What kind of sugar substitute do you use?
By catjane
@catjane (1036)
United States
February 28, 2008 8:29am CST
I use splenda. What kind do you use as a diabetic. Do you have a sweet tooth and always are looking for "sugar free" products? I have been able to find many, even pies and cakes. You still hve to worry about the fat content though, especially in chocolate.
4 responses
@dodoguy (1292)
• Australia
28 Feb 08
Hi catjane,
I gather you're a diabetic? Here's some quick thoughts about sweeteners - not intended to please the chemical vendors, but seriously worth considering since it's our health that's at stake...
1. The artificial sweeteners are pretty much all dubious. They discovered that Saccharin caused cancer in lab-rats years ago. Ditto Cyclamate based sweeteners. Both got banned for human consumption as a result, but there's moves afoot to re-approve both (if it hasn't already happened).
2. Aspartame (as used in Nutrasweet) is allegedly a cumulative neurotoxin which has insidious long-term effects.
3. The jury is still out on Sucralose (which is used in Splenda) but you'll find there's some controversy about this sweetener already, based on it's chlorinated structure. If it's anything like all the previous artificial sweeteners, we won't see detrimental effects until people's eyes start falling out or something similar, about 15 years down the track.
4. ALL those artificial sweeteners were approved by the FDA. That's relevant, because there's a certain amount of evidence that each of these substances is not entirely safe - see [ www.sweetpoison.com/aspartame-sweeteners.html ]...
5. The FDA apparently made a concerted effort to ban American access to Stevia, which is a natural herbal sweetener tha is safe for diabetics. I believe that it's only available in the USA now as a "dietary supplement", ie, it's illegal to market it as a "sweetener" (???). From reading on the subject, I get the sense that the FDA is acting to protect the commercial interests of the domestic pharmaceutical and sugar industries.
6. Stevia has been used by indigenous South Americans for centuries, and is used extensively in Japan, Brazil and a few other countries. I have a Stevia bush growing in a pot on my back porch, and the leaves are indeed very sweet.
The bottom line is that there's big bucks in the low-calorie sweetener industry, both for diabetics and for people trying to manage their weight.
So you really can't trust anything the manufacturers (or the FDA) say about them - all they can see is the dollar signs. You MUST do your own research and satisfy yourself that what you're onto is both good for your needs and safe to use.
I'm quite happy to just use plain old sugar, or honey, to sweetne things when I need it. And if I ever need to cater for a diabetic or two, I'll head for the Stevia every time.
But my personal choice is to stay well away from any of the artificial sweeteners on the market - any hint of "artificial" gets those alarm bells ringing.
@catjane (1036)
• United States
28 Feb 08
Dodoguy, you gather correctly lol and thanks for all the good information. More diabetics should know about these artifical sweetners. Maybe I'll switch to real sugar or honey for my cereal. I don't put that much on so what culd it hurt? After all it's just a carbohydrate right!
@dodoguy (1292)
• Australia
28 Feb 08
Hi again catjane,
You're so right!
I imagine it must be very difficult to have to ration something like sugar in one's diet, because the desire for something sweet is so entrenched in our taste buds.
I reckon those people who say we came from orangutans might be onto something. The desire for sweet stuff does suggest that we're supposed to consume a lot of fruit.
@ceciliamilgate (157)
• Australia
5 Mar 08
I use sugarine.type2, Very hard to manage if you have sweet tooth, sometimes my sugar goes up as high 23.6 when its low 1.7 sometimes in my sleep i feel having headache that's when I check and it's so low.I take tablets 3/a day gloucovance and avandia. I'm over weight 20 kilos, my problem lazy to walk n exercise.But I do all housework in the house that keep me so busy and no time for my self.now I'm careful with my food intake.
@catjane (1036)
• United States
5 Mar 08
I'm not sure where you are from so I don't know these numbers you are using. They must be metric? I am type 2 also and have a sweet tooth ever since I quit smoking 8 years ago. Sometimes I eat sugar sometimes I substiute, it all depends on my glucose reading. If you treat sugars as a carbohydrate, you can have some. I hear avandia is very bad for you, please check it out. When my glucose goes low I start to sweat and shake so I take a glucose tablet in and minutes I'm okay. It doesn't happen often, but it can be scary. I take metformin and glyburide.
@calibeachbabe21 (9)
• United States
28 Feb 08
Usually, I try to cut the sugar in 1/4 and use splenda for the remaing part. I love sweets too, and my sugar is not bad enough that I have to cut all of my sugar out... THank Heavens!!!