply in love and won’t listen to any cautionary advice. But, you also feel and care for your friend very much and don’t want anyone harm him/her in any way!
What best you will suggest doing in this situation such that friendship is not broken and your friend is also adequately warned!?
6 people like this
10 responses
@novataylor (6570)
• United States
27 Feb 08
This is so difficult, Kamran, quite a dicey one, difficult to strike the right balance. But I think that I might tell my friend of my concerns, and use the terms 'I feel' and 'I believe' and not things like 'he always' or 'he never', do you know what I mean? Like, don't say, "he always does this, or he never does that. That just gets a persons defenses up immediately, and closes their mind to further words from you. I think you need to assure them that you care about them, and will be there for them, no matter what they decide. And you'll support them even if they choose to be with that person, although it goes against everything for you to do that. What they need the most here, I think, is to know that you are their true friend and will support their choices, wrong or right, and be there to catch them when they inevitably fall, although you shouldn't tell them that particular thing, you know? That way, you can voice your concerns and they can feel like you're not damning them or dropping them, and you will probably be able to maintain and even perhaps strengthen your friendship. Good luck,Kamran. I know this is important to you and I so hope that it all works out for you and your friend.
2 people like this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
27 Feb 08
What you said is quite reasonable and wise, nova, especially about using tactful words. I may not standby someone when they are ruining themselves especially when the person is someone I deeply care about but I want you to know that I really appreciate your input here, which will make me able to decide a best course of action, thank you for the words of wisdom!:-)
1 person likes this
@novataylor (6570)
• United States
27 Feb 08
Good luck, Kamran, it's a fine line you walk here with your friend. I will hope the best for both of you.
1 person likes this
@Wario_1 (965)
• Sweden
27 Feb 08
Good discussion, damn this is trouble in a freakin bolted up nutshell made of bulletproff titanium. Just letting it go could result in the friend getting hurt by the dishonest piece of a**. Rushing into the situation will probably not do any good, it maj even backfire on you resulting as the loss of your friend and the previous thing.
I think the best thing is to sit down and talk about this, to say that you are saying this because you care for the person and you dont want to se them end up getting hurt by the dishonest person. Friends take care of eachother, and stop eachother from getting hurt, even if it means being inconvenient.
2 people like this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
27 Feb 08
Hello Wario_1,
You rounded the situation up quite well. Sitting down and talking is nice but what if that person isn't ready to even "start" listening anything against that person. Love can be such a blinding experience, eh?
But then, one can't let it go either. I know the head will be injured one way or the other. I do understand what you are saying, Wario_1, and it's what it is. Thank you for your wise words of advice!:-)
2 people like this
@Wario_1 (965)
• Sweden
28 Feb 08
Your welcome, its nice to be of help for people whenever possible. You are right, love can be very blinding. Still i believe that you can get her attention, if you play your cards the right way. If she cant listen, then its hard to give any advice since i dont think any shorter periods of time would help. If waiting any longer time their is the risk of her getting betrayed.
I think i stick to what i said previously, that you sit down and talk it out in a soft and sensitive manner. If she isnt listening at all, then doing anything with force will probably really backfire, i guess you cant do mutch after that but hope she understands that you did what you could to stop her from getting herself hurt.
1 person likes this
@Wario_1 (965)
• Sweden
27 Feb 08
Felt i need to be more precise when it means stopping eachother from getting hurt. Not that friends are safety nets so that no one gets hurt, more that a friend stops you from going or doing something that will hurt you.
Accidents and similar stuff cant be avoided, but drunk driving can be. I hope you understand a little better on how im thinking about this.
2 people like this
@Sissygrl (10912)
• Canada
1 Mar 08
If it my good friend, then i will tell her, listen, this is your life, and you are free to do what you choose, i will support you and stick by you whatever you decide, and please dont be angry with me i'm just tryign to be honest. and then i'd lay it on her and tell her the truth. ;)
2 people like this
@sarahruthbeth22 (43143)
• United States
29 Feb 08
If you know that this girlfriend/boy friend isn't honest, you must tell your friend. I would take them for a walk and then I would say that I love them and you want your friendship to continue and then hell her/him.Don't over bad mouth this person your friend likes.
2 people like this
@cdparazo (5765)
• Philippines
28 Feb 08
I don't really believe that I would loose our friendship if I tell my friend about the boy's wrong deeds. I have experienced just the same thing years ago wherein I told my friend that her boyfriend has been unfaithful to her. However, I would not tell my friend what to do. All I would tell is the truth as I see it and let her decide without telling her what to do. I would let her know that I am with her no matter what and whatever her decisions may be. As friends, we should not dictate the actions of the other, rather, our role should be to lend support at all times. If our friend fall and get broken hearted in the process, we should be there for them to help them pick up the broken pieces.
2 people like this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
28 Feb 08
Hello cdparazo!:-)
I do understand what you are saying here. I have done that before too and initially it ruined things at first and ended up in hot headed argument. Thankfully, something happened and the person in question paused for a moment and then started observing things and with the time came to realization that I was being very honest. Our relationship is much stronger now than what it was before, but it did take a while to settle things down and I feel sorry about that period, I am happy with the end though.
I am kind of a person who can’t support someone ruining him/herself but I can’t leave him/her either ruining him/herself, so can’t sit idle. You are right that we should not dictate but It’s all the way more difficult to do calmly with people you care, where emotions run high and reason can be thrown out easily.
Thank you for your views, cdparazo!:-)
1 person likes this
@youless (112481)
• Guangzhou, China
29 Feb 08
In such kind of situation, I shall not worry about losing the friendship. The most important for me to do is to tell my friend the truth. I hate being cheated. So I don't allow my friend to be cheated, too. Especially it's so hurtful to be cheated in love. If he/she doesn't listen to me, it's not my fault. One day time will prove I am right. If I don't tell him/her the truth, then it's my fault.
@Angelwhispers (8978)
• United States
27 Feb 08
Hey there Sugar, You know it might not be my position or business, but I feel that if you really love a person, you are going to be honest with them. Even if that jeopardizes the friendship. I could not be a real friend if I did not do something to protect that friend from harm. I would lay it out on the table for him/her say my peace then shut up about it unless my friend wanted to talk further. I would not badger or make accusations. There is always the possibility that I do not have the full story myself. Tact is the key here along with sincere reassurance of your best intentions and love for that friend.
2 people like this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
27 Feb 08
Angel, what you are saying is the voice of both my heart and brain. I am a pretty straightforward person and lack a little in tact. I have had an episode a while back (with another person) and it finally ended well but it did cause bitterness for a while.
"There is always the possibility that I do not have the full story myself."
You don't forget to leave your wise signatures, do you?:-)
1 person likes this
@I_LUV_U (2519)
• India
27 Feb 08
This is really tough! I think I will likely not worry too much about our friendship and go tell my friend that his/her GF/BF isn't really the honest person they believe him/her to be.
I understand that this might affect our friendship - but in the long run, my friend will realise the truth and come back to me.
I will try to inform this matter softly, delicately, with emotions attached and in a lonely place where there is not much disturbance.
I feel how and where you convey the truth also plays an equally important role. If you put your point across right away like "Your girl is insincere, she has lied to you all her life, just forget her and move on, she is not worth your love" - then your friend might consider your words to be coming out of jealousy or some other ulterior motive.
I'm pretty sure that if you and your friend understand and listen to each other very well - this method will be successful.
2 people like this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
27 Feb 08
Hello I_LUV_U!:-)
It's so good to see you, my friend!:-)
I am quite a straightforward person but I know that in these circumstances, it can work very negatively and even if my friend realize later that I was honest, the damage would already have been done, which is what I won't like to see.
You are right about environment playing an important role in communication!
"I'm pretty sure that if you and your friend understand and listen to each other very well"
Love can be a very blinding experience, my friend! I just hope to let a blind see. I really appreciate your input here and your words of reason!:-)
1 person likes this
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
28 Feb 08
Hello merjun,
Welcome to mylot, I hope you would be enjoying your experience here!:-)
Sometimes, one does feel like saying, 'do what you want and go to hell' but isn't it really the difficult part of a friendly relationship that you can't just see happening? dilemma is we can't do much either on our own, can we? Yes, friends are there for help, support and hold you up when you are down and I won't turn away someone even if I hated their action in first place. Thanks for your comment anyway!:-)
1 person likes this
@smartsaxo (5)
•
28 Feb 08
It is a rather difficult position to be in, but as friends are always there after any boy or girlfriend, it would always be the right thing to do and warn them of the person in question. Like previously said always use the term i feel and i beleive. Also stress that you will be there to help pick up the pieces when it all goes wrong. There will come a time when they will be grateful u gave them the advice that the person they are in love with is going to harm them.
Tell ur friend that u know its not ur place to tell them what to do or who to se but hat u are concerned that the person they love does not have their best intentions at heart. Tell them that they only reason you are sayiung anything is that you car for them and dont want them to get hurt
@kamran12 (5526)
• Pakistan
28 Feb 08
Hello smartsaxo!
Welcome to mylot, I hope you will enjoy your stay here!:-)
You sound familiar as if we have already talked, may be because what you say sounds my own voice. I appreciate your reasoning and can identify myself with that. Thanks for sharing!:-)
1 person likes this